Originally Posted by
wheelreason
Sounds like cable tension, limit screw, or both. Rule out the shifter by detaching the cable from the dlr, and going through the clicks while pulling tension manually. Doesn't sound like a hard one.
No, cable tension is fine. It is the shifter that isn't catching. If I pull at the cable it shifts. And it shifts from small to middle no problem. When I took the cover off I could see what was happening, I just couldn't figure out how to fix it, but the lube was thick and sticky so that is likely it. And just by looking at it I could make it work but not consistently.