Thread: Need help!
View Single Post
Old 03-19-15 | 07:00 AM
  #8  
MRT2's Avatar
MRT2
Senior Member
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 6,320
Likes: 218
From: Wisconsin

Bikes: 2012 Salsa Casseroll, 2009 Kona Blast

Originally Posted by Little Darwin
Worth it is so subjective... If you look at retail value, I am sure that themore expensive bike is worth it. The real question is whether the difference is worth $200 to us, your respondents...

In my opinion, Either bike would do fine for your purposes (similar to my own).

One significant factor is 8 vs 10 speed... 8 speeds is plenty (that is all I have ridden for thousands of miles)... and you will actually have a wider gear range with the lower end bike because of the triple front.

Hydraulic versus mechanical disks... Everything I have heard is that hydraulic brakes are better, but you can adjust mechanical with standard tools, and never have to bleed them. Either one of them should stop you fine as long as they are maintained properly.

Any drive train components on bike shop level bikes will perform well enough for most casual riders, although higher end will sometimes feel more precise, and possibly be a touch better at shifting, and usually be lighter and/or polished better.

Bottom bracket is largely irrelevant other than the fact that the type needs to match the cranks used... and since it is a prebuilt bike, I am pretty confident that they will be the right type.

The more expensive bike will probably be slightly lighter than the cheaper bike due to component choices. Probably not enough to be noticeable when cruising, but possible a bit detrimental on climbs, or if you need to pick your bike up to put it away, or on a rack.

If I were picking between these two, I would probably save the $200 and put it toward a nice destination ride later in the year.
Pretty much agree. It is a tough call. In general, 8 speed shifters should be more than enough. If you consult a gear inch calculator, it is pretty clear that both bikes have almost identical wide gear ranges. The more expensive bike is a double, the less expensive one a triple. I have triples on most of my bikes that work well for me, maybe better than a compact double. However, this compact double on the Giant seems really well suited for its task with a 32 tooth small chainring.

As for spending the extra cash, it really depends on how long you own your bikes. I tend to keep my bikes for a long time so an extra $200 up front isn't much if I really liked the more expensive bike better.
MRT2 is offline  
Reply