Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Clipless falling survey (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/592821-clipless-falling-survey.html)

Moffetts 10-12-09 10:26 PM

Several times, usually because I forgot that I was clipped in. I get distracted pretty easily. One time I clipped out but managed to clip back in before I stopped.

That one was a catastrophe.

Kneez 10-12-09 10:45 PM

I have never fallen with clipless pedals but I have fallen with toe clips, straps, and the old slotted cleats. It was a lot harder to get out of those quickly than it is now with clipless.

Rumpled 10-13-09 05:26 PM

I'm guessing umd must be a really good rider - even better than a US Champion :D

From George H's twitter today

"My wifes first bike crash with cleates on. She's fine. But let's see if she still wants to ride. This is fun.

And yes she was stopped. She did the tilt over crash we have all done."

So, looks like George would vote Yes.

rugerben 10-13-09 05:29 PM

Twice. Oddly, I've been ridding clipless for two years. The two times I've fallen were about 2 months ago, and last week. Go figure. 2 years incident free, and then two falls in such close proximity. I guess I'm getting sloppy.

trigger 10-13-09 05:31 PM

I voted yes, but it only happened once, and it was soon after I'd switched over. I was waiting at a light and some guy asked me to push the crosswalk button. I forgot that one foot was still clipped in, leaned over too far and couldn't get my foot out in time to stop myself from going over. So yeah, it was a clipless fall, but mostly it was an 'I'm-an-idiot' fall.

umd 10-13-09 05:37 PM


Originally Posted by Rumpled (Post 9852326)
I'm guessing umd must be a really good rider - even better than a US Champion :D

From George H's twitter today

"My wifes first bike crash with cleates on. She's fine. But let's see if she still wants to ride. This is fun.

And yes she was stopped. She did the tilt over crash we have all done."

So, looks like George would vote Yes.


It has nothing to do with "better", it just hasn't happened, just as it hasn't happened to over 1/4 of the other responders. I think nothing less of the people who have.

doorunrun 10-13-09 06:43 PM

I have to laugh at myself for my first day riding with road clips. I got the bike out of the car and wanted to coast a short distance. I had experience with MTB clips/shoes, and so I thought I could do it with my new road shoes and 105 pedals.
So I stood to one side (left) of the bike with the crank arm pointing down took a step or two, put my shoe on the pedal (left shoe just behind the cleat) and coasted......about 3 feet where upon my foot slipped off, I got off balance and the bike and I went down with me on the bottom. Oh the shame of it! I won't be trying that again soon. Why in the hell do they make the sole so slick?

cranky old road 10-13-09 07:34 PM

Haven't with Speedplay X's in the 10 years I've used them. Did with clips and straps a couple of times.

Bontrager 10-13-09 08:12 PM

Everyone that voted "no" is lying.

umd 10-13-09 08:19 PM


Originally Posted by Bontrager (Post 9853422)
Everyone that voted "no" is lying.

everyone who thinks that is a moron

Rob P. 10-13-09 08:22 PM

I have fallen while clipped in. However, that fall was not "because of" my pedals. It was because I was tired at the end of a ride and stupidly tried to track stand at a light without really knowing how.

At the time my pedals were old Look delta's. My current pedals are Ultegra SL's.

Lost Rider 10-13-09 08:46 PM

I fell recently for the first time, after about 1,000 miles of successful use. I was behind two other riders, barely moving (off the road), fiddling with the settings on my Garmin, when I looked up and saw they had stopped. Down I went before I could react. I was actually starting to think I would be one of the ones that wouldn't fall! :lol:

oldbobcat 10-14-09 10:42 PM

Yes. And that was while leaning against my car in the garage, testing the adjustments I just made to my saddle position.

Now if you want to talk about tipping over in toeclips and slotted cleats . . .

johnileo61 10-15-09 05:15 AM

Happened just once. Pulled up to a stop light (red) towards the end of a 60+ mile solo ride... unclipped the wrong foot and "T-I-MMMMM-B-E-RRRR!!!!!!" It was like in slo-mo, too. Managed to get my left hand out to cushion the blow as I went over to the left (into traffic... but everybody was stopped so no biggie). Somehow twisted my left ankle badly as a result and ended up with a grade-2 sprain. Rode home and walking was no fun for a couple weeks afterwards. Riding was OK though... just a chore remembering to unclip out of the OTHER pedal for that time.

Nasty scratch on my Ultegra 6620 pedal but no other damage... other than my ankle and ego.

MissKristen 10-15-09 07:07 AM

I voted yes, however...it wasn't because of my pedals; it was because I was going up a steep hill in the wrong gear, ran out of steam and came to a complete stop, THEN fell over (head-first, downhill... awesome) because my feet weren't mobile. It was my own stupidity for not knowing how to climb a hill. I've never fallen over on flat pavement at a stop sign or light or anything though. Not yet, at least....

Edit: over the winter I'm going to attempt to teach myself how to track stand, so this answer will probably turn into a solid YES, I HAVE FALLEN BECAUSE OF MY CLIPLESS PEDALS

garboplex 10-15-09 07:21 AM

Never with so called "clipless" pedals.
Only ever fell learning with toe clips and cleats 30 years ago, back then you had to reach down and release the toe-straps before you could get out. Once at a traffic light and I went down. Twice at another light, but broke my fall on a car.

Debusama 10-15-09 07:31 AM

I fell a bunch of times on my mountain bike because I was accustomed to putting a foot down in certain situations. When I couldn’t get my foot off of the petal, I ended up on the ground. I’ve never fallen on road.

I was using crank brothers egg beater-c petals. On road, I use Crank Brothers
smarty.

Nachoman 10-15-09 07:57 AM

Yes. But only once about five years ago.

Vinci 10-15-09 08:10 AM

I've done it two or three times within the couple thousand miles since I started riding clipless last year. None of those occasions are the fault of the pedals, though. They were all occasions where I assumed that I wouldn't need to come to a complete stop, but ended up needing to at the last moment (hidden traffic, pedestrian, etc.). Unfortunately, I can't blame the pedals for my stupidity. :)

Tsuru 10-15-09 10:35 AM

Fell twice, but the clipless only slowed my ability to react. Both times it was my brain stopping & leaning left, which is what I always do, but the circumstances resulted in a right lean stop. Was so in my "muscle memory" moment, when I realized what was happening it was too late to react. No problem though, put my arm out and caught my fall on the ground so no biggie.

My wife fell twice because she couldn't unclip in time. I switched her to my used Look pedals that were REALLY broken in (too loose for me) and she had no problems since, now she's used to the motion and it's all good.

urbanknight 10-15-09 10:56 AM

Wow, over 1/3 of the responders have replied that they have never fallen. Even if half of them are lying, I'm starting to feel like a clutsy goofball.

stonecrd 10-15-09 11:42 AM

I use Ultegra SPD-SLs and I have not fallen in the 4 years I have been using them. I have been close a few times but I have always managed to get clipped out before falling. I think I have more issues getting clipped in after a stop, many times I have had to ride a bit before I could get clipped in and then had to chase up.

urbanknight 10-15-09 11:49 AM


Originally Posted by stonecrd (Post 9863337)
I think I have more issues getting clipped in after a stop, many times I have had to ride a bit before I could get clipped in and then had to chase up.

If you haven't gotten used to that in 4 years, you might be a good candidate for double-sided pedals such as Speedplay or Crank Bros.

stonecrd 10-15-09 11:51 AM


Originally Posted by urbanknight (Post 9863386)
If you haven't gotten used to that in 4 years, you might be a good candidate for double-sided pedals such as Speedplay or Crank Bros.

I wouldn't say I am hopeless but my daily ride has probably 4 stops and in a week I may struggle once or twice a week getting clipped in. Seems to occur a lot more when I am tired.

urbanknight 10-15-09 11:59 AM

Ahh. I guess that's not a big deal then.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:43 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.