Wheelset Evaluations (other variables to consider)
#1
Thread Starter
"Great One"
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 4,463
Likes: 0
From: Might as well be underwater because I make less drag than a torpedoE (no aero bars here though)
Wheelset Evaluations (other variables to consider)
Most of the time when I read wheelset comparsions the term "acceleration" comes up quite often.
One thing I have learned while researching hubs is that drag within the bearings is vastly different across the board. In fact, one wheelbuilder mentioned that the difference between the overbuilt Chris King hubset and the smaller American Classic front hub was quite noticeable. In fact, he said that if you were coasting down a hill with others and you had Chris Kings you would get left behind (due to bearing drag: differences in bearing surface area/tolerances)
In contrast, the smaller and no doubt more flexible American Classic hub almost wants to spin forever on the stand.
My point is that research in the hub quality of a wheelset is just as important as weight.
One thing I have learned while researching hubs is that drag within the bearings is vastly different across the board. In fact, one wheelbuilder mentioned that the difference between the overbuilt Chris King hubset and the smaller American Classic front hub was quite noticeable. In fact, he said that if you were coasting down a hill with others and you had Chris Kings you would get left behind (due to bearing drag: differences in bearing surface area/tolerances)
In contrast, the smaller and no doubt more flexible American Classic hub almost wants to spin forever on the stand.
My point is that research in the hub quality of a wheelset is just as important as weight.
Last edited by 53-11_alltheway; 05-07-05 at 01:00 PM.
#4
Senior Member

Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 18,138
Likes: 324
Bikes: 2 many
Originally Posted by 53-11_alltheway
Most of the time when I read wheelset comparsions the term "acceleration" comes up quite often.
One thing I have learned while researching hubs is that drag within the bearings is vastly different across the board. In fact, one wheelbuilder mentioned that the difference between the overbuilt Chris King hubset and the smaller American Classic front hub was quite noticeable. In fact, he said that if you were coasting down a hill with others and you had Chris Kings you would get left behind (due to bearing drag: differences in bearing surface area/tolerances)
In contrast, the smaller and no doubt more flexible American Classic hub almost wants to spin forever on the stand.
My point is that research in the hub quality of a wheelset is just as important as weight.
One thing I have learned while researching hubs is that drag within the bearings is vastly different across the board. In fact, one wheelbuilder mentioned that the difference between the overbuilt Chris King hubset and the smaller American Classic front hub was quite noticeable. In fact, he said that if you were coasting down a hill with others and you had Chris Kings you would get left behind (due to bearing drag: differences in bearing surface area/tolerances)
In contrast, the smaller and no doubt more flexible American Classic hub almost wants to spin forever on the stand.
My point is that research in the hub quality of a wheelset is just as important as weight.
#5
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 469
Likes: 0
From: Cental New Jersey
Bikes: Klein Quantum Pro
I agree with your point. I think, in general, we put way too much emphasis on the weight of various components instead of the engineering and quality of a component. Light does not always mean better. In addition, reviews are very subjective. What a reviewer finds to be great about a wheelset might really bother me. Other than actually trying a component at the LBS, I'm not sure there is a real good way of comparing products.
On a side note, I own a set of the American Classic hubs. They are wonderful pieces of engineering. It is true that they spin really nice. You can coast forever on these things. In addition, they are a no-brainer to disassemble and maintain.
On a side note, I own a set of the American Classic hubs. They are wonderful pieces of engineering. It is true that they spin really nice. You can coast forever on these things. In addition, they are a no-brainer to disassemble and maintain.
#6
Originally Posted by 53-11_alltheway
My point is that research in the hub quality of a wheelset is just as important as weight.
#9
Originally Posted by 53-11_alltheway
One thing I have learned while researching hubs is that drag within the bearings is vastly different across the board. In fact, one wheelbuilder mentioned that the difference between the overbuilt Chris King hubset and the smaller American Classic front hub was quite noticeable. In fact, he said that if you were coasting down a hill with others and you had Chris Kings you would get left behind (due to bearing drag: differences in bearing surface area/tolerances)
bearing drag <<< aero drag. if you're getting dropped on downhill coasting, its because you're fat.
#10
Thread Starter
"Great One"
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 4,463
Likes: 0
From: Might as well be underwater because I make less drag than a torpedoE (no aero bars here though)
Originally Posted by baxtefer
i call shena****ns.
bearing drag <<< aero drag. if you're getting dropped on downhill coasting, its because you're fat.
bearing drag <<< aero drag. if you're getting dropped on downhill coasting, its because you're fat.
As far as aero drag goes I guess it depends how fast you are going. If there was any bearing "drag" effect it would only be noticeable at very slow speeds where air-resistance is not great.
Originally Posted by The_Convert
I had thought of that before regarding kings hubs, however I wouldn't say they are low quality. 

Large bearing surface are combined with tight tolerances would be great for doing jumps on a mtn bike though.
Last edited by 53-11_alltheway; 05-08-05 at 06:15 PM.






