IMHO? A Step through.. My Brompton is an excellent city bike for the city [ Actually a Small town ], I live In .

Low BB So saddle though High enough to pedal comfortably, still lets Me put a foot down also comfortably at stoplights ..



As to your pictured either Or
Ones a 29er MTB the other a Hybrid , neither have any accessories like mudguards lights and Racks to start to Be Practical in Most cities .