Well, I went to Shaker Cycle, Mitch only could find one old crank with the same BCD and it was a lower grade crank. So I ended up buying a new Origin8 track crank. I'll post pics when it's installed. I'm still a little fumed over this whole fiasco, I should've just left the pedals as they were.

edit - The old ugly Fuji crank was $22 and the new Origin8 was $50. I just looked it up and the Origin8 goes for $40-$65, so I think I got a decent deal.