Originally Posted by
pillar
Sorry crawdaddio, I should have been more specific.
I am now looking to replace my cable lock and I am debating between getting a cable with an integrated (keyed) lock, or getting a cable with looped ends and a padlock.
I am leaning towards the looped ends + padlock because it seems to be more secure (to my untrained eye) and it would be more versatile, although it is heavier. I look forward to your input, thanks!
Of the two choices, I would recommend the padlock with the caveat that it be a decent hardened, shrouded version. Heavier, yes. Depending on where you are locking up, I would hope that you are using a good U lock in addition to the cable. Ignore me if you live in one of those small, crime free towns. If you just want something lighter and you aren't really at risk of bike theft in your area, the key integrated cable lock will do fine in keeping honest people honest.
I would recommend above either of those options using a good U lock to complete the loops of the cable (or in addition to your padlock) as I pictured above.