Go deep or not?
#26
Middle-Aged Member
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 2,276
Likes: 1
From: Mesa, AZ
Bikes: Bianchi Infinito CV 2014, TREK HIFI 2011, Argon18 E-116 2013
I went with Boyd 58 wheels and love em. Super sexy look and the wide profile makes the ride nice and cushy with my 25c GP4Ks. I am in total agreement with others on here; just because AERO only makes a few seconds difference in the 40k times, doesn't mean they aren't worth it. I love my wheels and how they look. My friends love checken' em out too. We are all consumerists so there's no issue; none of us are retro-grouches so there's no problem there either
.
.
#27
Senior Member
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 2,435
Likes: 3
From: Pittsburgh, PA
Bikes: Colnago, Cervelo, Scott
I want to see how aero jerseys compare to skin suits, actual race-cut jerseys, and regular euro-fit as opposed to the over-sized club fit straw man and if I can't find data am tempted to play with my power meter and rchung's virtual elevation model to estimate CdA.
Along those lines, while I agree about body position probably being the most important thing, in road racing, being in the most aero position possible is not really practical or even doable a lot of the time, at least when you're talking about road races and crits. The nice things about clothing, wheels, frame, etc. is that they're all aero all the time even when you're not or can't be.
#28
Administrator

Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 13,655
Likes: 2,706
From: Delaware shore
Bikes: Cervelo C5, Guru Photon, Waterford, Specialized CX
#29
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 1,476
Likes: 30
From: Apopka, Florida
Bikes: Santa Cruz Stigmata
Good replies, thanks! While I agree that I'll probably never take full advantage of a nice set of aero wheels, I believe they'll make me feel like riding faster. I like the look and if I can gain any advantage at all that would be a plus. I've been making strides to get lower on the bike and have the stem flipped with only one 5mm spacer below so I'm about as low as I can go aerodynamically speaking. As far as clothes go, there's only so far a slightly overweight 43 year old man can go when it comes to kit fit, I don't ever see myself in a skin suit but have gotten comfortable wearing my lg bibs and a snug Cannondale jersey so again about as far as I'm willing to go for the sake of aerodynamics. A new helmet sounds like a good place to start, I'm currently running a Specialized Echelon II which I chose because it actually fits my oversize melon quite nicely but maybe it's time to look around for something a bit more streamlined? I haven't completely ruled out a lighter set of wheels just yet, I still like the thought of having some Hed's or H+Son's built up or possibly trying something like the American Classic Argent's which are wide, tubeless, light (1392g), 30mm deep, and they claim to have an aero advantage due to the way the tire profile fits the rim?
#30
Good replies, thanks! While I agree that I'll probably never take full advantage of a nice set of aero wheels, I believe they'll make me feel like riding faster. I like the look and if I can gain any advantage at all that would be a plus. I've been making strides to get lower on the bike and have the stem flipped with only one 5mm spacer below so I'm about as low as I can go aerodynamically speaking. As far as clothes go, there's only so far a slightly overweight 43 year old man can go when it comes to kit fit, I don't ever see myself in a skin suit but have gotten comfortable wearing my lg bibs and a snug Cannondale jersey so again about as far as I'm willing to go for the sake of aerodynamics. A new helmet sounds like a good place to start, I'm currently running a Specialized Echelon II which I chose because it actually fits my oversize melon quite nicely but maybe it's time to look around for something a bit more streamlined? I haven't completely ruled out a lighter set of wheels just yet, I still like the thought of having some Hed's or H+Son's built up or possibly trying something like the American Classic Argent's which are wide, tubeless, light (1392g), 30mm deep, and they claim to have an aero advantage due to the way the tire profile fits the rim?
stop the aero advantage thought process already. Get the wheels if you think that they will make your bike look sexy and if they euphoria will help you pedal faster and or ride more then it's a "win win". But stop with the pretense of getting an aero advantage. The best riders in the world would gain seconds over a 40K distance, where does that leave you and the rest of us.
You will get better "aero" if you adjust your posture on the bike. And for the record I am an over weight 42y/o looking to get sexy wheel also.
#31
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2014
Posts: 2,977
Likes: 5
From: Columbia, SC
Bikes: 2014 Cannondale Synapse Carbon 4 Rival; 2014 Cannondale Trail 7 29; 1972 Schwinn Suburban, 1996 Proflex 756, 1987(?) Peugeot, Dahon Speed P8; 1979 Raleigh Competition GS; 1995 Stumpjumper M2 FS, 1978 Raleigh Sports, Schwinn Prologue
#32
Thread Killer

Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 13,144
Likes: 2,167
From: Ann Arbor, MI
Bikes: 15 Kinesis Racelight 4S, 76 Motebecane Gran Jubilée, 17 Dedacciai Gladiatore2, 12 Breezer Venturi, 09 Dahon Mariner, 12 Mercier Nano, 95 DeKerf Team SL, 19 Tern Rally, 21 Breezer Doppler Cafe+, 19 T-Lab X3, 91 Serotta CII, 23 3T Strada
I dunno, but while it's hard to absolutely isolate aero advantage, I set all my PRs on my Argent wheelset, which I swap between Ksyrium Equipes on one bike, while I have another bike with either Velocity Aeroheat or Mavic Open Pros rims. Regardless of the mix-n-match, PRs all belong to Argents.
I'm firmly of the opinion that aero helps carry speed and allow a higher average during recovery or sub-max efforts, which then allow longer, harder max efforts. If I can drop back to Tempo and shave another 5-10bpm, I'll last longer and have more punch for efforts. Aero wheels are like Viagra, you see?
It's almost impossible to look at a typical ride and quantify what you did with the extra energy; I might average 19.2mph over 50mi @ 1.7k ft elevation one day, but grab a segment PR another day over the same ride while averaging 18mph. Does the lower average mean the aero didn't help? Of course not. Could've been weather, traffic, or just the goals of the ride.
Like Silvercivic27 said, the beauty of aero wheels is that they're at your service anytime you want to take advantage of them. I don't need to ride as hard as possible all the time on every single ride to derive benefit, so while I might make several seconds on a 40km TT, I'm happy to take two seconds on my favorite 1.5 mile segment when I drop the hammer and go for it. Netting than one PR is all the result I need to know the package is working.
I'm firmly of the opinion that aero helps carry speed and allow a higher average during recovery or sub-max efforts, which then allow longer, harder max efforts. If I can drop back to Tempo and shave another 5-10bpm, I'll last longer and have more punch for efforts. Aero wheels are like Viagra, you see?

It's almost impossible to look at a typical ride and quantify what you did with the extra energy; I might average 19.2mph over 50mi @ 1.7k ft elevation one day, but grab a segment PR another day over the same ride while averaging 18mph. Does the lower average mean the aero didn't help? Of course not. Could've been weather, traffic, or just the goals of the ride.
Like Silvercivic27 said, the beauty of aero wheels is that they're at your service anytime you want to take advantage of them. I don't need to ride as hard as possible all the time on every single ride to derive benefit, so while I might make several seconds on a 40km TT, I'm happy to take two seconds on my favorite 1.5 mile segment when I drop the hammer and go for it. Netting than one PR is all the result I need to know the package is working.
#33
Old Fart
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 3,348
Likes: 3
From: Bumpkinsville
Bikes: '97 Klein Quantum '16 Gravity Knockout
stop the aero advantage thought process already. Get the wheels if you think that they will make your bike look sexy and if they euphoria will help you pedal faster and or ride more then it's a "win win". But stop with the pretense of getting an aero advantage. The best riders in the world would gain seconds over a 40K distance, where does that leave you and the rest of us.
You will get better "aero" if you adjust your posture on the bike. And for the record I am an over weight 42y/o looking to get sexy wheel also.
You will get better "aero" if you adjust your posture on the bike. And for the record I am an over weight 42y/o looking to get sexy wheel also.
Is my aero Venge faster? Yes...because i tend to puit more effort into it and hit the hills harder, since it is a "fast bike". If I try doing the same on my old Klein, it is just as fast.
#34
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 6,341
Likes: 326
From: Mountain View, CA USA and Golden, CO USA
Bikes: 97 Litespeed, 50-39-30x13-26 10 cogs, Campagnolo Ultrashift, retroreflective rims on SON28/PowerTap hubs
From Drag difference between a normal bike/bibs and a tri suit?: Triathlon Forum: Slowtwitch Forums
So for example, we have club cut, race cut, and aero jerseys. Club cut is a casual ride jersey. The race cut is a more fitted version of the club cut, while the aero jerseys use a stretch polyester on the sleeves and are skin-fit. Pro cyclists normally wear aero jerseys all the time.
We have a 16k flat course to test our jerseys, nothing overly scientific, but it does produce some interesting data. At the last runs, the aero jerseys saved an average of 20 seconds, so assuming a constant, it comes to 50 seconds over a 40k course, over the club cut. And tri suits clocked slightly faster times than aero jerseys. But the more impressive savings came on days with heavy headwinds. There the aero jersey did an average of 28 seconds better than the club cut on our 16k course, so 1:10 over a 40k course. The tri suit again did the best, averaging about 31 sec better, or 1:17 over the club cut on a 40k course. Again, this was not wind-tunnel precision, but the only variable was the apparel and we did 3 runs, taking the average.
We have a 16k flat course to test our jerseys, nothing overly scientific, but it does produce some interesting data. At the last runs, the aero jerseys saved an average of 20 seconds, so assuming a constant, it comes to 50 seconds over a 40k course, over the club cut. And tri suits clocked slightly faster times than aero jerseys. But the more impressive savings came on days with heavy headwinds. There the aero jersey did an average of 28 seconds better than the club cut on our 16k course, so 1:10 over a 40k course. The tri suit again did the best, averaging about 31 sec better, or 1:17 over the club cut on a 40k course. Again, this was not wind-tunnel precision, but the only variable was the apparel and we did 3 runs, taking the average.
Louis Garneau XS pro-fit, quite nice at a relaxed pace. They don't make a smaller size, and it would have fit issues in the shoulders or due to length if they did.
Louis Garneau XS skin-fit, for high-speed:
I'd love a comparison of that sort of difference, on a road bike without aero bars, at a more typical 20-22 MPH solo speed.
Last edited by Drew Eckhardt; 03-03-15 at 11:24 AM.
#35
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 231
Likes: 0
From: Beyond the Sun
Bikes: Cannondale Supersix Evo HiMod - Sram Red
stop the aero advantage thought process already. Get the wheels if you think that they will make your bike look sexy and if they euphoria will help you pedal faster and or ride more then it's a "win win". But stop with the pretense of getting an aero advantage. The best riders in the world would gain seconds over a 40K distance, where does that leave you and the rest of us.
You will get better "aero" if you adjust your posture on the bike. And for the record I am an over weight 42y/o looking to get sexy wheel also.
You will get better "aero" if you adjust your posture on the bike. And for the record I am an over weight 42y/o looking to get sexy wheel also.
The ironic part about the whole "aero wheels to make me look and feel sexier so I will ride more" is, to most everyone else, seeing an overweight, out of shape middle aged guy on aero wheels (especially the ones plastered with giant decals) makes them look WORSE than riding regular ones. Unless you really look the part of a fit, fast, strong cyclist then wheels like that make everyone look like a poser, IMO. And of course, we make our bikes look sexy for the benefit of everyone else out there, don't we? Think about it. If you were alone on a deserted island with no one else to see you and your bike, would you really bother with "visual upgrades"? I know I wouldn't. I don't as it is in a local area with many dozens of other people out there every day.
Co-incidentally, when one does look the part enough to be able to "get away" with that look, said person is also usually fast enough to actually reap some of the benefits.
I desire to keep my bike as understated looking as possible, if you hadn't already figured that out. I'm not fast or strong either, btw.
Last edited by rideBjj; 03-03-15 at 12:12 PM. Reason: for clarity
#36
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 6,682
Likes: 4
From: Above ground, Walnut Creek, Ca
Bikes: 8 ss bikes, 1 5-speed touring bike
I'll preface this by saying, no offense to OP and I'm not saying this is him, BUT
The ironic part about the whole "aero wheels to make me look and feel sexier so I will ride more" is, to most everyone else, seeing an overweight, out of shape middle aged guy on aero wheels (especially the ones plastered with giant decals) makes them look WORSE than riding regular ones. Unless you really look the part of a fit, fast, strong cyclist then wheels like that make everyone look like a poser, IMO. And of course, we make our bikes look sexy for the benefit of everyone else out there, don't we? Think about it. If you were alone on a deserted island with no one else to see you and your bike, would you really bother with "visual upgrades"? I know I wouldn't. I don't as it is in a local area with many dozens of other people out there every day.
Co-incidentally, when one does look the part enough to be able to "get away" with that look, said person is also usually fast enough to actually reap some of the benefits.
I desire to keep my bike as understated looking as possible, if you hadn't already figured that out. I'm not fast or strong either, btw.
The ironic part about the whole "aero wheels to make me look and feel sexier so I will ride more" is, to most everyone else, seeing an overweight, out of shape middle aged guy on aero wheels (especially the ones plastered with giant decals) makes them look WORSE than riding regular ones. Unless you really look the part of a fit, fast, strong cyclist then wheels like that make everyone look like a poser, IMO. And of course, we make our bikes look sexy for the benefit of everyone else out there, don't we? Think about it. If you were alone on a deserted island with no one else to see you and your bike, would you really bother with "visual upgrades"? I know I wouldn't. I don't as it is in a local area with many dozens of other people out there every day.
Co-incidentally, when one does look the part enough to be able to "get away" with that look, said person is also usually fast enough to actually reap some of the benefits.
I desire to keep my bike as understated looking as possible, if you hadn't already figured that out. I'm not fast or strong either, btw.
i get it.
#37
So the day to day variance in wind, how you feel, the elevation gain, blah blah blah, means the "noise" will usually swamp out any measured "gain" from aero wheels. I agree with others here, especially if you're not racing, that deeper wheels are mainly an exercise in making your bike pretty or aesthetically pleasing to yourself. Just get what's good looking to your eye and is within your personal budget. It's nice to ride a bike that you think looks good.
#38
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 1,476
Likes: 30
From: Apopka, Florida
Bikes: Santa Cruz Stigmata
I'll preface this by saying, no offense to OP and I'm not saying this is him, BUT
The ironic part about the whole "aero wheels to make me look and feel sexier so I will ride more" is, to most everyone else, seeing an overweight, out of shape middle aged guy on aero wheels (especially the ones plastered with giant decals) makes them look WORSE than riding regular ones. Unless you really look the part of a fit, fast, strong cyclist then wheels like that make everyone look like a poser, IMO. And of course, we make our bikes look sexy for the benefit of everyone else out there, don't we? Think about it. If you were alone on a deserted island with no one else to see you and your bike, would you really bother with "visual upgrades"? I know I wouldn't. I don't as it is in a local area with many dozens of other people out there every day.
Co-incidentally, when one does look the part enough to be able to "get away" with that look, said person is also usually fast enough to actually reap some of the benefits.
I desire to keep my bike as understated looking as possible, if you hadn't already figured that out. I'm not fast or strong either, btw.
The ironic part about the whole "aero wheels to make me look and feel sexier so I will ride more" is, to most everyone else, seeing an overweight, out of shape middle aged guy on aero wheels (especially the ones plastered with giant decals) makes them look WORSE than riding regular ones. Unless you really look the part of a fit, fast, strong cyclist then wheels like that make everyone look like a poser, IMO. And of course, we make our bikes look sexy for the benefit of everyone else out there, don't we? Think about it. If you were alone on a deserted island with no one else to see you and your bike, would you really bother with "visual upgrades"? I know I wouldn't. I don't as it is in a local area with many dozens of other people out there every day.
Co-incidentally, when one does look the part enough to be able to "get away" with that look, said person is also usually fast enough to actually reap some of the benefits.
I desire to keep my bike as understated looking as possible, if you hadn't already figured that out. I'm not fast or strong either, btw.
#39
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 508
Likes: 0
From: Kleinburg, ON
Aero wheels give you incremental speed. Just like a previous poster said, just like a aero helmet and according to specialized, if you have hairy legs, shaving them will give you the same benefits (at zero cost). All these little benefits add up to a significant time for racers, for recreational riders does it matter?
add aero full carbon wheels cause they look nice, if that has a placebo to make you ride faster and more, then it might be worth it.
add aero full carbon wheels cause they look nice, if that has a placebo to make you ride faster and more, then it might be worth it.
#40
Senior Member

Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 8,546
Likes: 5
From: Boulder, CO
So, since you haven't bought wheels yet...
I would recommend demoing some wheels if you possibly can, especially whatever you think you are going to buy. There's more than meets the eye - stiffness and how they handle in wind are hard to describe, if you can try them it would be good.
Also, make sure they fit in your frame, I have a Scott Plasma TT bike that I can't put my Zipp 303 front wheel on, the frame is too narrow.
I would recommend demoing some wheels if you possibly can, especially whatever you think you are going to buy. There's more than meets the eye - stiffness and how they handle in wind are hard to describe, if you can try them it would be good.
Also, make sure they fit in your frame, I have a Scott Plasma TT bike that I can't put my Zipp 303 front wheel on, the frame is too narrow.
#41
Senior Member
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 2,330
Likes: 2
From: Antioch, IL
Bikes: 2013 Synapse 4
Go deep
go balls deep.
go balls deep.
#42
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 1,476
Likes: 30
From: Apopka, Florida
Bikes: Santa Cruz Stigmata
So, since you haven't bought wheels yet...
I would recommend demoing some wheels if you possibly can, especially whatever you think you are going to buy. There's more than meets the eye - stiffness and how they handle in wind are hard to describe, if you can try them it would be good.
Also, make sure they fit in your frame, I have a Scott Plasma TT bike that I can't put my Zipp 303 front wheel on, the frame is too narrow.
I would recommend demoing some wheels if you possibly can, especially whatever you think you are going to buy. There's more than meets the eye - stiffness and how they handle in wind are hard to describe, if you can try them it would be good.
Also, make sure they fit in your frame, I have a Scott Plasma TT bike that I can't put my Zipp 303 front wheel on, the frame is too narrow.
#43
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2014
Posts: 1,206
Likes: 3
From: Cascadia
Bikes: Jamis Quest Comp
I'll preface this by saying, no offense to OP and I'm not saying this is him, BUT
The ironic part about the whole "aero wheels to make me look and feel sexier so I will ride more" is, to most everyone else, seeing an overweight, out of shape middle aged guy on aero wheels (especially the ones plastered with giant decals) makes them look WORSE than riding regular ones. Unless you really look the part of a fit, fast, strong cyclist then wheels like that make everyone look like a poser, IMO. And of course, we make our bikes look sexy for the benefit of everyone else out there, don't we? Think about it. If you were alone on a deserted island with no one else to see you and your bike, would you really bother with "visual upgrades"? I know I wouldn't. I don't as it is in a local area with many dozens of other people out there every day.
Co-incidentally, when one does look the part enough to be able to "get away" with that look, said person is also usually fast enough to actually reap some of the benefits.
I desire to keep my bike as understated looking as possible, if you hadn't already figured that out. I'm not fast or strong either, btw.
The ironic part about the whole "aero wheels to make me look and feel sexier so I will ride more" is, to most everyone else, seeing an overweight, out of shape middle aged guy on aero wheels (especially the ones plastered with giant decals) makes them look WORSE than riding regular ones. Unless you really look the part of a fit, fast, strong cyclist then wheels like that make everyone look like a poser, IMO. And of course, we make our bikes look sexy for the benefit of everyone else out there, don't we? Think about it. If you were alone on a deserted island with no one else to see you and your bike, would you really bother with "visual upgrades"? I know I wouldn't. I don't as it is in a local area with many dozens of other people out there every day.
Co-incidentally, when one does look the part enough to be able to "get away" with that look, said person is also usually fast enough to actually reap some of the benefits.
I desire to keep my bike as understated looking as possible, if you hadn't already figured that out. I'm not fast or strong either, btw.
#44
Senior Member
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 2,435
Likes: 3
From: Pittsburgh, PA
Bikes: Colnago, Cervelo, Scott
#45
Administrator

Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 13,655
Likes: 2,706
From: Delaware shore
Bikes: Cervelo C5, Guru Photon, Waterford, Specialized CX
#46
Having said all that, I just went for the maiden voyage on my new Reynold's assault wheels. I'm pretty convinced they pedaled themselves.
But real comments - they're not super deep by any means but I could definitely feel the wind on the front wheel, and I'm not a small cyclist either. The thing that surprised me was how flighty they felt bombing down a hill at a little over 40+. My AL clinchers felt much more stable at that speed, so that surprised me a little.
I was probably about a minute faster on my 13 mile route tonight than I was a week or two ago, and I included a little detour tonight to a public restroom. The fact that I was well rested probably had more to do with that than the actual wheels but I enjoyed the sensation of riding on them and pushed a little harder than I normally would. I don't want to be "that guy" you know.

I'll have to do some little scientific experiment, but I think I got some rear pad rub when I was out of the saddle climbing up a short but steepish hill. I say "think" because the traffic noise was challenging. The wheels are so true I put the brakes pretty close to the rim, certainly closer than they were on my other rims last time I rode. With only 24 spokes in the rear I guess that's to be expected.
$800 though, I really love 'em for that price.
#47
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 231
Likes: 0
From: Beyond the Sun
Bikes: Cannondale Supersix Evo HiMod - Sram Red
[QUOTE=TrojanHorse;17604771]I'm a little sad at how much influence everybody else has on your behavior & opinions.]
It's not as sad as how you carved up my post to try and make it look like it had the opposite meaning from what it did.
Did I hit a nerve? How many aero wheel sets and other items do you have that are carefully selected for aesthetic value? They all nicely match your team sky / raphpa / retro systeme-U kit? I bet you're just the belle of the ball at the group rides. Does your purse have an aero component, so it doesn't hold you back too much as it hangs jauntily from your arm?
It's not as sad as how you carved up my post to try and make it look like it had the opposite meaning from what it did.
Did I hit a nerve? How many aero wheel sets and other items do you have that are carefully selected for aesthetic value? They all nicely match your team sky / raphpa / retro systeme-U kit? I bet you're just the belle of the ball at the group rides. Does your purse have an aero component, so it doesn't hold you back too much as it hangs jauntily from your arm?
Last edited by rideBjj; 03-05-15 at 10:24 AM.
#48
Old Fart
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 3,348
Likes: 3
From: Bumpkinsville
Bikes: '97 Klein Quantum '16 Gravity Knockout
Now that deep wheels are "the look" and have become common, I'd much rather be different and old-school by riding my plain-old aluminum non-aero wheels. -and i wouldn't pay hundreds, or $1000 or more for wheels that don't do anything more than any other wheel....
#49
Thread Starter
Senior Member

Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 1,476
Likes: 30
From: Apopka, Florida
Bikes: Santa Cruz Stigmata
#50
It's not as sad as how you carved up my post to try and make it look like it had the opposite meaning from what it did.
Did I hit a nerve? How many aero wheel sets and other items do you have that are carefully selected for aesthetic value? They all nicely match your team sky / raphpa / retro systeme-U kit? I bet you're just the belle of the ball at the group rides. Does your purse have an aero component, so it doesn't hold you back too much as it hangs jauntily from your arm?





