Originally Posted by sers
I have those on my commuter. I'm not a huge fan, although they do the job. They were a total pain in the ass to install. Despite my best efforts, I ended up losing 3 or so of the nuts that secure the fender at the top. Next time I'll probably snag the planet bike ones.
My experience was the opposite. I didn't even have to take the rear wheel off to get the fender installed. And I just have to take the brake off to remove the front fender on nice days. Of course, I may just love it because my old fenders were the world's shattiest.