I also just got back from the LBS with my wife. I am narrowed down to the 7.2 FX. However, I would love for her to get in to cycling, so we had her on several bikes.

She rode the Trek 7.2 FX WSD first. She like how smooth it was and the shifting. She then rod another Trek, I forget the name, with integrated fenders and front basket for $800. She thought it wasn't as nice of a bike, but liked sitting up. She then road a Verve 3. She liked sitting up and found this bike comfortable.

Now, she (we?) are trying to work out the best move. We are on a large hill (~300' over 0.25 mile), so the ability to get up that is important. Ideally she would commute 7 miles, but not sure how feasible it is.

Thoughts on the 7.2 FX vs the Verve 3? It seems she would be more comfortable strolling around town on the Verve, but perhaps the FX would be more appropriate for fitness biking. What do you think would be better for a 7 mile commute with a large hill?

I am aware that the best bike is the one that she will ride the most. She isn't a big cycler, but hasn't owned a bike in modern times.

We were also trying to figure out her appropriate size. One of the LBSs has a 7.2 FX WSD in 13" for $300. However, it is likely a 15" would be more appropriate (damn). But once again, getting the fit right is more important than saving $150.