zacster

WHY WHY WHY WHY WHY? ? ? ? ? ? ?

Why does that require a special tool? Why isn't it a standard 8 or 10mm allen wrench that everybody already has, or is at least available at a hardware store? Why do I need to buy a tool just for this? It is just a piece of plastic, as is the tool. If it has to be a special tool, why don't they just include one?

I've bought my share of specialized bike tools over the years but as a home mechanic working mostly on my own bikes many if not most don't get used more than once. It's just crazy.

For this one I'm going to improvise, especially since it isn't even supposed to go tight. After all, it is just a plastic piece. I've got some very hard ipe scrap wood that I can chisel to a square that'll fit. Hmmm, I wonder if a square taper spindle would work???

Polaris OBark

You can just stick a wide-blade screwdriver in there and tighten it, or get one of these:




in your favorite color, for $5 on Amazon.

The point of the plastic is to prevent you from cranking it down too much.

HillRider

That plastic tool is intended to limit the torque you apply. The specified torque is 0.7 to 1.5 Nm which is quite low and well within "finger tight" using that plastic tool. BTW, that tool is really cheap so it's not like you are being taken.

A standard 8 or 10mm allen key would allow (or encourage) excessive tightening.

cxwrench

Exactly this. The OP is obviously not a mechanic nor has he paid any attention to the Shimano service instructions.

Andrew R Stewart 

Nor has the OP an understanding to Shimano's marketing methods. Of course they would make a unique tool. Andy

Camilo

I agree with the posts about the tool being designed to be more or less idiot proof. I have one. But the first Hollowtech crank I installed was before I got the tool. I just took a small/fine-bladed needle nose pliers and spread it against the fastener to tighten it. I read the installation instructions so I understood it should be about finger tight and did so.

Polaris OBark

The OP makes it clear that the requirement for minimal torque is in fact understood. The question raised, as I understand it, is why the non-standard tool (which we all answered), and, in the absence of having that over-priced bit of plastic, how something can be improvised (which some of us answered).

zacster

You are all mostly missing the point. Why design something that needs a special tool if you’re not going to include it? Even IKEA includes them. Why even design it so it needs a tool at all? You could make it so you can turn it with your fingers, just knurl the edge and have it protrude. The one in the pic looks about right, except leave off the hex slot if you don’t want it torqued.

And before you make assumptions about someone’s misunderstanding of written instructions, how about you try to read what was written in the first place.

I did find something that fits it that won’t be able to torque it. Just hand tight.

This is a truly dumb design of what should be a simple piece of plastic.

Andrew R Stewart 

If one were to redesign the draw/preload bolt (that plastic threaded thing we are talking about) please don't have it stick out past the crankarm's surface. There's a reason why crank arm dust caps have been flush (or very nearly so) with the arm's surface, for many decades. But the best way to figure out what works better is to make a version and then pass it around to others to get their feedback. I am sure many here would look forward to being part of the testing phase

I'll add just because I understand and have learned to deal with Shimano's designs and business/product philosophy doesn't mean I like it better than other companies way of design or marketing. I do respect what the big S has done though. Andy

Iride01 

It's not a big deal. You can with a little effort push the crank arms on far enough to engage the stopper plate with your own hands. At least I have been able too.

The only purpose of the fancy named pre-load adjustment tool is to get the crank arms on the spindle at the proper depth to let the stopper plate engage the notch in the spindle.

There are all sorts of tools listed in the Shimano documents for the components on my bike. I frequently get by without most of them. Why does this one upset you so much?

leob1

I did the same thing, it was easier using the 'special tool', but using an alternative method worked just as well.

dedhed

You can buy the $25 one.

​​​​​​https://www.abbeybiketools.com/produ...=8648382546037

alcjphil

I have a Park tool BBT 9 which includes the tool for bearing preload

jimc101

HT2 has been out for almost 20 years now and the tool for the crank pre-load hasn't changed since it was introduced, could understand an issue if Shimano changed the spec every few years, but they haven't, the only change in HT2 since it's introduction has been the size of higher end bottom brackets (smaller shell size), and when these changed (not bought one recently, so unsure if they still do) the retail packaged BB's came with an adaptor to if the older tools.

As you need a tool to fit the BB's as alcjphil notes, the Park BBT9 is an all in one which includes the BB and crank tool.

zacster

My first choice of improvised tool didn't work well, my thumb. In the end I used the rear end of a plastic tire lever and it was fine. I tightened it more than I knew was necessary to see how that felt, then loosened and freed the arm and did it again the proper way. I checked the feel and then checked for any play and everything spins freely with no play. Since it is a plastic cap you can't tighten it too much anyway. I don't understand why a knurled edge isn't just put on it so you can do it by hand. I already had the tool in my cart but didn't need it anyway. I also improvised the bearing press for the BB bearings, a long bolt, a few large washers and a nut to tighten. That also worked fine.

Racing Dan

Im sure they didnt put in a 12mm hex to prevent a ham fist from "pre loading" the bearings into oblivion. It only needs snugging up to take out side to side play. You will load the bearings plenty as you pedal.

alcjphil

Think about this: If there was a knurled edge that projected above the edge of the center of the crank arm it could easily come into contact with your ankle as you pedal. No manufacturer would ever accept such a design, especially if it were to be sold in the USA. It could bankrupt them. No component manufacturer has ever done this for very good reason

zacster

Wait, what? A plastic knurled edge flush with the arm is a hazard? GMAFB. Just look at the pic above of that after-market cap, and I wouldn't even have it protrude that much, nor would I make it 7075 Al, just plastic. And even further, the pinch bolts are what hold it on, the cap is just to adjust the preload. Get rid of it altogether. Make the cap a tool to adjust the preload that comes off and stays off and just include it with the crank. And this brings me back to my first point, why not just include the plastic tool? It is a cheap piece of plastic.

It may be a 20 year old design, but it is a pretty poor one.

Andrew R Stewart 

zacster- I think you now have a project to do. Design and make (3D print, machine your choice) a replacement draw bolt. Please report back to us after you have some real world testing/use. Andy

jccaclimber

The official Shimano tool for this is all of $5, or if you want to get it from Jeff Bezos in which case it’s less than $7. I think one even came with one of my cranks, though that would have been ~10 years ago.

Should it probably be a common thing like a 6 mm allen? Yes. Can it be improvised with common toolbox items? Yes. Do I use a torque wrench with that particular plastic screw? No.

cxwrench

It's obvious you don't have much experience with this system. The crank arm won't stay on if the plastic preload adjuster isn't installed. That is precisely why Shimano added the stopper plate/pin to the design, it didn't exist the first couple of years of HTll. The crank axle isn't tapered at all, just splined. You use the adjuster to pull the crank arm on and create the proper preload. You then tighten the crank arm bolts to the specified torque, this tightens the axle around the adjuster so it won't loosen up. The preload adjuster backs up the crank bolts, the crank bolts back up the adjuster. The tool was included with cranks for years, I guess Shimano now thinks there are so many around they don't need to make them anymore. There are also lots of aftermarket tools.

theblackbullet

The majority of people using these cranks don't install the crank themselves, and the majority of people installing these cranks already have the tool. As already stated a non-specialized interface ie: 8mm allen would encourage over torqueing for those who don't know what they're doing.

gkamieneski

I don’t work on HTII cranks all that often. I do have one but mainly Campagnolo. But I do think the preload tool is doing more than pushing the crank on far enough to secure the retention device. I always thought the preload was, well, preloading the bearings before the crank arm is secured.

veganbikes

I haven't had any issues getting a tool and using it. This isn't rocket appliances here. The Shimano tool is cheap and you can get an even nicer tool and spend a little more and that is fine as well. 8 bucks for a tool you rarely use is not a huge investment and if that is too much for you then maybe tools aren't your jam. Or maybe don't buy Shimano HT2 Cranks!

I like the proprietary tool in this part because it makes it hard to over tighten. This is bearing pre-load it is rather important it is not an Ikea shelf here it is a fairly expensive part and very important to install properly. A lot of folks don't want to install these parts themselves and don't need a tool and those who do want to install it could easily get that tool and will learn how to use it somehow either through various videos or reading the Shimano manual. You give someone a 8-10mm tool they will use it and crank down on a fastener that doesn't require that and a little 3mm hole would be rather silly and probably would still wind up with striped fasteners in some way. That $8 tool helps prevent that is easy to acquire and at the end any good shop will have one and is also happy to do the work for you if you don't wish to to do it or don't want to buy a tool.

cpach

I'll agree that this is both a kind of annoying design choice and is also not really that big of a deal. I liked the design of some older FSA cranks that were basically HTII cross compatible that used a 5mm hex tooling on the preload bolt, and included a small plastic tool you were supposed to use to prevent over torquing. The danger of course is that it's easy to overtorque them with a normal 5mm wrench if you're an idiot. At least Shimano has stuck with this design for a while.