Wasn't sure what forum to put this in, so figured General Discussion should do.

Looking for advice as to which type of trainer is best, a magnetic resistance trainer or a fluid resistance trainer. Exactly what is the difference anyways?

I currently have a magnetic resistance model that is about 10 years old nowadays and on its last leg, so looking to get a new one before sub-zero temps set in.

Just trying to figure if I should stick to magnetic or switch over to fluid.

Thanks in advance for any comments / tips / suggestions.

Can't make up your mind for you .. Difference involves Physics *. Try Both , in a Shop. get a Snow bike and ride outside..

* ie Magnetism vs fluid dynamics.

I think you should consider what kind of features you want first, such as a power meter, app interfacing, etc. Obviously the Wahoo Kickr is at the top of the pile in most regards, but it's a solid $1k, which also puts it at the top of the pile!

I certainly don't need a $1,000 trainer with all the bells and whistles.

Just looking for one that will let do some simple indoor spinning with a minimum amount of noise. I just want to hop on, spin for anywhere from 30 to 60 minutes and feel like I've accomplished a little something.

The one I currently have sounded like a semi truck was rumbling thru my apartment at times.

Just Your Bike + Rollers.. https://www.tacx.com/products/trainers/galaxia

Then quiet them with a rubber mat.

I have a Cycleops Fluid 2 and love it. It is quite and very well designed. I rode rollers years ago but at 61 yrs I feel much more secure on the trainer.

mike

Fluid Vs. Magnetic Bike Trainers | LIVESTRONG.COM

Lot's of info can be found via google...

Yes, but information about a product mainly talks AT you whereas oftentimes personal experiences talk TO you, which is what I'm looking for.

I have tried a magnetic trainer ... I prefer my fluid trainer. I have a Nashbar fluid trainer which has served me well for many years.

You can get fluid trainers from Nashbar, and other places, starting at about $170.

Nashbar - Trainers

I'm looking to buy a trainer as well and would appreciate some input about 2 brands I've seen advertised. One is the Racermate Computrainer and the other is the Kurt Kinetic Fluid Trainer. Anyone have any experience or knowledge of either of these?