Thread: Cycling and ADD
View Single Post
Old 11-28-05 | 09:45 PM
  #32  
Mars's Avatar
Mars
coitus non circum.
 
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,495
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by pharnabazos
An article in Pediatrics about a year ago suggested a direct correlation between childrens' exposure to TV between the ages of 1.5 and 3.5 and then subsequent ADHD at age 7.

They were Danish kids--and only 2% of Danish kids that age watch TV, versus 50% (!) of American kids.

[PEDIATRICS Vol. 113 No. 4 April 2004, pp. 708-713

Early Television Exposure and Subsequent Attentional Problems in Children]
Trouble with correlational studies is that they do not imply causation... which you are. Perhaps kids with AD/HD prefer TV more than other kids?

I'm a psychology professor and did my Ph.D. dissertation on adult AD/HD. To discuss the potential benfits of exercise to a sufferer of AD/HD, you have to remember there are 3 types: AD/HD Hyperative/Impulsive type, AD/HD Inattentive type, and AD/HD Combined type (symptoms of both hyperactivity and inattentiveness). The AD/HD - I type is the least common, and I can't really see how riding a bike would help that much. In both AD/HD-HI and AD/HD-Co the core symptom is believed to be impulsivity. This, in turn, affects a host of executive cognitive functions like memory, rule following, emotional control, and so forth.

A common myth in popular culture is that AD/HD people can't stay focused on things. They can, if it is stimulating enough. For example, many AD/HD people can play video games for hours on end. But see what happens when they have to do something tedious or rote, like writing an essay or listening to a boring lecture. A person with AD/HD might do very well at a bike messenger job (like Treespeed mentioned) because there is lots of variety and stimulation. Put them in a cubilcle doing accounts receivable and they will have a lot of trouble.

There are no known benefits to having AD/HD. People can cope with the disorder by finding activities that suit their need for stimulation and variety. People with AD/HD may enjoy a chaotic and risky environment more than others... but will be more accident prone. Medications help reduce levels of impulsivity and give other executive functions a better chance to kick in. Strenuous exercise provides an outlet for surplus physical energy, some novelty, and is just plain good for you. In other words, I can't think of any way that cycling would be better for AD/HD sufferers than it would for anyone else.

The prevalence rate for AD/HD is not believed to have changed over the years. More people are diagnosed with it now (and many are misdiagnosed with it). Unfortunately, there is a tendency to assume every misbehaved child has AD/HD, and that may not be the case. Correlations with environmental pollutants, birthing complications, and parenting practices exist, but have not proved decisive. Heredity seems to play a big role. By the way diet does not. Special diets like the Fiengold diet have not shown any efect in controlled studies.

Hope this helps answer some questions...
Mars is offline  
Reply