I hit up 4 bike shops in our small little town today. I rode the following:

- Specialized Sirrus (L) - Felt a little too big
- Trek 7.2 FX (17.5")
- Kona Dew
- Giant Escape 2

I had a hard time discerning the difference between the first 3. All 3 rode nice, smooth, quiet. A great upgrade. The Giant Escape 2 rode nice, however it rattled. I know it was the cables against something, but it would drive me insane.

I am thinking the 7.2 FX is the right bike for me for a commuter. The 7.3 is $150 more, and I am not sure that is necessary since I have a nice road bike.

The salesman was trying to talk me into disc breaks. I have to do some research, but my gut instinct tells me they are not necessary ($100 upcharge on the 7.2). Thoughts?