Originally Posted by ewitz
I think you are right. Having used alu for the last 10 years I can say that the current frames do not resist dings as well as the old ones. While thiese dings will not affect the durability or performance of the frame who wants needs to worry about the cosmetic appearance of the frame every time it is mishandled, whether it is during riding or just getting the bike in and out of the house.
Exactly. I don't want to spend cash on a new bike and worry that when I put it in my garage, it may dent if I lean it against something a bit too hard.
To be clear, I don't believe this frame will ever fail. I'm a Cannondale owner myself and do believe in their product--hence why I would like to buy another one, but the physics behind the technology (i.e. what Phatman said about frame deflection) and the fact that the frame cutout I saw showed my how thin the walls actually are make me wonder about its resistance. I believe even the Cannondale warranty speaks to handing the bike with care as the top tube is prone to dents.
Anyways, thanks all for your input.