I can tell You what saddle I Bought But You will not be sitting on it.. just go out and try something..

Selle Royale makes a bunch of day to day saddles must have sold a lot of them to Buy Out Brooks ,

they also are making the Fizik Lines of saddles ..

Hit the Bike Shops ,, Take Offs are New saddles just taken off when a New Bike Buyer wanted something else

Its not a Peer approval, Popularity thing, Its between your Butt an your saddle

How about a Copy of the Selle Italia Turbo thru Merry/Soma/ sales the TaiBo

or the Crocs Foam PDW saddle , which is waterproof and the plastic is the padding and the covering
so no Pleather cover to tear https://www.ridepdw.com/goods/cockpi...hronous-saddle

neither cost much maybe 3~4:1 Brooks .

Or how about getting one at a charity shop for a Buck, OK SF Bay area thats $5.