Saddles are very subjective. For example, I like the feel of a very hard, very narrow saddle. But also like the feel of a nice leather brooks. Two different worlds. Maybe check out the saddle swap thread in the classifieds. Bt remember to give it a while for your butt to adjust, and the saddle to brake in. The brooks on my fixed gear townie took a good 100+ miles feeling like crap, and very sore taint, now I won't ride on the road with anything else.