Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Campagnolo vs Shimano (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/904602-campagnolo-vs-shimano.html)

hockeyguy 07-30-13 05:25 PM

Campagnolo vs Shimano
 
Is there a comparison? Are Campagnolo shifters, brakes, derailleurs better than Shimano?

Thanks

banerjek 07-30-13 05:29 PM


Originally Posted by hockeyguy (Post 15905924)
Is there a comparison? Are Campagnolo shifters, brakes, derailleurs better than Shimano?

Thanks

You forgot to mention SRAM.

But there is no comparison between any of them. That's why nobody even tries.

SSRI 07-30-13 06:25 PM

lets throw in Microshift...

escarpment 07-30-13 06:29 PM

Mavic made components for a bit.

Its like asking who makes the better car. Everyone has their own opinions. None is inherently better than the other.

rpenmanparker 07-30-13 06:45 PM

And if it stopped here...

gregf83 07-30-13 07:09 PM

yes

stilltooslow 07-30-13 07:19 PM

What everyone's trying to say is:

They're all good, and they're all different.

Just a matter of preference.

RollCNY 07-30-13 07:24 PM


Originally Posted by stilltooslow (Post 15906375)
What everyone's trying to say is:

Campagnolo is vastly superior.

FIFY :thumb:

rpenmanparker 07-30-13 07:39 PM

What did I tell you? The C people just can't contain themselves. They have an unproveable contention, but just can't stop foisting it on us. Must be an inferiority complex, huh? We all feel the same about our own favorites, but only the big C inspires such BS. Everybody else says they are all the same, it is just what turns you on. But nooooo! Not Italo-poop. I just can't stand it. It's not the goods I don't like, it is the attitude.

RollCNY 07-30-13 07:44 PM

Lighten up Francis. I picked Campy randomly, and could have just as easily said Microshift.

And [MENTION=242346]stilltooslow[/MENTION], I only corrupted your quote to be playful.

Voodoo76 07-30-13 07:48 PM

Compared to even 15 years ago It's all pretty much flawless. I touch lever and bike shifts, even under power. I'm never rattling between gears, grinding on Front D cage, shifting into my spokes, dropping chain, "auto shifting" under power, ect, ect. So I guess it boils down to which flawless is better, splittin hairs. :)

stilltooslow 07-30-13 08:02 PM


Originally Posted by RollCNY (Post 15906531)
And @stilltooslow, I only corrupted your quote to be playful.

I know. Got a chuckle out of it! : - )

Homebrew01 07-30-13 08:07 PM


Originally Posted by rpenmanparker (Post 15906505)
What did I tell you? The C people just can't contain themselves. They have an unproveable contention, but just can't stop foisting it on us. Must be an inferiority complex, huh? We all feel the same about our own favorites, but only the big C inspires such BS. Everybody else says they are all the same, it is just what turns you on. But nooooo! Not Italo-poop. I just can't stand it. It's not the goods I don't like, it is the attitude.

Off your meds ?

Homebrew01 07-30-13 08:09 PM


Originally Posted by SSRI (Post 15906169)
lets throw in Microshift...



Current stuff looks nice. Only seen the pictures.

rpenmanparker 07-30-13 08:18 PM


Originally Posted by Homebrew01 (Post 15906666)
Off your meds ?

Nah. You don't want to see me off my meds!

Seriously, just wait. This ain't over yet.

Homebrew01 07-30-13 08:23 PM


Originally Posted by rpenmanparker (Post 15906706)
Nah. You don't want to see me off my meds!

Seriously, just wait. This ain't over yet.

No doubt .... 7 pages ?

RollCNY 07-30-13 08:24 PM

OP, people will compare weight, which is the only objective measurement available. And it is a useless objective measure.

All else is subjective.

rpenmanparker 07-30-13 08:35 PM

Okay, I will admit my ignorance. I have been reading posts mentioning Microshift for a long time, but have no idea what it is. So...what is it?

vwchad 07-30-13 08:35 PM

:popcorn

vwchad 07-30-13 08:36 PM


Originally Posted by rpenmanparker (Post 15906770)
Okay, I will admit my ignorance. I have been reading posts mentioning Microshift for a long time, but have no idea what it is. So...what is it?

Shifters for very small hands.....

RollCNY 07-30-13 08:36 PM

It is another manufacturer that is fully Shimano compatible, except for the newest brake travel.

canam73 07-30-13 08:43 PM


Originally Posted by RollCNY (Post 15906779)
It is another manufacturer that is fully Shimano compatible, except for the newest brake travel.

Also, they make the Nashbar/Performance house brand shifters and derailleurs along with the stuff Sampson & Sunrace markets. Basically, any brifter you can find that isn't SRAM, Shimano or Campy.

They are available on low end Felts under their own name.

h2oxtc 07-30-13 10:42 PM


Originally Posted by banerjek (Post 15905940)
You forgot to mention SRAM.

But there is no comparison between any of them. That's why nobody even tries.

Agreed - no point in comparing.

Simple solution is to have at least one bike with each system. You'll learn to like them all. I do.

halfspeed 07-30-13 11:37 PM


Originally Posted by rpenmanparker (Post 15906505)
What did I tell you? The C people just can't contain themselves. They have an unproveable contention, but just can't stop foisting it on us. Must be an inferiority complex, huh? We all feel the same about our own favorites, but only the big C inspires such BS. Everybody else says they are all the same, it is just what turns you on. But nooooo! Not Italo-poop. I just can't stand it. It's not the goods I don't like, it is the attitude.

I rent bikes pretty frequently when I travel. Invariably they are Shimano equipped. I'm riding a Scott CR1 with Ultegra this week. Every time I ride a Shimano equipped bike, I remind my friends to slap me silly if I ever mull the idea of buying one. It's just my preference, but it's a strong one that doesn't seem to be moving with exposure.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:07 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.