Could well be its shape just plain doesn't fit you. Just like most saddles I've tried (in 35 years of riding) don't fit me. And the one that fits me best (Cinelli Unicanitor Mod 50 or 55) provokes expressions of horror from most folks. It's a plain plastic shell, supposedly designed (in the '50s or early '60s) to mimic a well-broken in Brooks, but no Brooks I've ever tried fits as well. Every butt is different.

SP
Bend, OR