Originally Posted by
the sci guy
If you've got $1600 I'd say none of those.
All-City Space Horse is what I'd get.
Back up would be a Surly Cross-Check.
Both have all the mounts for fenders and racks and everything you could want, and can take many different sized tires from narrow to fairly wide.
Both good choices. I really like a number of the All-City bikes and would consider one for a N+1 someday. I would also consider the Straggler if disc brakes are of interest.
Really a lot comes down to what you find comfortable riding regularly, if you want to prioritize comfort or speed, and how "flexible" of a bike do you want.