Originally Posted by lawkd
That is a great article! And it underlines your point very clearly as to why there are some greases that do *not* function well *except* at high temps, therefore (just as Barnett said) they would not be good for bicycle use:
"It is, of course, a good thing that there are greases that function at high temperatures. But it would be wrong to believe that these greases will also function well at low temperatures. On the contrary, they often function very badly. The high temperature greases do not generally release a single drop of oil at low temperatures. In fact the opposite happens, and they absorb the grease that has already been released. This results in the object that is to be lubricated – for example a ball-bearing – drying out. With the increased friction, the temperature rises, oil is released and the bearing is lubricated again: then it cools down and dries out again, resulting in an increased pace of wear and tear on the bearing."
Now, how do we get grease manufacturers to let us know which greases have paraffinic as well as naphthenic oils? Some of them won't even reveal what thickener they use.
Sorry, but can you tell me just what the low temperatures are that are being discussed. Having spent half a winter in Canada, where the maximum day temps can be minus 38 deg C, I can tell you that for autmotive, industrial and mining applications in truly cold weather, I can believe the performance of oils and greases will change when compared with high-temperature environments. But are the normal ambient temperatures that bicycles operate under -- let's say between 0 and 45 deg C, the low temperatures being referred to in the articles and this discussion?.