Originally Posted by
hsea17
Thanks to both Kontact and Iride01 for the answers. Iride's answer / conclusion below is well in a way what I was looking for and even if it's not a usual road bike position it has functioned for my body proportions. I was a little unsure if the straight seat post would change my position even with the same distances to the seat/handlebar etc.
It's your body proportions and your preferences that determine where your saddle should be.
hsea17
There's more to position than having your knee over the pedal. It is unlikely that you are balanced on the bike being so far forward over the cranks. But I'm glad you got your answer.