Gear shifter?
#1
Gear shifter?
I'm going to put riser bars on my road bike. It's a Felt and has 25 gears.I'm going to put Shimano 3x8 speed shifter/brake lever combo because the Simano 3x9 cost double the price on the 3x8 on Ebay is like $25.That would put me at 24 gears which is just fine.I don't need 25 gears.With that shifter missing one gear.Will it work? or will I just not have access to that last gear?
Last edited by SANDBORNSTEVE; 08-09-17 at 10:27 PM.
#3
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 8,687
Likes: 300
Your bike does not have 25 gears.
You don't have 24 or 27 gears either.
You can have 24 or 27 different combinations.
Some of those shouldn't be used due to cross-chaining.
Some are repeat ratios.
As a crude rule-of-thumb, expect to have about 2/3 as many usefully different ratios as you have possible combinations.
Opinions on mixing 8-/9-speed vary.
8- and 9-speed cassettes are equally wide.
So the sprockets are spaced tighter by some fraction of a mm on the 9-speed.
Now, (at least) Shimano derailer pulleys have some sideways float.
Which forgives a bit of mismatch.
Even mixing 7/8-speed will usually kinda-sorta work.
And they have a bigger difference in spacing.
Whether or not you'll be content with the performance is impossible to say.
Degree of wear, tune, shifting style and rider expectations tend to play a big role in how satisfied someone is with a mixed drivetrain.
You don't have 24 or 27 gears either.
You can have 24 or 27 different combinations.
Some of those shouldn't be used due to cross-chaining.
Some are repeat ratios.
As a crude rule-of-thumb, expect to have about 2/3 as many usefully different ratios as you have possible combinations.
Opinions on mixing 8-/9-speed vary.
8- and 9-speed cassettes are equally wide.
So the sprockets are spaced tighter by some fraction of a mm on the 9-speed.
Now, (at least) Shimano derailer pulleys have some sideways float.
Which forgives a bit of mismatch.
Even mixing 7/8-speed will usually kinda-sorta work.
And they have a bigger difference in spacing.
Whether or not you'll be content with the performance is impossible to say.
Degree of wear, tune, shifting style and rider expectations tend to play a big role in how satisfied someone is with a mixed drivetrain.
#4
Senior Member


Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 30,225
Likes: 649
From: St Peters, Missouri
Bikes: Catrike 559 I own some others but they don't get ridden very much.
I don't think that you have that quite right. 7 and 8-speed cassette cog spacing are the ones within a fraction of a mm with one another. 8 and 9-speed varies by quite a bit and won't mix/match. Assuming OP has a 3 x 9 drivetrain now, if he wants to use an 8-speed shifter to save money, he'll need to buy an 8-speed cassette so I doubt he's going to save anything. I'd get the 9-speed shifter.
__________________
My greatest fear is all of my kids standing around my coffin and talking about "how sensible" dad was.
My greatest fear is all of my kids standing around my coffin and talking about "how sensible" dad was.
#5
I'm going to put riser bars on my road bike. It's a Felt and has 25 gears.I'm going to put Shimano 3x8 speed shifter/brake lever combo because the Simano 3x9 cost double the price on the 3x8 on Ebay is like $25.That would put me at 24 gears which is just fine.I don't need 25 gears.With that shifter missing one gear.Will it work? or will I just not have access to that last gear?
In general, compatibility depends on three things. Any of these can prevent the shifting from working correctly.
The spacing between rear cogs.
The cable pull distance per click from the shifter.
The amount of movement of the rear derailleur when the cable is shifted.
There are some workarounds to get non-compatible components to function. A few incorrect combinations will "kind-of" work, not quite lined up, but close enough for some riders.
So,
post your rear derailleur model, and the number of rear cogs you have.
You can post photos by clicking "Advanced" and use the paperclip icon to upload a photo.
You'll get more useful answers.
Last edited by rm -rf; 08-10-17 at 05:34 AM.
#6
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 8,687
Likes: 300
I don't think that you have that quite right. 7 and 8-speed cassette cog spacing are the ones within a fraction of a mm with one another. 8 and 9-speed varies by quite a bit and won't mix/match. Assuming OP has a 3 x 9 drivetrain now, if he wants to use an 8-speed shifter to save money, he'll need to buy an 8-speed cassette so I doubt he's going to save anything. I'd get the 9-speed shifter.
Shimano 8-speed is 4.80 mm.
Shimano 9-speed is 4.35 mm
So yeah, roughly twice the error mixing 8/9 as mixing 7/8.
Never said I thought it was a good idea.
But I've ridden with people claiming to be happy with it.
I might try it, If those were the parts I had home.
But I wouldn't buy mismatched parts like that.
#7
Banned
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 43,586
Likes: 1,380
From: NW,Oregon Coast
Bikes: 8
" Gear" = a ratio .... count teeth, use those numbers.. a 40 tooth front sprocket turns a 20t hub cog twice.
We call that a 2:1 ratio.
Popular is to then multiply the ratio by the wheel diameter, measured in inches.. that is called 'gear-inches'
We call that a 2:1 ratio.
Popular is to then multiply the ratio by the wheel diameter, measured in inches.. that is called 'gear-inches'
#8
I'm going to put riser bars on my road bike. It's a Felt and has 25 gears.I'm going to put Shimano 3x8 speed shifter/brake lever combo because the Simano 3x9 cost double the price on the 3x8 on Ebay is like $25.That would put me at 24 gears which is just fine.I don't need 25 gears.With that shifter missing one gear.Will it work? or will I just not have access to that last gear?
Last edited by alcjphil; 08-11-17 at 01:48 PM.
#9
I'm going to put riser bars on my road bike. It's a Felt and has 25 gears.I'm going to put Shimano 3x8 speed shifter/brake lever combo because the Simano 3x9 cost double the price on the 3x8 on Ebay is like $25.That would put me at 24 gears which is just fine.I don't need 25 gears.With that shifter missing one gear.Will it work? or will I just not have access to that last gear?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Philphine
Bicycle Mechanics
24
11-08-14 08:48 PM






