View Single Post
Old 04-06-23 | 12:41 PM
  #28  
Piff's Avatar
Piff
Senior Member
Titanium Club Membership
10 Anniversary
 
Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 1,966
Likes: 1,137
From: Southern California

Bikes: 1981 Univega Super Special, '80s Custom Chris Pauley, 1972 Fuji 'The Finest'

Originally Posted by Kilroy1988
Well, we're talking from two different perspectives here. I agree entirely that "all steel has the same stiffness" if your measurements are identical. However, I am talking from the perspective of a built frame. The stiffness of the frames I've had - and the advertised utility of a frame - made from 853 has in general been greater than my 531 frames. The inherent strength of the frame material allows that to be accomplished.

Please note that in my initial post you quoted I said a "stiffer frame," not "stiffer steel."

-Gregory
I thought that might've been what you meant, I just wanted to be extra clear for Bad Lag Since they asked (as you noted) a well-trodden question and your response had some assumptions about an 853 frame that he may not be aware of, like how oversize tubing affects stiffness.
Piff is offline  
Reply