Originally Posted by Slow Train
I've been thinking about getting a second bike and was considering the Cannondale fifty-fifty which is equipped with an 8 speed internal hub. But after doing a little bit of research I haved cooled to the idea.
Here is why:
(disclaimer - these are second-hand impressions all formed from reading postings here and elsehwere)
1) Some people report very noisy hubs especialy while in low gears riding up hills. Sometimes described as a coffee can rattling sound.
2) Check Sheldon Browns site. He may be favorably impressed but many worry about durabiilty.
3) Overhauling - many bike shops are lucky if they have one true mechanic. If it needs attention will your mechanic be up to speed?
1) Mine's fine. And if all it is is noise,I don't think I'd worry. You should hear some Harley Sportsters with aftermarket cams.
2) Shimano makes good stuff. I can't see major manufacturers like Cannondale and Bianchi using them if there were serious probs.
3) You can either send it back to Shimano,or work it yourself. There's no way the insides are any worse than a motorcycle transmission. Also,from everything I've read they go a
very long time between overhauls.
I also looked at a 50/50,but couldn't figure out why they put on such monster tires and didn't utilise the integrated rear brake.