Never trust a saddle from a "fixie" company.... they are most likely bottom of the barrel hatchets targeted in fruity colors for kiddies.

OP, I think you should consider a second hand or a take off (via your LBS) saddle if you're trying to stretch your dollar.

As far as comfort goes, if it hasn't been mentioned in here already, our bums cannot tell what your bum will like if comfort is what you're looking for in a new saddle.