Is this acceptable?
#26
Are you specifically trying to create a grocery shopping bike? You should start with a cargo bike type of design:

^ I rode a bike with this small front wheel/ frame mounted basket design once, and it was very, very stable even carrying a good load. It was a revelation. It's nothing like putting a basket on a regular bike.

^ I rode a bike with this small front wheel/ frame mounted basket design once, and it was very, very stable even carrying a good load. It was a revelation. It's nothing like putting a basket on a regular bike.
#27
Sunshine
Joined: Aug 2014
Posts: 18,699
Likes: 10,236
From: Des Moines, IA
Bikes: '18 class built steel roadbike, '19 Fairlight Secan, '88 Schwinn Premis , Black Mountain Cycles Monstercross V4, '89 Novara Trionfo
You forgot to list why steel tubing for your frame and why disc brakes instead of rim.
But the biggest thing you forgot is to say why you are even asking if your bike spec is acceptable.
Why are you asking if it's acceptable? If someone says 'NO!' will that matter? If someone says 'YES!' will that matter?
But the biggest thing you forgot is to say why you are even asking if your bike spec is acceptable.
Why are you asking if it's acceptable? If someone says 'NO!' will that matter? If someone says 'YES!' will that matter?
#28
Senior Member


Joined: May 2016
Posts: 4,214
Likes: 1,948
Bikes: Trek 1100, Raleigh R-500, Cannondale R800, Roadmaster gravel/beater mountain bike
-plastic pedals with reflectors
plastic because even if it's rare to hit your shins, the marks from metal pedals can last for years. Also reflectors because once I was in a bus at night and the only thing you saw from a cyclist at night once was the pedal reflectors.
plastic because even if it's rare to hit your shins, the marks from metal pedals can last for years. Also reflectors because once I was in a bus at night and the only thing you saw from a cyclist at night once was the pedal reflectors.
#30
Senior Member

Joined: Dec 2020
Posts: 6,987
Likes: 3,836
From: Wake Forest, NC
Bikes: 1989 Cinelli Supercorsa
#31
You forgot to list why steel tubing for your frame and why disc brakes instead of rim.
But the biggest thing you forgot is to say why you are even asking if your bike spec is acceptable.
Why are you asking if it's acceptable? If someone says 'NO!' will that matter? If someone says 'YES!' will that matter?
But the biggest thing you forgot is to say why you are even asking if your bike spec is acceptable.
Why are you asking if it's acceptable? If someone says 'NO!' will that matter? If someone says 'YES!' will that matter?
As for the disc brakes, well someone commented on here that some people are not as good at adjusting V-brakes as they can with disc brakes. I remember on one bike I had super squealing that could shake the entire bike with the V-brakes. Then I learned how to adjust the brake pads at an angle (toe-in) with an elastic band or twist-tie. I don't think everyone knows how to do that. Besides, some V-brakes after a while loose their tension. I did find a trick for that on Youtube but again not everyone would know how to do that.
And the other point, about other people's opinions. I really think the way some bikes are configured that some companies are just not paying attention to what the consumer wants. Just look at the Marin Kentfield 1. When I saw someone driving one with an upright seating position on Youtube I was thinking this is great. When I noticed the weird gearing though it's a 1x drivetrain with 7 speeds in the rear. Who does that anyway? First, it's only seven speeds. Second, with 38T cranks and 11-32T cassette it only goes down to around 32 gear inches. And by the way, I read a hub for a 7 speed cassette is not compatible with an 8 or 9 speed cassette. So it's not easily modifiable. Does that mean they want to force you to get the Deore model? What if I wanted an Acera model (or minimum Altus)?
#32
Senior Member


Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 11,475
Likes: 4,880
From: San Jose (Willow Glen) Ca
Bikes: Kirk Custom JK Special, 86 De Rosa Pro, '84 Team Miyata,(dura ace old school) 80?? SR Semi-Pro 600 Arabesque
OK well I did say I do like aluminum. But, the main points about steel is more road vibration absorption, the ability to re-bend it if it's a bit banged up, and the fact it's easier to find welders who can weld steel rather than aluminum.
As for the disc brakes, well someone commented on here that some people are not as good at adjusting V-brakes as they can with disc brakes. I remember on one bike I had super squealing that could shake the entire bike with the V-brakes. Then I learned how to adjust the brake pads at an angle (toe-in) with an elastic band or twist-tie. I don't think everyone knows how to do that. Besides, some V-brakes after a while loose their tension. I did find a trick for that on Youtube but again not everyone would know how to do that.
And the other point, about other people's opinions. I really think the way some bikes are configured that some companies are just not paying attention to what the consumer wants. Just look at the Marin Kentfield 1. When I saw someone driving one with an upright seating position on Youtube I was thinking this is great. When I noticed the weird gearing though it's a 1x drivetrain with 7 speeds in the rear. Who does that anyway? First, it's only seven speeds. Second, with 38T cranks and 11-32T cassette it only goes down to around 32 gear inches. And by the way, I read a hub for a 7 speed cassette is not compatible with an 8 or 9 speed cassette. So it's not easily modifiable. Does that mean they want to force you to get the Deore model? What if I wanted an Acera model (or minimum Altus)?
As for the disc brakes, well someone commented on here that some people are not as good at adjusting V-brakes as they can with disc brakes. I remember on one bike I had super squealing that could shake the entire bike with the V-brakes. Then I learned how to adjust the brake pads at an angle (toe-in) with an elastic band or twist-tie. I don't think everyone knows how to do that. Besides, some V-brakes after a while loose their tension. I did find a trick for that on Youtube but again not everyone would know how to do that.
And the other point, about other people's opinions. I really think the way some bikes are configured that some companies are just not paying attention to what the consumer wants. Just look at the Marin Kentfield 1. When I saw someone driving one with an upright seating position on Youtube I was thinking this is great. When I noticed the weird gearing though it's a 1x drivetrain with 7 speeds in the rear. Who does that anyway? First, it's only seven speeds. Second, with 38T cranks and 11-32T cassette it only goes down to around 32 gear inches. And by the way, I read a hub for a 7 speed cassette is not compatible with an 8 or 9 speed cassette. So it's not easily modifiable. Does that mean they want to force you to get the Deore model? What if I wanted an Acera model (or minimum Altus)?
people do not want friction shifters.
gearing setup including 7 speed it there to meet a price point
this is simple runaround bike
most people are not going to get a bike and then mod it
your basic thinking is: this is what I like so everyone should like it......that is flawed
I like tubulars and don't like tubeless....that does not mean that is the best for everyone....best for me. and does not mean everyone should like that preference
__________________
Life is too short not to ride the best bike you have, as much as you can.
Life is too short not to ride the best bike you have, as much as you can.
#33
People are answering the way they are because you haven't included the most important part. Acceptable for what? We do not know what you are going to use the bike for, or what your preferences are. We don't know if you want to commute on the bike, ride trails, or what. It helps to know if you simply want a bike to ride the MUP, or around town, od just around the neighborhood for fun.
#34
Senior Member

Joined: Dec 2020
Posts: 6,987
Likes: 3,836
From: Wake Forest, NC
Bikes: 1989 Cinelli Supercorsa
People are answering the way they are because you haven't included the most important part. Acceptable for what? We do not know what you are going to use the bike for, or what your preferences are. We don't know if you want to commute on the bike, ride trails, or what. It helps to know if you simply want a bike to ride the MUP, or around town, od just around the neighborhood for fun.
#35
With a mighty wind

Joined: May 2015
Posts: 3,432
Likes: 1,485
I have 3 high level steel road bikes. They’re ok.
As for adjusting brakes on the side of the road? That’s a fallacy the anti-hydro crowd puts forth. With mechanical you can replace the cable or recenter the pads sure. With hydro, you don’t have to because they don’t need it.
With the exception of a pretty severe crash, properly maintained and decent quality hydro’s are going to go several years between adjustments.
But if you’re really looking for a bike to ride to the edge of the ice wall, just get rim brakes. They aren’t better but they fit the vibe.
#36
#37
Senior Member

Joined: Dec 2020
Posts: 6,987
Likes: 3,836
From: Wake Forest, NC
Bikes: 1989 Cinelli Supercorsa
#38
#40
Senior Member

Joined: Dec 2020
Posts: 6,987
Likes: 3,836
From: Wake Forest, NC
Bikes: 1989 Cinelli Supercorsa
#41
I'll admit I don't think I've ever looked seriously at Internal Geared Hubs. But one idea I can't believe got put down on this site is direct mount caliper brakes. Maybe they came about around the time disc brakes already emerged but the idea I thought would be cool for large tires. I still believe in 27.5x2.15" tires though (even 2.35"). One of the reasons I believe the 650b fad is not as hot though is because companies like Brodie Bikes eliminated some of those models and replaced them with 700c models. So I guess since 700x40c has caught on I hope one company will come out with direct mount brakes for those.
As a passing comment on tires, I tested 41mm, 44mm and 55mm tires on the same gravel road with 1 inch rocks. The most pleasant was obviously 55mm. Even 41mm wouldn't compare though is more plush than 36mm (some tires marked 38c are actually 36mm). If I didn't want a squishy feeling but wanted to at least survive potholes then 36mm would be my minimum. (I did see a video however on Youtube by pathlesscycled where he said 40mm was way softer on cobblestone roads then 35mm.) The Schwalbe Green Marathon tread pattern is probably my favorite on paper even though I haven't tried it yet.
As a passing comment on tires, I tested 41mm, 44mm and 55mm tires on the same gravel road with 1 inch rocks. The most pleasant was obviously 55mm. Even 41mm wouldn't compare though is more plush than 36mm (some tires marked 38c are actually 36mm). If I didn't want a squishy feeling but wanted to at least survive potholes then 36mm would be my minimum. (I did see a video however on Youtube by pathlesscycled where he said 40mm was way softer on cobblestone roads then 35mm.) The Schwalbe Green Marathon tread pattern is probably my favorite on paper even though I haven't tried it yet.
#42
I'll admit I don't think I've ever looked seriously at Internal Geared Hubs. But one idea I can't believe got put down on this site is direct mount caliper brakes. Maybe they came about around the time disc brakes already emerged but the idea I thought would be cool for large tires. I still believe in 27.5x2.15" tires though (even 2.35"). One of the reasons I believe the 650b fad is not as hot though is because companies like Brodie Bikes eliminated some of those models and replaced them with 700c models. So I guess since 700x40c has caught on I hope one company will come out with direct mount brakes for those.
As a passing comment on tires, I tested 41mm, 44mm and 55mm tires on the same gravel road with 1 inch rocks. The most pleasant was obviously 55mm. Even 41mm wouldn't compare though is more plush than 36mm (some tires marked 38c are actually 36mm). If I didn't want a squishy feeling but wanted to at least survive potholes then 36mm would be my minimum. (I did see a video however on Youtube by pathlesscycled where he said 40mm was way softer on cobblestone roads then 35mm.) The Schwalbe Green Marathon tread pattern is probably my favorite on paper even though I haven't tried it yet.
As a passing comment on tires, I tested 41mm, 44mm and 55mm tires on the same gravel road with 1 inch rocks. The most pleasant was obviously 55mm. Even 41mm wouldn't compare though is more plush than 36mm (some tires marked 38c are actually 36mm). If I didn't want a squishy feeling but wanted to at least survive potholes then 36mm would be my minimum. (I did see a video however on Youtube by pathlesscycled where he said 40mm was way softer on cobblestone roads then 35mm.) The Schwalbe Green Marathon tread pattern is probably my favorite on paper even though I haven't tried it yet.
#43
As a mechanic who has worked with linkglide/CUES since it came out, this part makes no sense to me. Do you base a lot of your decisions on what “one poster” or “some YouTuber” said?
#44
Well, that's good if they're adjustable. But I did hear from several youtubers that CUES is slower than Hyperglide. Even if that doesn't seem like a large factor, I'm pretty sure I'd find it annoying if my gear changes were a bit slower every time I wanted to change gears, even if I'm not a racer.






