No offense, but holy facepalm. You are asking people over the internet for advice as to which insole will fit your feet (how would we know?!?), then you will use that as a basis for ordering online, if you can. This is part of the reason that Spesh are so strict on limiting online sales, to try to quash this kind of thing.

I would be more superior, but I went through the same thing last year. I ended up reluctantly going to my local Spesh dealer, and had my feet/ legs assessed. The insoles came with wedges and shims, after a brief fit session he also added a wedge on one side. There was no extra charge, but it was more than just slapping a pair of coloured insoles into my shoe. When one buys Spesh insoles one is paying for fit as much as, if not more than, just the insoles. BTW, I ended up with blue, and I am relatively flat-footed.