Go Back  Bike Forums > Bike Forums > Classic & Vintage
Reload this Page >

Why is titanium controversial?

Search
Notices
Classic & Vintage This forum is to discuss the many aspects of classic and vintage bicycles, including musclebikes, lightweights, middleweights, hi-wheelers, bone-shakers, safety bikes and much more.

Why is titanium controversial?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 10-30-12 | 06:40 PM
  #101  
Jseis's Avatar
Other Worldly Member
Titanium Club Membership
10 Anniversary
 
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 1,540
Likes: 139
From: The old Northwest Coast.

Bikes: 1973 Motobecane Grand Jubilee, 1981 Centurion Super LeMans, 2010 Gary Fisher Wahoo, 2003 Colnago Dream Lux, 2014 Giant Defy 1, 2015 Framed Bikes Minnesota 3.0, several older family Treks

A straight bar Ti cross disc with a few rack lugs would be my ultimate for sneaking off on the logging roads and taking "short cuts" of a week or so, then back on the tarmac for cheese burger and fries.
__________________
Make ******* Grate Cheese Again
Jseis is offline  
Reply
Old 10-30-12 | 09:13 PM
  #102  
1 Lugnut's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 577
Likes: 115
From: S.F. Bay Area

Bikes: Motobecane Grand Record, Colnago Super, Mondia Super, Mondia Special, Mondia Prestige (for sale 55cm),Titan Star, Titan Exklusiv, Windsor

Originally Posted by cehowardGS

Bad A** ....
1 Lugnut is offline  
Reply
Old 10-31-12 | 09:38 AM
  #103  
Collector of Useless Info
 
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 1,404
Likes: 5
Originally Posted by DVC45
More like a BF NWT is what I have in mind. But, yes, R20 Ti would be very nice too.
Minor thread hijack, but I'd like a folding titanium Brompton-like bike from UFB:

https://www.ufbusa.com/Ultimate_Foldi...Home_Page.html

Too bad they quit development.
cycle_maven is offline  
Reply
Old 11-06-12 | 12:20 AM
  #104  
Senior Member
 
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 1,511
Likes: 7
From: Boulder County, CO

Bikes: '92 22" Cannondale M2000, '92 Cannondale R1000 Tandem, another modern Canndondale tandem, Two Holy Grail '86 Cannondale ST800s 27" (68.5cm) Touring bike w/Superbe Pro components and Phil Wood hubs. A bunch of other 27" ST frames & bikes.

Originally Posted by aroundoz
I think some frame builders don't like titanium because they are not skilled enough to work with it.

When I bought my custom Co-motion in 2003, they claimed their aluminum road bike frame, the Ristretto, was better than a titanium bike. I had to check their site and they have removed that sentence.
That is it in a nutshell. Back in the day of vintage lightweights many steel makes were making a killing selling cheap steel tubing as thousand dollar "framesets" as value added. The punchline being that anyone can learn to build a very nice steel frame in about two days. If you let someone build for a year, you'd be hardpressed to tell their frames apart from the acknowledged master builders if examples of both were stripped and repainted, and the bikes were dressed with identical neutral components.

In reality most people like the fit and finish of a custom hand crafted steel bike, but like their Joe Bell paint job even more. What is true, and was back in the day, is that the technical competence required to weld aluminum and titanium can't even be seriously compared to what is required to work with steel. You can learn to lug a steel bike in an afternoon, if someone competent shows you. You can learn to lay a TIG bead on a steel bike in about a week.

If you can weld aluminum or titanium competently you are making near six figures working for a defense contractor (not building bikes), and you are near the pinnacle of your craft.

Back in the day, when the likes of Masi were relocating to the US to cash in on the bike boom, aluminum bikes from Cannondale and Klein were lighter, stronger, stiffer and faster than anything the steel boys had, or reasonably could come up with. When you can't compete on product you compete on misinformation. The bike industry geared up to castigate rumors of Cannondales being "too stiff."

The funny thing is that some of these preposterous rumors endure. We all know someone who has a Quintana Roo hanging in their garage with some torture device of a solid carbon shell TT "saddle" adorned on it. That cyclist will boast of how the near 100g "saddle" saves him seconds on the bike portion of his Tri. The funny thing is that same cyclist has a custom steel build that he boasts is more "comfortable" than anything else he has ever ridden. He believes it too.

Truth is that a vintage Klein or Cannondale from that era is STILL a freakin' phenomenal rocket bike. Veritable craigslist race bikes if built up with modern carbon fork, wheels and components. No the steel makers of the world were NOT going to survive selling people snake oil with a Colnago sticker on it any longer.

Titanium is more interesting for singles. You can make an epic bike out of ti. It is durable, comfortable, and can almost be built to be as great of a climber as an aluminum bike, and can almost be built to be as effective in a sprint. However, while you want to race on aluminum, you want to take that once in a lifetime bike vacation on your titanium bike. It doesn't need to climb as effectively, it doesn't need to purely accelerate. There is more to a great bike than just pure speed, and pure efficacy of translated energy.

However, some hack master builder can't work with titanium because in reality he isn't really a tenth the craftsman he purports to be, so titanium gets shortchanged a lot. To me it is idiocy to build a custom bike out of steel. That is like having a custom engagement ring setting designed to display a lump of coal.

Titanium always builds a better bike than steel. ALWAYS.

As for tandems, while titanium makes great singles, it is very hard to build a good titanium tandem. There are just too many limitations on the available tubesets. If you talk to someone who has a 68cm or larger custom titanium single, odds are you know someone who sold it for pennies on the dollar. They hated it. It was noodly like wet spaghetti and they were completely disappointed in the ride characteristics. Big powerful cyclists on big bikes with big triangles embarass steel and titanium frames. However, even little cyclists on tandems can stress a tandem frame beyond the material's build range.

Nothing is as disappointing on a tandem as a flexy inefficient frame. Lateral frame stiffness is required on a tandem. Quite simply you can always build a better tandem out of epoxy or aluminum than titanium. We won't mention steel. There is no such thing as a quality steel tandem. These are price point bikes even if they have a Santana or Co-Motion sticker on them.
mtnbke is offline  
Reply
Old 11-07-12 | 11:19 PM
  #105  
CMC SanDiego's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 745
Likes: 9
From: San Diego

Bikes: Too many to list, all titanium or steel.

Originally Posted by jet sanchEz
I had a chance to buy an older Litespeed but changed my mind when I heard about flex issues around the BB when Ti is used. Is this just one of those "schoolyard rumours" or is such a thing well-known?
Titanium does seem to give a little more than steel, and much more than aluminum, which is why they typically use larger tubes for the down tube (kind of like modern steel tandem tubes) it makes the bottom bracket more rigid and you feel less flex when you pedal. I've ridden a Ti bike that was built with a single size of tubing (it looked equvalent to OS tubing in diameter) and that bike felt a little "whippy" when you stood up to pedal. I think the more you weigh the more likely you are to feel the flex as well.
I like a bike made of titanium with a carbon fork for my longer rides, just because its so comfortable. I like the feel of steel almost as much, but find my hands and arms are more prone to tingling/going to sleep perhaps because of road vibrations. I've yet to put a carbon fork on any of my steel bikes so I'm not sure if that is the difference.

CMC
CMC SanDiego is offline  
Reply
Old 11-07-12 | 11:31 PM
  #106  
kaliayev's Avatar
Gouge Away
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 984
Likes: 12
From: BFOH
Originally Posted by mtnbke
That is it in a nutshell. Back in the day of vintage lightweights many steel makes were making a killing selling cheap steel tubing as thousand dollar "framesets" as value added. The punchline being that anyone can learn to build a very nice steel frame in about two days. If you let someone build for a year, you'd be hardpressed to tell their frames apart from the acknowledged master builders if examples of both were stripped and repainted, and the bikes were dressed with identical neutral components.

In reality most people like the fit and finish of a custom hand crafted steel bike, but like their Joe Bell paint job even more. What is true, and was back in the day, is that the technical competence required to weld aluminum and titanium can't even be seriously compared to what is required to work with steel. You can learn to lug a steel bike in an afternoon, if someone competent shows you. You can learn to lay a TIG bead on a steel bike in about a week.

If you can weld aluminum or titanium competently you are making near six figures working for a defense contractor (not building bikes), and you are near the pinnacle of your craft.

Back in the day, when the likes of Masi were relocating to the US to cash in on the bike boom, aluminum bikes from Cannondale and Klein were lighter, stronger, stiffer and faster than anything the steel boys had, or reasonably could come up with. When you can't compete on product you compete on misinformation. The bike industry geared up to castigate rumors of Cannondales being "too stiff."

The funny thing is that some of these preposterous rumors endure. We all know someone who has a Quintana Roo hanging in their garage with some torture device of a solid carbon shell TT "saddle" adorned on it. That cyclist will boast of how the near 100g "saddle" saves him seconds on the bike portion of his Tri. The funny thing is that same cyclist has a custom steel build that he boasts is more "comfortable" than anything else he has ever ridden. He believes it too.

Truth is that a vintage Klein or Cannondale from that era is STILL a freakin' phenomenal rocket bike. Veritable craigslist race bikes if built up with modern carbon fork, wheels and components. No the steel makers of the world were NOT going to survive selling people snake oil with a Colnago sticker on it any longer.

Titanium is more interesting for singles. You can make an epic bike out of ti. It is durable, comfortable, and can almost be built to be as great of a climber as an aluminum bike, and can almost be built to be as effective in a sprint. However, while you want to race on aluminum, you want to take that once in a lifetime bike vacation on your titanium bike. It doesn't need to climb as effectively, it doesn't need to purely accelerate. There is more to a great bike than just pure speed, and pure efficacy of translated energy.

However, some hack master builder can't work with titanium because in reality he isn't really a tenth the craftsman he purports to be, so titanium gets shortchanged a lot. To me it is idiocy to build a custom bike out of steel. That is like having a custom engagement ring setting designed to display a lump of coal.

Titanium always builds a better bike than steel. ALWAYS.

As for tandems, while titanium makes great singles, it is very hard to build a good titanium tandem. There are just too many limitations on the available tubesets. If you talk to someone who has a 68cm or larger custom titanium single, odds are you know someone who sold it for pennies on the dollar. They hated it. It was noodly like wet spaghetti and they were completely disappointed in the ride characteristics. Big powerful cyclists on big bikes with big triangles embarass steel and titanium frames. However, even little cyclists on tandems can stress a tandem frame beyond the material's build range.

Nothing is as disappointing on a tandem as a flexy inefficient frame. Lateral frame stiffness is required on a tandem. Quite simply you can always build a better tandem out of epoxy or aluminum than titanium. We won't mention steel. There is no such thing as a quality steel tandem. These are price point bikes even if they have a Santana or Co-Motion sticker on them.
I had a really good laugh tonight watching the pundits on Fox News explaining the reasons for the Republican failure last night. Did not think anything could compare until I read this gibberish.
kaliayev is offline  
Reply
Old 11-08-12 | 07:04 AM
  #107  
Chrome Molly's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 3,190
Likes: 17
From: Forksbent, MN

Bikes: Yes

Originally Posted by mtnbke

Titanium always builds a better bike than steel. ALWAYS.
Congratulations, you just made me blow coffee out my nose.


https://www.strongframes.com/more_stu...ls_tech/specs/
Just one of many comparisons that can be found listing the relative merits of different materials. Not seeing always listed...

Last edited by Chrome Molly; 11-08-12 at 07:11 AM.
Chrome Molly is offline  
Reply
Old 11-08-12 | 07:52 AM
  #108  
Italuminium's Avatar
Cisalpinist
 
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 5,557
Likes: 18
From: Holland

Bikes: blue ones.

Originally Posted by kaliayev
I had a really good laugh tonight watching the pundits on Fox News explaining the reasons for the Republican failure last night. Did not think anything could compare until I read this gibberish.
I really have a hard time understanding (and a good time laughing) as European to see all these American politicians and preachers tumble over each other with the weirdest and most out-of-touch quotes laden with religious fervour (hi, senator Todd!), but I think this guy is a branch of the same tree.
Italuminium is offline  
Reply
Old 11-08-12 | 10:04 PM
  #109  
CrankyFranky's Avatar
Procrastinateur supreme
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 1,216
Likes: 3
From: Franko barada nikto

Bikes: Enough bikes...for today!

If the thread isn't already locked... I read the whole flippin' thing, and there are many opinions and factoids, and lots of "I want one too"... but besides the known fact of the Teledyne Ti breaking issue, where's the dirt?

Does anyone has some real evidence that titanium production is worse than mountain top removal for coal mining, shale oil/tar sands oil production, copper or aluminum production etc? Show us the stains, please. Otherwise, I'm not going to be too shy about saying that I'd like a nice riding modern Ti too, just so I can stop worrying about the expense of upgrading my 30 and 40 year old steel - which won't make them much lighter anyhow.

Even if I possessed one, I can bet that in 40 years I would have a hard time finding components that fit on it.
CrankyFranky is offline  
Reply
Old 11-08-12 | 11:06 PM
  #110  
dgodave's Avatar
Behold my avatar:
 
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 1,037
Likes: 447
From: SW Colorado

Bikes: 2019 Gorilla Monsoon, 2013 Surly Krampus, Brompton folder

Love my Ti Litespeed Ocoee from 1994(?).
.
dgodave is offline  
Reply
Old 01-02-13 | 08:29 PM
  #111  
Paul Y.'s Avatar
Senior Member
 
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 912
Likes: 0
From: kennett sq. pa

Bikes: 2008 Lynskey R220 2005 Lemond

I love my Titanium but... I don't know where he gets that information.
Paul Y. is offline  
Reply
Old 01-02-13 | 09:02 PM
  #112  
shoota's Avatar
Senior Member
Titanium Club Membership
10 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jun 2012
Posts: 7,852
Likes: 716
From: Stillwater, OK
Originally Posted by cehowardGS
A zombie thread, back from the grave..

My one and only TI, 1996 LiteSpeed Classic..

That might be my dream bike.
shoota is offline  
Reply
Old 01-02-13 | 10:04 PM
  #113  
Salubrious's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Anniversary
 
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 1,655
Likes: 366
From: St. Paul, MN

Bikes: Too many 3-speeds, Jones Plus LWB

I've got a Titus road frame (Titus is known for MTBs) set up with an Alfine 11-speed hub, nice Mavic road rims, composite bars, brooks saddle, Reynolds 953 (stainless) fork. Parts from all over. Comes in at about 20 lbs, lighter than my Guerciotti, which is all-Campy. I prefer the TI ride though. I can make better time on it and the ride is easier.
Salubrious is offline  
Reply
Old 01-02-13 | 10:09 PM
  #114  
shoota's Avatar
Senior Member
Titanium Club Membership
10 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jun 2012
Posts: 7,852
Likes: 716
From: Stillwater, OK
Originally Posted by Salubrious
I've got a Titus road frame (Titus is known for MTBs) set up with an Alfine 11-speed hub, nice Mavic road rims, composite bars, brooks saddle, Reynolds 953 (stainless) fork. Parts from all over. Comes in at about 20 lbs, lighter than my Guerciotti, which is all-Campy. I prefer the TI ride though. I can make better time on it and the ride is easier.
Pics or it didn't happen.
shoota is offline  
Reply
Old 01-02-13 | 11:06 PM
  #115  
Junior Member
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 124
Likes: 0
From: Bloomington, IL
No controversy here. I've got a ti roadie and she's one of the nicer riding steeds I've owned.
russd32 is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 12:37 AM
  #116  
onespeedbiker's Avatar
Retro Grouch
 
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 2,210
Likes: 3
From: Santa Cruz

Bikes: Yes

Originally Posted by kpug505
Now now now...Them theres is fightin' words!

On a serious note...Ti got a bad wrap when it was introduced on the market for good reason. It broke...It's a fact. It wasn't until different Ti alloys were introduced and better engineering and manufacturing techniques came around that Ti found it's place in the world of bicycles. And what a great place it has found! Nobody in their right mind can deny that Ti is a fantastic material for making frames and select components when used and built appropriately.
Ti first got a bad rap with bicycles in the 1982 Girod'Italia when Laurent Fignon had a bad fall while he was in the lead due to a broken Super Record axle. This resulted in a second generation Super Record with steel replacing the previous Ti parts (while the SR Ti axle is legendary, there is no evidence they were ever available beyond the pro sponsored riders). Titanium tube sets cost about the same as 853 steel, but like 953 (that costs a couple $100 more), the cost of the frame is in the build not the tubes. It should be noted that there is more titanium in a Boeing 747 than all the ti bike frames ever built; close to 20 tons. To those that judge the ultimate metal as strength to weight, Reynolds 853 is equal to ti and 953 is 25% stronger; a good frame maker can coax any ride quality out of any material.

I read this in another post I've ridden a slew of both materials (ti and steel) and I think materials come in about last place when I think about how a bike feels beneath me.

Last edited by onespeedbiker; 01-03-13 at 12:43 AM.
onespeedbiker is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 06:54 AM
  #117  
martl's Avatar
Strong Walker
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 1,404
Likes: 616
From: Black Forest, Germany

Bikes: too many

Originally Posted by Sixty Fiver
My dream bike would be made out out titanium and be fitted with a belt drive and a Rohloff.

Price is the only barrier here.
Originally Posted by miamijim
That right there is a nice setup!!!!
Originally Posted by Sixty Fiver
Hell yes.

I may have to build it myself
-> https://www.rewelbikes.com/It/home.asp



They build to your specs and have load of experience, one of the Ti pioneers. Very competitive pricing too. Go on holiday in the Dolomites and order your bike..

Also recommendeable: Van Nicholas


Last edited by martl; 01-03-13 at 06:57 AM.
martl is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 11:37 AM
  #118  
jr59's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 2,287
Likes: 15
From: the 904, Jax fl
I like my Ti bike just fine!
jr59 is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 11:45 AM
  #119  
KonAaron Snake's Avatar
Thread Starter
Fat Guy on a Little Bike
Titanium Club Membership
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 15,946
Likes: 371
From: Philadelphia, PA

Bikes: Two wheeled ones

The only thing I don't like about the ti bike above is that it's not mine.
KonAaron Snake is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 12:08 PM
  #120  
non-fixie's Avatar
Cyclotouriste
Titanium Club Membership
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 11,785
Likes: 6,997
From: South Holland, NL

Bikes: Yes, please.

Too small to ride, but large enough not to need my reading glasses to look at it. Which is good, as it's probably the best-looking bike I own.

__________________
Shuffling with the prince












non-fixie is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 02:08 PM
  #121  
Catnap's Avatar
Senior Member
Titanium Club Membership
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 2,097
Likes: 810
From: Ridgewood, Queens

Bikes: Zunow, 3Rensho, Look KG196

Originally Posted by martl
-> https://www.rewelbikes.com/It/home.asp



They build to your specs and have load of experience, one of the Ti pioneers. Very competitive pricing too. Go on holiday in the Dolomites and order your bike..

that bike looks like the Euro answer to the Surly Long Haul Trucker. being TI and Euro tho, I assume the price is 3x higher. still, looks hella fun.
__________________
Check out www.djcatnap.com for articles on vintage Japanese & French bicycle restorations, components and history.
Catnap is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 02:46 PM
  #122  
martl's Avatar
Strong Walker
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 1,404
Likes: 616
From: Black Forest, Germany

Bikes: too many

Originally Posted by Catnap
that bike looks like the Euro answer to the Surly Long Haul Trucker. being TI and Euro tho, I assume the price is 3x higher. still, looks hella fun.
Well, the answer came15 years before the question, Rewel started using Titanium in 1986.
Rewels are actually quite a bit cheaper than a Moots, Litespeed or Merlin over here, and they do any geometry you like (Friend of mine had them build him a Hardtail MTB with the same angles and position as his fully Giant).
They aren't expensive - starting below 2000€ for a custom made to measure frame.

Van Nicholas are budget Ti frames, starting at 1700€ for the Rohloff Randonneur.
martl is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 04:47 PM
  #123  
KonAaron Snake's Avatar
Thread Starter
Fat Guy on a Little Bike
Titanium Club Membership
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 15,946
Likes: 371
From: Philadelphia, PA

Bikes: Two wheeled ones

Originally Posted by jr59
I like my Ti bike just fine!
Did you pay a model for that photo?
KonAaron Snake is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 05:05 PM
  #124  
jr59's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 2,287
Likes: 15
From: the 904, Jax fl
Originally Posted by KonAaron Snake
Did you pay a model for that photo?
No I just bought her lunch at the end of the shoot!
jr59 is offline  
Reply
Old 01-03-13 | 05:07 PM
  #125  
jr59's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 2,287
Likes: 15
From: the 904, Jax fl
Originally Posted by KonAaron Snake
The only thing I don't like about the ti bike above is that it's not mine.
I guess I should go on and build up the other Spectrum as well. I can't run on these 23-25 tires to much.

I need my 35s, so I should build the new one up!
jr59 is offline  
Reply


Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.