Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Extremely low weight frame options (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/711766-extremely-low-weight-frame-options.html)

Ben FR 02-05-11 08:31 PM

Extremely low weight frame options
 
What are the options? Cost and weight too pls.

Parlee Z5 SL
Cervelo R5ca and R5
Pinarello Dogma
Wilier?
Scott Addict R1
Guru Photon

For the frames that have integrated seat posts, can you help me understand what the weight differences are on an apples to apples basis?

2ndGen 02-05-11 08:36 PM

Parlee & Gure.
Forget the rest.

As for cost & weight of each?

http://tinyurl.com/6beuvzq

Ben FR 02-05-11 08:40 PM

Regarding your picture, this information is not easily googled. The manufacturers purposely avoid posting weights. Also, no good information on how to compare frames with integrated seatposts.

2ndGen 02-05-11 08:43 PM


Originally Posted by Ben FR (Post 12184569)
Regarding your picture, this information is not easily googled. The manufacturers purposely avoid posting weights.

A) http://weightweenies.starbike.com/li...ype=roadframes

B) http://tinyurl.com/6l4cfvf ------> First link: http://www.trisports.com/scott-addict-r1.html

Scott Addict R1 Road Frame Set
Frame weight: 790 grams
Regular price: $2,999.95


Took me all of .26 seconds.

(works for me) :D

cyclebycle13 02-05-11 09:08 PM

Having purchased a new frameset this summer, I was doing quite a bit of research on the guru photon, parlee z5, cervelos and various addict models.

I've seen a few reports of guru photons developing cracks. Only a few, but how many of them are out there. Also, depending on the frame size, once you get above a 54cm, they're not "superlight" anymore.
I've only read of 1 problem with a parlee z5, I was saving for one until I found a scott addict sl frameset for less than 1500. That was, without a doubt, as good a price to weight ratio as I was going to get- the frame came in at 810g (54cm) and the fork was under 300g once I cut the steerer tube. Since I previously had a scott cr1 sl, it was a no brainer.

I test rode the cervelo r3sl and was unimpressed, especially for the price. But, this is what worked for me. The other frame mentioned never came to mind- I'm too much of a weight weenie and they were too heavy (and too expensive)-- besides, the ride of the addict is incredible- so much better than the cr1 sl.

electusunus 02-05-11 09:15 PM

Are you planning to use the bike for only climbing?

2ndGen 02-05-11 09:20 PM


Originally Posted by cyclebycle13 (Post 12184656)
Having purchased a new frameset this summer, I was doing quite a bit of research on the guru photon, parlee z5, cervelos and various addict models.

I've seen a few reports of guru photons developing cracks. Only a few, but how many of them are out there. Also, depending on the frame size, once you get above a 54cm, they're not "superlight" anymore.
I've only read of 1 problem with a parlee z5, I was saving for one until I found a scott addict sl frameset for less than 1500. That was, without a doubt, as good a price to weight ratio as I was going to get- the frame came in at 810g (54cm) and the fork was under 300g once I cut the steerer tube. Since I previously had a scott cr1 sl, it was a no brainer.

I test rode the cervelo r3sl and was unimpressed, especially for the price. But, this is what worked for me. The other frame mentioned never came to mind- I'm too much of a weight weenie and they were too heavy (and too expensive)-- besides, the ride of the addict is incredible- so much better than the cr1 sl.

Weight of your built Addict?

3kmi 02-05-11 10:29 PM

Why you would include a Pinarello of any sort or a Wilier is completely beyond me. Super six is significantly lighter. Other custom options like a Crumpton SL are great too

twobadfish 02-05-11 10:32 PM

You have a target weight in mind for the finished bike?

nacler22 02-05-11 11:30 PM

Might want to include the Storck Fascenario 0.7 or 0.6 on your list.

M_FactorX19 02-06-11 12:57 AM

scott addict end of search!

NathanC 02-06-11 01:38 AM

Low frame weight and Dogma do not go hand in hand.

Tapeworm21 02-06-11 03:31 AM

Is weight the only thing you're considering? Because ride quality is "kinda" important too.

rollin 02-06-11 05:44 AM


Originally Posted by Tapeworm21 (Post 12185339)
Is weight the only thing you're considering? Because ride quality is "kinda" important too.

who said anything about riding the bloody thing? ;)

WHOOOSSHHH... 02-06-11 06:38 AM


Originally Posted by x43x (Post 12184902)
My ti frame is lighter than the Dogma

I didn't know you had a Ti frame? ;)

roadiejorge 02-06-11 07:25 AM


Originally Posted by rollin (Post 12185435)
who said anything about riding the bloody thing? ;)

Indeed. Well it should be comfortable enough to get you to the coffee shop.

;)

2ndGen 02-06-11 11:09 AM

Looks like the Guru gets some bad reviews as far as quality goes.
Complaints of breakage and refusal of Guru to honor warranty.

I_Like_Bike 02-06-11 11:18 AM


Originally Posted by Tapeworm21 (Post 12185339)
Is weight the only thing you're considering? Because ride quality is "kinda" important too.

but you can't measure/quantify ride quality.

WhyFi 02-06-11 11:20 AM


Originally Posted by roadiejorge (Post 12185544)
Indeed. Well it should be comfortable enough to get you to the coffee shop.

;)

Most coffee shops don't meet my standards - I make my own espresso at home. The bike only needs to hang on the wall in my loft/converted warehouse space. Frame color is important - must complement the Basquiat on the wall perpendicular.

2ndGen 02-06-11 11:33 AM


Originally Posted by WhyFi (Post 12186144)
Most coffee shops don't meet my standards - I make my own espresso at home. The bike only needs to hang on the wall in my loft/converted warehouse space. Frame color is important - must complement the Basquiat on the wall perpendicular.

OT, but yeah, me too...Bustelo for me. :D

Triguy 02-06-11 11:38 AM

Crumpton SL - I think around $4K, weight will vary on what you tell Nick you want
Ibis Silk SL (in clear coat, i.e. not the red or green) - $1700, come in around 850-8750 grams for the 55cm

WhyFi 02-06-11 12:20 PM


Originally Posted by 2ndGen (Post 12186183)
OT, but yeah, me too...Bustelo for me. :D

The rest was BS, but I actually am a coffee super snob.

2ndGen 02-06-11 12:25 PM


Originally Posted by WhyFi (Post 12186323)

I roll "old school"! :D ------> http://www.grupogangas.es/images/cafetera%209.jpg

2ndGen 02-06-11 12:26 PM

Strongest sub-1000 gram frame?

FogVilleLad 02-06-11 01:09 PM


Originally Posted by cyclebycle13 (Post 12184656)
I found a scott addict sl frameset for less than 1500. That was, without a doubt, as good a price to weight ratio as I was going to get. Since I previously had a scott cr1 sl, it was a no brainer....
besides, the ride of the addict is incredible- so much better than the cr1 sl.

I'm thinking of the CR1 as my next frame. What do you like better about the addict?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:47 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.