Classic and Vintage Sturmey Archer vs Modern Competitors
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2009
Posts: 141
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Classic and Vintage Sturmey Archer vs Modern Competitors
Just wondering if anyone has analyzed the costs/benefits of a modern IGH versus a vintage one. Pros/cons, etc.
Thanks so much.
John
Thanks so much.
John
#2
Wood
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Beaumont, Tx
Posts: 2,293
Bikes: Raleigh Sports: hers. Vianelli Professional & Bridgestone 300: mine
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 8 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 12 Times
in
10 Posts
There are just so many vintage ones around for next to nothing, unless you want the 8 speeds, it hardly makes sense to go new.
You can get 3 speed with coaster for around $45 used, and $63 new, that is the best comparison for something a little hard to come by. But $10 used and $60 new is a stretch.
The 8 speeds go for around $135 at best, w/o the shifter.
You can get 3 speed with coaster for around $45 used, and $63 new, that is the best comparison for something a little hard to come by. But $10 used and $60 new is a stretch.
The 8 speeds go for around $135 at best, w/o the shifter.
#3
Rustbelt Rider
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Canton, OH
Posts: 9,104
Bikes: 1990 Trek 1420 - 1978 Raleigh Professional - 1973 Schwinn Collegiate - 1974 Schwinn Suburban
Mentioned: 20 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 261 Post(s)
Liked 372 Times
in
177 Posts
I am under the impression that most modern hubs don't require oil, because they are greased and sealed at the factory. If that is correct, it could be a pro or con depending on your perspective.
__________________
|^^^^^^^^^^^^^^| ||
|......GO.BROWNS........| ||'|";, ___.
|_..._..._______===|=||_|__|..., ] -
"(@)'(@)"""''"**|(@)(@)*****''(@)
|^^^^^^^^^^^^^^| ||
|......GO.BROWNS........| ||'|";, ___.
|_..._..._______===|=||_|__|..., ] -
"(@)'(@)"""''"**|(@)(@)*****''(@)
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Pinole, CA, USA
Posts: 17,392
Mentioned: 24 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 443 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 27 Times
in
25 Posts
The new SRF3 hub doesn't require oil and doesn't leak. It has a beautiful aluminum shell with thick flanges that don't require spoke washers. It has no neutral between second and third. I paid $53 for mine. I haven't found any $10 AWs, but if I did, how would I know if they were in good shape or in need of repairs?
Invisible wheel shot of my hub:
Invisible wheel shot of my hub:
#9
Membership Not Required
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: On the road-USA
Posts: 16,855
Bikes: Giant Excursion, Raleigh Sports, Raleigh R.S.W. Compact, Motobecane? and about 20 more! OMG
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 70 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 15 Times
in
14 Posts
Modern hubs quite often have better spacing of the gear steps than the old AW Sturmey Archer. I am not sure that the non oil bath hubs are an improvement. We will know in about 40 years after they have seen some service. I know the old AW is all but bullet proof, biggest two issues with it being the neutral between 2nd and 3rd and the steps between the gears. Other than those two quirks the hubs apparently will last forever with minimal maintenance. I have one with somewhere around 30,000 miles on it. When I tore it down to re-grease the bearings the only "issue" I found was a couple of weak pawl springs. The insides were clean and ready to go some more. FWIW that particular hub has been in my possession since 1982 and is probably a 1971 hub (no date). When the bike was in regular use it got a small squirt of oil in the hub every couple of weeks. Somehow I don't think the modern hubs will be able to do that with their sealed systems. I believe that the Shimano Alfine is supposed to be torn down and dipped in oil occasionally.
Aaron
Aaron
__________________
Webshots is bailing out, if you find any of my posts with corrupt picture files and want to see them corrected please let me know. :(
ISO: A late 1980's Giant Iguana MTB frameset (or complete bike) 23" Red with yellow graphics.
"Cycling should be a way of life, not a hobby.
RIDE, YOU FOOL, RIDE!"_Nicodemus
"Steel: nearly a thousand years of metallurgical development
Aluminum: barely a hundred
Which one would you rather have under your butt at 30mph?"_krazygluon
Webshots is bailing out, if you find any of my posts with corrupt picture files and want to see them corrected please let me know. :(
ISO: A late 1980's Giant Iguana MTB frameset (or complete bike) 23" Red with yellow graphics.
"Cycling should be a way of life, not a hobby.
RIDE, YOU FOOL, RIDE!"_Nicodemus
"Steel: nearly a thousand years of metallurgical development
Aluminum: barely a hundred
Which one would you rather have under your butt at 30mph?"_krazygluon
#10
afraid of whales
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Front Range, CO
Posts: 4,306
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 347 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 5 Times
in
5 Posts
I have both and find each has it's place. For a modern commuter, the SRAM i9 is very nice. For an off road or all weather bike, the Alfine is great. I just ordered an old school 5 speed SA hub for a new project, I wanted some retro. No experience with the Rohloff, the new Shimano and SRAM products have their moments so the real benefit is the extra gears. I still have to take care when shifting to let up slightly, otherwise the hub gets stuck or shifts to a different gear than the one I'm selecting.
wrt oil bath, I've switched one of my Alfines, the Nexus and my i9 to oil bath. The oil bath improves shifting performance and the coast down performance is better.
I agree, if you're looking for a project, the old SA hubs on the 'bay look tempting, better be prepared to learn how to tear one down. For $53, the new version is a bargin.
wrt oil bath, I've switched one of my Alfines, the Nexus and my i9 to oil bath. The oil bath improves shifting performance and the coast down performance is better.
I haven't found any $10 AWs, but if I did, how would I know if they were in good shape or in need of repairs?
#11
Palmer
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Parts Unknown
Posts: 8,621
Bikes: Mike Melton custom, Alex Moulton AM, Dahon Curl
Mentioned: 37 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1663 Post(s)
Liked 1,817 Times
in
1,057 Posts
Comparing like-to-like, i.e. three-speeds, today's Sturmey AW-NIG family (SRF3, etc.) has exactly the same gear spacing as the old AW which hit the market in the late 1930s. The SRAM iM3 and T3 hubs have the same gear spacing as the old Sachs Torpedo 3s dating back for a half century or more.
These aren't your grandfather's three speed hubs, though. The SunRace built -NIG hubs actually have quite a number of internal improvements vis-a-vis the old British models. The SRAM iM3 shifts instantly under moderate pedal pressure, has a simple and nicely thought out cable attach/detach, and one model will accept a std 6-bolt brake disc. The coaster brake iM3 model uses roller actuation. The Shimano SG-3D55 has an alluminum shell, a roller clutch instead of a ratchet style freewheel, and will accept a center mount disc.
tcs
Last edited by tcs; 10-15-09 at 07:14 AM.
#12
Palmer
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Parts Unknown
Posts: 8,621
Bikes: Mike Melton custom, Alex Moulton AM, Dahon Curl
Mentioned: 37 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1663 Post(s)
Liked 1,817 Times
in
1,057 Posts
With seven or more gears, definitely go modern. The Sachs 12 speed was a boat anchor that nearly sunk the company. Sturmey's seven speed and first generation 8 speed - the last of the British designs - had issues. Shimano's first generation seven speed was delicate and short lived.
tcs
tcs
#13
Reeks of aged cotton duck
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Middle Georgia, USA
Posts: 1,176
Bikes: 2008 Kogswell PR mkII, 1976 Raleigh Professional, 1996 Serotta Atlanta, 1984 Trek 520, 1979 Raleigh Comp GS
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 5 Times
in
4 Posts
I recently bought a very clean Schwinn Collegiate 3 speed for $30... kept the hub and shifter... and by the time I parted it out I was about $10 ahead. So it was as if someone gave me a clean AW hub and $10!
Plus I love to tinker with stuff... and even though I don't mind tearing into a hub, most of the time I find a rebuild unnecessary. A wipe down and a couple of squirts of oil and you're good to go.
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Mississippi Coast
Posts: 812
Bikes: 198? Raleigh Technium 480, 1970 Raleigh Sports, Motobecane Nomade Sprint
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
I've only ridden classic SA hubs and I like them. But price is a big factor for me and it's WAY cheaper to find an old bike with one than to buy one. When you factor in having a shop build the wheel even a free hub is going to cost you a decent amount to make into a wheel. If you're confident that you can build it yourself then that's a different story, but I don't think there are that many people that would be confident in building their own wheel.
Another reason I prefer the classic hubs is the shifter. I really like the classic SA trigger shifter. Maybe it was a bad experience with twist shifters, but I just don't like them and I think all of the 7+ speed hubs use the twist shifters.
Another reason I prefer the classic hubs is the shifter. I really like the classic SA trigger shifter. Maybe it was a bad experience with twist shifters, but I just don't like them and I think all of the 7+ speed hubs use the twist shifters.
#15
On the road
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: New England
Posts: 2,171
Bikes: Old Schwinns and old Raleighs
Mentioned: 35 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 373 Post(s)
Liked 847 Times
in
323 Posts
I'm especially fond of the AW when equipped with a 22 tooth cog. I have several AWs around and all of them work wonderfully after just a minor clean up and re-oil. If I were to buy a three speed hub, the traditional AW would be it.
On the other hand, if I wanted more gears I'd go with a modern internal gear hub. I like the looks of the Sachs and Rohloff hubs. The new Sturmey Archer offerings also seem like they'd be nice. I guess I'd give any of those a try. I'm not crazy about Shimano ones simply because I'm not crazy about Shimano parts in general. Some of the worst parts failures I've had on bicycles came from brand new Shimano stuff.
I prefer internal gear hubs to any derailleur system.
On the other hand, if I wanted more gears I'd go with a modern internal gear hub. I like the looks of the Sachs and Rohloff hubs. The new Sturmey Archer offerings also seem like they'd be nice. I guess I'd give any of those a try. I'm not crazy about Shimano ones simply because I'm not crazy about Shimano parts in general. Some of the worst parts failures I've had on bicycles came from brand new Shimano stuff.
I prefer internal gear hubs to any derailleur system.
__________________
Classic American and British Roadsters, Utility Bikes, and Sporting Bikes (1935-1979):
https://bikeshedva.blogspot.com/
Classic American and British Roadsters, Utility Bikes, and Sporting Bikes (1935-1979):
https://bikeshedva.blogspot.com/
#16
Senior Member
The new SRF3 hub doesn't require oil and doesn't leak. It has a beautiful aluminum shell with thick flanges that don't require spoke washers. It has no neutral between second and third. I paid $53 for mine. I haven't found any $10 AWs, but if I did, how would I know if they were in good shape or in need of repairs?
Invisible wheel shot of my hub:
Invisible wheel shot of my hub:
#17
multimodal commuter
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: NJ, NYC, LI
Posts: 19,808
Bikes: 1940s Fothergill, 1959 Allegro Special, 1963? Claud Butler Olympic Sprint, Lambert 'Clubman', 1974 Fuji "the Ace", 1976 Holdsworth 650b conversion rando bike, 1983 Trek 720 tourer, 1984 Counterpoint Opus II, 1993 Basso Gap, 2010 Downtube 8h, and...
Mentioned: 584 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1908 Post(s)
Liked 574 Times
in
339 Posts
Well, I do most of my riding on a folding bike with the new SA 8 hub, and it is the nicest shifting hub I've used. The gears are spaced very nicely; nicer than on the Shimano 8 speed hub. I wouldn't recommend the SA 8 for a bike with big wheels, though; the way it's geared, you'd have to use a tiny little chain ring, and it would look very strange. There's no way you could use one with an old Raleigh cottered crank.
The thing about the 8sp hub is that it totally changes the way you ride a bike. On my folding bike, my pedaling cadence is extremely constant, like typically within 5% of 100 rpm. This makes the steps between the gears of the AW feel very big to me. Don't get me wrong, I'm not complaining about the AW; it's just a different riding experience, that's all.
The thing about the 8sp hub is that it totally changes the way you ride a bike. On my folding bike, my pedaling cadence is extremely constant, like typically within 5% of 100 rpm. This makes the steps between the gears of the AW feel very big to me. Don't get me wrong, I'm not complaining about the AW; it's just a different riding experience, that's all.
#18
On the road
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: New England
Posts: 2,171
Bikes: Old Schwinns and old Raleighs
Mentioned: 35 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 373 Post(s)
Liked 847 Times
in
323 Posts
Well, I do most of my riding on a folding bike with the new SA 8 hub, and it is the nicest shifting hub I've used. The gears are spaced very nicely; nicer than on the Shimano 8 speed hub. I wouldn't recommend the SA 8 for a bike with big wheels, though; the way it's geared, you'd have to use a tiny little chain ring, and it would look very strange. There's no way you could use one with an old Raleigh cottered crank.
The thing about the 8sp hub is that it totally changes the way you ride a bike. On my folding bike, my pedaling cadence is extremely constant, like typically within 5% of 100 rpm. This makes the steps between the gears of the AW feel very big to me. Don't get me wrong, I'm not complaining about the AW; it's just a different riding experience, that's all.
The thing about the 8sp hub is that it totally changes the way you ride a bike. On my folding bike, my pedaling cadence is extremely constant, like typically within 5% of 100 rpm. This makes the steps between the gears of the AW feel very big to me. Don't get me wrong, I'm not complaining about the AW; it's just a different riding experience, that's all.
__________________
Classic American and British Roadsters, Utility Bikes, and Sporting Bikes (1935-1979):
https://bikeshedva.blogspot.com/
Classic American and British Roadsters, Utility Bikes, and Sporting Bikes (1935-1979):
https://bikeshedva.blogspot.com/
#19
Palmer
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Parts Unknown
Posts: 8,621
Bikes: Mike Melton custom, Alex Moulton AM, Dahon Curl
Mentioned: 37 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1663 Post(s)
Liked 1,817 Times
in
1,057 Posts
I really like the classic SA trigger shifter.
Maybe it was a bad experience with twist shifters, but I just don't like them and I think all of the 7+ speed hubs use the twist shifters.
HTH,
tcs
#20
Palmer
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Parts Unknown
Posts: 8,621
Bikes: Mike Melton custom, Alex Moulton AM, Dahon Curl
Mentioned: 37 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1663 Post(s)
Liked 1,817 Times
in
1,057 Posts
I surveyed 120 new models of Trek adult bicycle; 89 of them had from the factory "tiny little chainrings" that would produce a mainstream gear range with an SA8 hub.
Yes, these "tiny little chainrings" were the inner ring of a triple crank; still, I have to conclude small chainrings are common items and have wide acceptance in today's bike market.
tcs
#21
Palmer
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Parts Unknown
Posts: 8,621
Bikes: Mike Melton custom, Alex Moulton AM, Dahon Curl
Mentioned: 37 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1663 Post(s)
Liked 1,817 Times
in
1,057 Posts
#22
afraid of whales
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Front Range, CO
Posts: 4,306
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 347 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 5 Times
in
5 Posts
Having experience with the Alfine and the i9, I have to say the Alfine is much more robust. The i9 needs a new dustcap on every overhaul, except they aren't available yet. The Alfine shifts buttery smooth, the i9 shifts like the old SA AW hub, clunk. Even gear steps and discount pricing are the only way the i9 can compete against an Alfine.
#23
multimodal commuter
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: NJ, NYC, LI
Posts: 19,808
Bikes: 1940s Fothergill, 1959 Allegro Special, 1963? Claud Butler Olympic Sprint, Lambert 'Clubman', 1974 Fuji "the Ace", 1976 Holdsworth 650b conversion rando bike, 1983 Trek 720 tourer, 1984 Counterpoint Opus II, 1993 Basso Gap, 2010 Downtube 8h, and...
Mentioned: 584 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1908 Post(s)
Liked 574 Times
in
339 Posts
True, but if you're talking about updating an old bike, such as an old English three speed bike with a 46T chain wheel, you are up against limitations: changing the crank is not practical; you have to get the gearing right by finding the right cog for the rear, and the options are somewhat limited.
#24
Senior Member
not to mention that sturmey archer recommended against gearing an AW too low because of the risk of it tearing itself to shreds from the extra torque. i think they recommended no larger than a 22T cog with a 46T chain ring.
#25
multimodal commuter
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: NJ, NYC, LI
Posts: 19,808
Bikes: 1940s Fothergill, 1959 Allegro Special, 1963? Claud Butler Olympic Sprint, Lambert 'Clubman', 1974 Fuji "the Ace", 1976 Holdsworth 650b conversion rando bike, 1983 Trek 720 tourer, 1984 Counterpoint Opus II, 1993 Basso Gap, 2010 Downtube 8h, and...
Mentioned: 584 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1908 Post(s)
Liked 574 Times
in
339 Posts
Ah, that would explain why they didn't make 'em!