Old 01-25-17 | 02:18 PM
  #9  
alcjphil's Avatar
alcjphil
Senior Member
20 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 6,655
Likes: 2,253
From: Montreal, Quebec
Originally Posted by Facanh
Shimano tried to use the same rear derailleur ratio (SIS), but then came 9-10 speed. They had to decrease the cable pull each time. This got pretty bad on 10spd. 10 speed SIS road systems are very sensitive to setup, or dirty, old cables. They pull very very little cable so everything needs to be very precise.

Shimano then introduced 10 speed on mountain bikes and used an entirely different cable pull and derailleur ratio so the system works overall better, especially in harsh environments. Dyna-Sys. A Dyna-Sys 10 speed mountain shifter pulls more cable than a 6 speed shifter...

When 11 speed came out Shimano changed the derailleur ratio on road stuff too, so the shifters can pull more cable. It works pretty good, but this means no backwards compatibility for SIS rear derailleurs. Later this trickled down to Tiagra 4700 and now Sora R3000. (SRAM with their 1:1 and I think Campagnolo have been doing this for a long time.)

What I don't understand is that why the cable pull and derailleur ratio is not the same on 11spd road and MTB stuff... I know that more cable pull is better for MTB, but I don't see a downside if road stuff used it too. You could mix RDs.

I've heard that people bought Sora R3000 rear derailleurs for older 8-9-10 speed stuff and it did not work.

I know that Tiagra 4700 uses the same derailleur ratio as 11 speed road stuff. Maybe this is the case with R3000 too, I don't know, I only know that it is definitely different than SIS.

A good article about all of this with some useful data (sadly nothing about 4700 or R3000 yet)

Art's Cyclery Blog » Science Behind the Magic | Drivetrain Compatibility
Like you, I am a little perplexed by Shimano's decision to separate cable pull ratios on road and mountain bike derailleurs. Of course it makes no difference to someone riding only road bikes or only mountain bikes, but for people doing something in between, such as touring, it really complicates things. I predict that "9 speed" mountain bike rear derailleurs will become highly sought after items if Shimano ever discontinues production. I am using one on my touring bike currently and I am wondering if I should stockpile another, just in case. I know that Shimano had to change pull ratio in order to advance to 10 speed mountain bike shifting and to 11 speed road shifting, but in a company as big as Shimano I wonder if it was a case of the two hands not talking to each other
alcjphil is offline  
Reply