I disagree. Perhaps it's the word cushioning you're objecting to. I find both the saddle & the shorts play a large role in my comfort. My Selle Italia Superflow SLR has minimal cushioning. It's shape & cutout lead to a more comfortable ride. Couple that saddle with Assos shorts & the comfort of the shorts leads to a very comfortable ride. Change either component & I'm less comfortable. Could all of that job be done by the saddle or shorts alone? Maybe. But who are you to decide for the rest which is the correct component for the job?