Originally Posted by Clang

I think the main problem with bicyclebluebook is that its quoted price is based more on depreciation rather than local market, and the condition ranking of the bike is rather nebulous. You'll need better and more photos to gauge condition online. Your best bet is to meet with them and ride it. If everything checks out: wheels true, shifts OK, fork operative, I don't think you're getting burned at $250 (but hey, like any craigslist bike, shoot for $200). Good luck!