Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Comparison of Road Cycling communities (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/1042583-comparison-road-cycling-communities.html)

gregf83 12-27-15 09:34 AM


Originally Posted by Doge (Post 18415694)
Would you take that KOM over say - a BC championship?

No. But if I was competitive on that KOM I'd be racing for a national championship. A championship is permanent, unlike a KOM.

Doge 12-27-15 11:40 AM

I understand that people value things differently. For me (proud racer dad/rec cyclist that used to compete) - a local KOM on a classic segment is something everyone you see (cycling wise) knows about and it is perpetual vs. a championship which is annual. I will be approached on rides about my son's KOMs while nothing is said - or they don't know about most race wins. I have no idea who the various SoCal State Champions are from year to year and most others don't either. But most SoCal cyclists know who has the Palomar KOM and most know the Cooks Como KOM.
A National Championship - yea, better than any Strava result. But some races are harder than National Championships to even get a top 10 - and those are not noticed. Get a KOM in those same races and my son's Facebook fills with friend requests.

More on communities.
SoCal has big group rides with 100ish riders weekends and others mid-week around 50ish (Como, Swamies, SDBC, Simi, Foodpark, Coffee Crew, Rose Bowl (forgot name), Bud's Ride, El Dorado Park, Great Park, New Years Day will be 500-1000 on coast Hwy - one pack). Europe has big race groups and big crowds (Belgium) watching but I have not seen the big group rides. The big group social aspect appears to be more an American (SoCal in particular) thing than Euro thing. Part of that may be the roads here/there, or maybe they save it for race day.

If you look a little closer at the classic Euro Strava segments of the famous riders and use that flyby feature http://labs.strava.com/flyby/viewer/...2&z=B&t=1MVzi2 you can see they are not often in groups.

Shuffleman 12-28-15 08:56 AM


Originally Posted by jon c. (Post 18414590)
He's just jealous that we have so many great back roads and country lanes.

I just thought of it as another example of "Northern Agression", but you are probably right:thumb:

Doge 12-28-15 09:32 AM


Originally Posted by kbarch (Post 18410391)
...But I noticed that even on rides where I felt we were riding as well as I ever do here, there my standings were consistently low - surprisingly low in many cases. But I also noticed that the number of riders recorded was relatively low, too. Perhaps that had to do with the fact that the nearest city of much size was about 80km away and the nearest "metropolis" (Milan) was more than 250km away.

Maybe only the most serious cyclists had occasion to ride those routes, whereas the routes I normally take are right next to the most populous city in the US? Maybe Italians (or at least Italian Freds) don't like Strava?

Currently 2015 - The Euro kids use Strava a lot, about the same as the USA kids. The USA kids/juniors are in generally faster on Strava, and the road.

EventServices 12-28-15 11:44 AM

By now, I just assume that all of the KOMs in the world have been set using TT bikes on days with a gale-force tailwind by guys who specifically went out with one purpose: to set that particular KOM. (I don't count the KOMs that go up a hill because I'm old and fat and know better.)

So to draw conclusion about a cycling community based on Strava data is a moving target. You have no idea what you're up against.

side story (feel free to skip): I did a long ride on a breezy day. Somewhere along the line, I unwittingly set a KOM in the tailwind section. The next day, the winds were 30mph. I get a notification that my KOM was beaten. Out of morbid curiosity, I check the guy's ride. He had only gone out to ride that segment. He took two runs at it. Huge tailwind. Beat me. Titled his ride: Your move, Smith.

Does he realize that Smith is old? Was on a mtb? Was 40 miles into my ride? Was unaware it was a segment? Didn't care? Didn't ride any faster than the rest of my ride?
So my only 'move' is to think that perhaps he's lonely. I don't engage.

As I said, if he's drawing any conclusions from his Strava performances, he's missing a lot of information.

Seattle Forrest 12-28-15 11:51 AM

Not a Strava member so I can't comment on any of that. I use their heat maps to find routes to ride sometimes, but that's as far as my experience with them goes.

I've spent a lot of time riding in the Methow Valley in northern Washington and the place is cycling heaven.

PepeM 12-28-15 11:59 AM

Less 'clydes' riding around in Europe.

bakes1 12-28-15 01:04 PM


Originally Posted by Doge (Post 18414098)
Specific example. My kid has to race adults with at least the top 3 cog handicap (11-12-13) and a 52+ ring. So real road racing reflects nothing if those cogs need to be used and he got dropped not having them. A Strava result where those cogs are not needed says more than the race win.

To my post which was some KOMs are more meaningful than race wins. This one is an example. Most everyone in SoCal knows this course. https://www.strava.com/segments/764232 58,320 attempts by 6,383 my son would not trade for 10 local race wins - or a state championship.

Yeah. Years later why would anyone want to be able to look back on a state championship victory against the known top competition on a level playing field when they can instead boast about a random Strava KOM where they stacked up against unknowns under random and different conditions?
I personally like to fire up my ebike to grab some KOMs on the world renowned SoCal segments of true supremacy. I regularly run into tdf riders and ofc state champions while I am out there because where else would they want to go to measure up against the best of the best right?

Doge 12-28-15 01:20 PM


Originally Posted by bakes1 (Post 18419150)
Yeah. Years later why would anyone want to be able to look back on a state championship victory against the known top competition on a level playing field when they can instead boast about a random Strava KOM where they stacked up against unknowns under random and different conditions?
I personally like to fire up my ebike to grab some KOMs on the world renowned SoCal segments of true supremacy. I regularly run into tdf riders and ofc state champions while I am out there because where else would they want to go to measure up against the best of the best right?

I think I already posted I have a junior, but this affects adults too if a junior is present. State Championships are not level playing fields. If there is a junior there (there usually are) they are by rules not allowed the same equipment. The winners are not really winners if there is a junior close behind.

Example - NRC Redlands Stage Race - one of the pro big ones - 2015 Phil wins. But after 10+ hours Adrian is 30 seconds behind - he got 3rd. Adrian is not allowed to use his 11T,12T,13T. Phil is and does. When it comes down to a level playing field Phil - a pro vs Adrian a junior. The same is true of group rides.

Doge 12-28-15 01:36 PM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by EventServices (Post 18418936)
By now, I just assume that all of the KOMs in the world have been set using TT bikes on days with a gale-force tailwind by guys who specifically went out with one purpose: to set that particular KOM. (I don't count the KOMs that go up a hill because I'm old and fat and know better.)

So to draw conclusion about a cycling community based on Strava data is a moving target. You have no idea what you're up against. ...

To the subject of this thread - it may very well be regional / cultural.
For us, around here KOMountain means wind and TT bikes don't help a whole bunch. Most my son's best rides are group rides and reflect a break or bridge - and except two - a hill. That everyone else posting here has different experiences based I expect on location and also age does not mean that some kids aren't more excited about KOMs than race wins. Strava posting is part of the social media things they do and a way they can share with everyone else (who decided not to go watch the race) how they did. They also like to hunt for hardware.

There were some prior posts here reflecting opinions about non-sanctioned events. This is the Rogers Cup - a perpetual Cup for a non sanctioned event going back to 1976 (40 years). There are at least 10 National Champion names on this trophy. Pros, Cat 1s, USA U23 National team riders compete for it. I do not think there is a race in SoCal outside of the Tour of California, and Redlands that will give a rider as much local attention.
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=495512

PepeM 12-28-15 01:38 PM

My biggest pride is the KOMUP I held once. Extremely prestigious, wouldn't change it for anything.

Doge 12-28-15 01:40 PM


Originally Posted by PepeM (Post 18419241)
My biggest pride is the KOMUP I held once. Extremely prestigious, wouldn't change it for anything.

Which one?

indyfabz 12-28-15 01:41 PM

****

RPK79 12-28-15 01:42 PM


Originally Posted by indyfabz (Post 18419250)
****

It's kind of pizzled out now. I think it's just going to die on its own.

PepeM 12-28-15 01:43 PM


Originally Posted by Doge (Post 18419248)
Which one?

Try to take it away from me and I'll flag you.

EventServices 12-28-15 05:11 PM

Rich Meeker's name on that trophy is all the tarnish it needs.

Erzulis Boat 12-28-15 07:37 PM

I ride in So Cal.

I just learned about this KOM feature on Strava like 2 days ago. I checked the stats.

This whole thing about a "TT Bike in gale force tailwinds" to gain a Strava KOM, is pretty thin in my opinion.

If you ride in an area with a lot of hardcore cyclists, you are not going to KOM a single segment unless you are a beast, or on a scooter.

All the KOM times I checked on my usual haunts were impressive, and I really need to step up my game to even get top 20. It's all fun. :)

Doge 12-28-15 08:01 PM


Originally Posted by EventServices (Post 18419759)
Rich Meeker's name on that trophy is all the tarnish it needs.

Pretty cool when a 16 year old can beat the druggies don't you think? There are 3 sides.

I'm an admitted proud dad ... This is Rodgers Cup. The crew there was 2-3 pros, 6-7 Cat 1s, USA U23 team, and a World Tour Pro Teammate of Sagan's at the time and some juniors that knew there was an uphil finish and knew how to ride together.
It was all for fun and memorial of how deadly this sport can be. As this year's winner picked up the trophy (my son was rowing during the event) he mentioned it was the most prized SoCal possession.
https://vimeo.com/113866136

Doge 12-28-15 08:23 PM


Originally Posted by EventServices (Post 18418936)
B...TT bikes on days with a gale-force tailwind by guys who specifically went

Here is the one I posted about. It is now 58,000 attempts by 6,407 people. FYI the sprint is a wee over 22W/kg.
https://vimeo.com/106844288

anotherbrian 12-28-15 11:16 PM

I've got a KOMUP that I'm pretty pleased with -- I don't know if it is prestigious or not, but it's the only place nearby you can ride 62mi+ without having to legally stop.

colnago62 12-29-15 12:44 AM

On the track, 17-18 year old juniors do not have gear restrictions. Their times are no where near the times of the elite men and not in the same stratosphere as the World Cup riders.
USA Cycling National Records - USA Cycling

Doge 12-29-15 12:58 AM

Is that what this thread is about? I think a lot of that has to do with the mass of rider and the time it takes to build that mass.
Different sports favor different ages. Swimmer teens are pretty fast. Most KOMs for juniors are not on the flats or descents.

kbarch 12-29-15 10:06 AM


Originally Posted by Doge (Post 18416976)

More on communities.
SoCal has big group rides with 100ish riders weekends and others mid-week around 50ish (Como, Swamies, SDBC, Simi, Foodpark, Coffee Crew, Rose Bowl (forgot name), Bud's Ride, El Dorado Park, Great Park, New Years Day will be 500-1000 on coast Hwy - one pack). Europe has big race groups and big crowds (Belgium) watching but I have not seen the big group rides. The big group social aspect appears to be more an American (SoCal in particular) thing than Euro thing. Part of that may be the roads here/there, or maybe they save it for race day.

If you look a little closer at the classic Euro Strava segments of the famous riders and use that flyby feature http://labs.strava.com/flyby/viewer/...2&z=B&t=1MVzi2 you can see they are not often in groups.

Yes. Come to think of it, while we did, from time to time, see other roadies, sometimes in pairs, the only groups we ever encountered were racing teams.

cruiserhead 12-29-15 10:40 AM


Originally Posted by Doge (Post 18416976)
I understand that people value things differently. For me (proud racer dad/rec cyclist that used to compete) - a local KOM on a classic segment is something everyone you see (cycling wise) knows about and it is perpetual vs. a championship which is annual. I will be approached on rides about my son's KOMs while nothing is said - or they don't know about most race wins. I have no idea who the various SoCal State Champions are from year to year and most others don't either. But most SoCal cyclists know who has the Palomar KOM and most know the Cooks Como KOM.
A National Championship - yea, better than any Strava result. But some races are harder than National Championships to even get a top 10 - and those are not noticed. Get a KOM in those same races and my son's Facebook fills with friend requests.

More on communities.
SoCal has big group rides with 100ish riders weekends and others mid-week around 50ish (Como, Swamies, SDBC, Simi, Foodpark, Coffee Crew, Rose Bowl (forgot name), Bud's Ride, El Dorado Park, Great Park, New Years Day will be 500-1000 on coast Hwy - one pack). Europe has big race groups and big crowds (Belgium) watching but I have not seen the big group rides. The big group social aspect appears to be more an American (SoCal in particular) thing than Euro thing. Part of that may be the roads here/there, or maybe they save it for race day.

If you look a little closer at the classic Euro Strava segments of the famous riders and use that flyby feature http://labs.strava.com/flyby/viewer/...2&z=B&t=1MVzi2 you can see they are not often in groups.

about 98% of that is inaccurate
You're proud of your son and you listed some group rides. Those are facts.

cruiserhead 12-29-15 10:43 AM


Originally Posted by EventServices (Post 18419759)
Rich Meeker's name on that trophy is all the tarnish it needs.

There are a couple names on there that were "going well"...
These dopers taint everything.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:45 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.