next step in cleaning up my old trek 560 is replacing the handlebar tape. i picked up some yellow bar tape at the lbs but it's kind of foamy and bright neonish yellow, i prefer the more orangey golden yellow tape that was on it and it's more like leather with the grain and perforation. i assume it's not leather but a synthetic of some sort, anybody know what specifically i should look for?

85 trek 560, purple with yellow everything.