Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Extremely low weight frame options (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/711766-extremely-low-weight-frame-options.html)

X-LinkedRider 02-06-11 01:27 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I have recently acquired a new contact and local Bike builder with his own stuff. You can't buy from him directly (I don't believe), you can certainly get in touch with him and he can tell you more. Totally great guy to deal with. (edit: His name is Tom)

http://superiorlitebikes.com/slproframe.php

This is the the one I am eying up for an eventual purchase.
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=188938

MajorMantra 02-06-11 01:36 PM


Originally Posted by FogVilleLad (Post 12186432)
I'm thinking of the CR1 as my next frame. What do you like better about the addict?

Just butting in, but the new CR1 is a more relaxed frame than the Addict. The old CR1 is sort of the predecessor of the Addict - it used to be the top of the line race frame.

Terex 02-06-11 02:06 PM


Originally Posted by MajorMantra (Post 12186539)
Just butting in, but the new CR1 is a more relaxed frame than the Addict. The old CR1 is sort of the predecessor of the Addict - it used to be the top of the line race frame.

I had the old CR1 Sl, now have an Addict R3 and a Parlee Z4. The '06 CR1 Sl was absolutely brilliant climbing and descending. I remember several distinct occasions climbing with the CR1 when I just laughed out loud, thinking that this was ridiculously easy. With the massive cross section front fork, it was an equally brilliant descender. Problem was, I wrapped the derailleur around the back end when the chain separated on one side of a link.

My '09 Addict is almost as good a ride, and appears to be a lot sturdier carbon build. The Parlee is even more impressive, in terms of build quality, but doesn't have the vibrancy of the Addict frame. I've ridden a Storck Absolutist 0.9 and I thought that the ride quality was terrible - like a block of wood.

If I was buying a light frame today, I'd like to try a C-Dale Super Six. From discussions with others, the ride quality is close to that of the Addict, and the carbon build quality appears to be much better. But I'd be tempted by an Addict R15, especially the 2010 white/gray model.

Right now, I'm interested in a cyclocross type frame, probably titanium, and I'd prefer to have disc brakes. But that's a different story.

2ndGen 02-06-11 02:22 PM


Originally Posted by Terex (Post 12186642)

If I was buying a light frame today, I'd like to try a C-Dale Super Six. .

I was going to ask what about the SuperSix HiMOD.
Since you did, I'll kick back and see if anyone has anything to offer.

sqharaway 02-06-11 02:26 PM


Originally Posted by Ben FR (Post 12184569)
Regarding your picture, this information is not easily googled. The manufacturers purposely avoid posting weights. Also, no good information on how to compare frames with integrated seatposts.

You might check reviews of the frames by competitive cyclist on youtube or their website. I know they have a video review for the Wilier Cento1 SL.

sqharaway 02-06-11 02:29 PM


Originally Posted by 2ndGen (Post 12186334)
Strongest sub-1000 gram frame?

The Wilier Cento1 SL may have a good case with Alexander Petacchi reaming on it in sprints. Plus, his bike is an awesome neon lime color, so that helps too...

twobadfish 02-06-11 02:41 PM

So my frame weighs 2.8lbs and I consider that pretty light... is there a point where structural integrity is sacrificed for weight?

MajorMantra 02-06-11 04:23 PM


Originally Posted by Terex (Post 12186642)
I had the old CR1 Sl, now have an Addict R3 and a Parlee Z4. The '06 CR1 Sl was absolutely brilliant climbing and descending. I remember several distinct occasions climbing with the CR1 when I just laughed out loud, thinking that this was ridiculously easy. With the massive cross section front fork, it was an equally brilliant descender. Problem was, I wrapped the derailleur around the back end when the chain separated on one side of a link.

My '09 Addict is almost as good a ride, and appears to be a lot sturdier carbon build. The Parlee is even more impressive, in terms of build quality, but doesn't have the vibrancy of the Addict frame. I've ridden a Storck Absolutist 0.9 and I thought that the ride quality was terrible - like a block of wood.

If I was buying a light frame today, I'd like to try a C-Dale Super Six. From discussions with others, the ride quality is close to that of the Addict, and the carbon build quality appears to be much better. But I'd be tempted by an Addict R15, especially the 2010 white/gray model.

Right now, I'm interested in a cyclocross type frame, probably titanium, and I'd prefer to have disc brakes. But that's a different story.

I've got a '10 R3 and I love it. I'm curious as to what you think is wrong with the build quality. Sure, some of the joins in the carbon are quite visible but I took that to mean that Scott hadn't wasted weight on making it cosmetically perfect. After all, what you see on the surface is only the tip of the iceberg.

Terex 02-06-11 05:22 PM


Originally Posted by MajorMantra (Post 12187139)
I've got a '10 R3 and I love it. I'm curious as to what you think is wrong with the build quality. Sure, some of the joins in the carbon are quite visible but I took that to mean that Scott hadn't wasted weight on making it cosmetically perfect. After all, what you see on the surface is only the tip of the iceberg.

My bike shop guy (BSG) sees lots of bikes. When I killed my CR1, Scott had a dealer cut out the bottom bracket as part of the crash replacement warrantee (or I would have sent it to Calfee for repair). I took it over to my BSG, and we did destructive testing. We stood on the frame until it broke. It didn't take much. The carbon build looked like paper mache.

When I brought in the Addict frame to be built up, a couple of the BSG's rode it. They both said that it was much more confidence inspiring than my old CR1 (which they'd also ridden), but not the same level of build quality as my Parlee or the C-Dales that they sell. I haven't ridden the C-Dale, but I absolutely trust the opinion of these guys. They see LOTS of bikes in their shop, and have the opportunity to do destructive testing on the frames of most manufacturers. A perk of their job.

And by build quality, I'm not talking about cosmetics. I'm talking about the quality of the carbon, the joining techniques, and those things that are usually hidden by a coat of paint. The cosmetic appearance of Scott bikes is good, as are the C-Dales. The cosmetic appearance, and the build quality of Parlee, OTOH, is superb.

All of these are terrific bikes that are reasonably priced. I think that the Addict R3 is one of the biggest performance values in cycling. If you buy a top of the line Parlee, or a Calfee or a Storck, you're talking about some serious money.

I guessing that the quality of carbon and the layup of a Calfee frame makes them pretty much bullet proof. And they do weigh more than a lot of top end bikes. With the lightest Scott, Parlee, Storck and C-Dale (among others), you're probably on the hairy end of structural integrity.

With the relatively low cost of the Scott Addicts, it only seem logical that sacrifices have been made. You know the saying, "Strong, light, cheap - pick two." The Scott is inexpensive and it's light. That's the two.

Schmadley 02-06-11 06:04 PM

Bike frames in general are getting lighter and lighter, but is there a resultant decrease in structural integrity - we will only find out in time.

What is amazing, is that there are COMPLETE bikes out there that are coming in at some amazing weights. Two that spring to mind are the Avanti Quantum Silver (http://www.avantibikes.com/race-perf...r.aspx?bid=431) - 5.6kg (12.35 lbs) and the new Focus Izalco Ultimate (http://www.focus-bikes.com/us/en_us/...googlebot=true) - 4.98kg (11 lbs).

I'm sure that there would be rider weight limits set for these bikes......


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:12 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.