Honestly, those tests dont really tell me all that much. Its in lab conditions, and only takes into account water vapor diffusion. There is no measurement in there for durability, comfort,price, ergonomics, style, availability, warranty...etc. Its a lab test, and like anything else being "tested" I could show whatever I want. Im an engineering analyst as my profession, and the joke we always say to ourselves is "What answer are you looking for?" when someone comes at us with a problem. Im not saying that isnt a valid water vapor diffusion study... im just saying that if I bought a material strictly based on that test I might not be buying the best thing. (not saying Gore is the best either)

I think you have a lot of valid points, and gore is very pricey. I will say though, it performs better than I ever imagined. I love my trail shoes(Montrail) and they are durable as all hell. I havent had my Orage shell long enough to comment. I have only worn it 2x in fact, but to me... I have already been loving it.