Originally Posted by ranger5oh
Don't people climb Everest in gore-tex? I mean hell... if its good enough for everest, its good enough for my trial and tribulations

Yes, and people climb everest in other materials also. How does that change anything? The jackets are usually sponsor supplied anyways. Its a material that has a 20 year and a billion dollars (just a guess) worth of marketing headstart on others. And threads like these prove that marketing beats real results in the minds of uninformed consumers.