Need some comfortable brake levers for a new build. I tend to like riding on the hoods and flat tops. What do you guys think?

The contenders:

Tektro


Cane Creek


Sram S500


Shimano BL-R400


Other

I've found the tektro to be fine for me, but everyone's hands are different.

Other:

You're a sick man

The Tektro and Cane Creek are quite similar...quite possibly identical, but I prefer the Cane Creek. Also you can get em with Tan hoods, which I like.

The new (current) tektro levers have hoods that are shaped a lot differently than the original ones, but they're equally as comfortable IMO. Not built quite as well but not bad. Also the current crop of tektro levers have levers that curve outwards to make the brakes easier to grab. Just FYI.

You're referring to two different models R100/R200 and R340/R341. Two different levers, each with two lever arm options.

I like the shape of Shimano levers, but that's just me...The BL-R400 and BL-R600 are very nice IMHO. And perhaps, more importantly, they look more the C&V part then the rest.

I just looked at the levers and you're right. I ordered R200's and they sent me R340's lol...

The new ones blind me. I couldnt put something so "special" on my bike.

I like Tektros, mainly because of the long, wide, flat top. Very comfy place to rest the hands, and a nice smooth transition to the "ramps" on the handlebar. Very much like 10sp Campy Ergos, another fave of mine. Shimanos have never appealed to me - too much like pre-aero Campys: narrow, short body, abrupt transition from handlebar, and too small around for my long fingers.

FWIW, Cane Creek levers are also made by Tektro.

SP
Bend, OR

I've only had the Tektro and Shimano and I liked them both, but I voted Tektro because I think they look better for no particular reason.

I'll hold off on voting for a little while.
I'm presently using Tektro Long-Pull levers on my commuter, and I really like them. I have ordered a set of Cane Creek SC-5's in silver with the gum rubber hoods for my Marinoni (along with a noodle bar), so will be able to have a better gauge on my preference.

My fave's to date were my Campy Ergo 10sp circa 2000, which the Tektro's are reminiscent of.

Uhmmm......make sure you choose the one with easily repalacable hoods. You know what happens when the bacon starts to cook! 45+ bucks if you can even find them! Cachinggggg!

Chombi

The SRAM are a bit pricey but look pretty comfortable and have the same hoods as all other sram levers so they should be easy to replace.

I've had both the Tektro/Cane Creek and the BL-R600 (R400?). The Tektros have a plastic body which is light but I found pretty "hollow" and the horizontal play in the metal lever itself was disappointing. The body was big but possibly too big for me; I didn't feel as though I could get a complete grip. Couple that with the loose lever arm and it was an okay lever for the price but nothing special.

The Shimano R600 (never tried the R400 but they seem similar) I recently got and their quality is really great. The body is metal and solid with the right amount of heft, the hoods feel slightly thicker, and the design allows my hand to get a comfortable, firmer grip. The metal levers are nicely polished with little lateral play. Whereas the Tektros felt unnecessarily big, the Shimanos were compact and of distinguishably better quality. I do wish they had the quick-release mechanism. They do cost almost 3X the price but they seem to be pretty cheap on eBay though. If you like the Shimano Aero design from the 80's (105, 600, etc.) then the R600 will not disappoint.

I also want to throw out Gran Compe levers too. I found that the higher quality stuff from Dia Compe was surprisingly good. I have Aero Gran Compe levers and the hood material is phenomenal while the body is solid, maybe a bit chunky. They started the whole spring in the lever part design I believe.

The SRAM don't look CV at all... look like brifters without the "-ifters" part.

Carbon record levers. Do it.

You mean to tell me it's about comfort. All along I thought it was how they looked.

~kn

_MG_9966 by individual image, on Flickr

They're not much to look at, but I like the bendy Tektros a lot. They fit my hands better than the RL100/200 and I can get great braking action from atop the hoods.

The Tektro site lists a gum hood for these but I've never seen them offered through any distributors (and they might not do much to make them look better anyway.)

They are truly brake levers only a mother could love....Glad they work for you.

^ They're actually very ergonomic in a good way.

They actually look like they would be a nice option. I just hate how ugly they are from the front