Be Honest
#51
Not sure why you're getting so worked up? Honest opinions were asked for...honest opinions were given. It's sad that you get would get so butthurt from things you read on the internet.
Skids? I can probably count on one hand how many times I've skidded to stop all these years.
Regardless, knowing how to ride brakeless, just riding brakeless and riding with handbrakes are three distinct riding styles to me. And so yes, you're right...it's all about the riding, but if there's no distinction between the three, then how will anyone find information about riding brakeless if they're looking for it?
And you're right, someone can have a brake and never touch it for weeks...but there are also riders out there who ride their fixed just like a road bike, rely on their brake and ride brake-focused. Some of these riders are almost more dangerous than people who know how to ride brakeless.
Skids? I can probably count on one hand how many times I've skidded to stop all these years.
Regardless, knowing how to ride brakeless, just riding brakeless and riding with handbrakes are three distinct riding styles to me. And so yes, you're right...it's all about the riding, but if there's no distinction between the three, then how will anyone find information about riding brakeless if they're looking for it?
And you're right, someone can have a brake and never touch it for weeks...but there are also riders out there who ride their fixed just like a road bike, rely on their brake and ride brake-focused. Some of these riders are almost more dangerous than people who know how to ride brakeless.
#52
Judging someone based on whether they use a brake or not is just about as dumb as judging someone based on whether they are riding a conversion or a track frame.
You want to ride brakeless? Good on ya. But don't assume I can't properly control my bike, or that I'm lazy, just because I choose to ride with a brake. That's my call to make based on my riding *preferences*. I respect your choice to ride brakeless; respect my choice to ride with brakes.
You want to ride brakeless? Good on ya. But don't assume I can't properly control my bike, or that I'm lazy, just because I choose to ride with a brake. That's my call to make based on my riding *preferences*. I respect your choice to ride brakeless; respect my choice to ride with brakes.
#53
bigbris - Your comment that people who rode with brakes were unskilled / lazy may have struck a nerve and it was actually pretty trollish.
You may be confusing lazy and unskilled with being smart and proactive.
You may be confusing lazy and unskilled with being smart and proactive.
#54
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 2,760
Likes: 0
From: San Francisco
Bikes: Steelman eurocross, Surly CrossCheck, IRO Rob Roy...
1. Resourceful
2. Smart
2. Smart
#55
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 3,054
Likes: 4
Bikes: 2012 Motobecane Vent Noir; 2016 Mercier Kilo TT Pro
Oh, I wasn't *personally* disrespected even though my tone seems to imply as such. But I was speaking to these specific comments:
(Which is actually kinda silly in and of itself considering that track bikes don't belong on the street anyway; they belong on the track. If riding a track bike on the street is accepted, why isn't slapping a brake on a track bike accepted? But I digress.)
Again, I wasn't *personally* disrespected. However, I choose to run with a brake on a track bike (well, it's a Kilo TT; I'm perfectly fine admitting it's not a track bike and saying it's a bike with track ends and track-ish geometry), I am neither too scared nor too lazy to run without it, and I know how to control my bike very well, thank you for asking.
Originally Posted by bigbris1
It's just it seems like they're either too scared to be riding fixed gear, or too lazy.
Originally Posted by dueL
2) Handbrakes don't belong on track bikes...even if the track bike is being ridden on the street.
Originally Posted by IllSpecialist
Not hating on brakes but if you wanna ride fixed then you should KNOW how to control your bike no matter what the situation.
__________________
https://www.pedalroom.com/members/iamtim
https://www.pedalroom.com/members/iamtim
#56
extra bitter

Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,588
Likes: 7
Bikes: Miyata 210, Fuji Royale II, Bridgestone Kabuki, Miyata Ninety
However, I choose to run with a brake on a track bike (well, it's a Kilo TT; I'm perfectly fine admitting it's not a track bike and saying it's a bike with track ends and track-ish geometry), I am neither too scared nor too lazy to run without it, and I know how to control my bike very well, thank you for asking.
This thread is hilarious.
#57
I got a story for you about the time I learned not to use a master link on a FG:
One day I was riding down Fifth Ave on the downward hill between 40th & 34th. I was between 2 busses when my chain popped. The busses closed in & I was gaining momentum down the hill. 38th, 37th, 36th...I was on the white lines with a bus on either side in their lanes. I mean there was about 2 feet between the two busses, not counting me & my bike.
As we approached 34th Street the light turned red. I would have sailed thru one of the busiest intesections in NYC & probably been hit by a taxi & blown clear inside the Empire State Building! Instict kicked in-I sat up on the bike, grabbed on to the window frames of either bus & as they braked for the red light at 34th, I came to a halt. My legs were shaking so bad I could hardly walk the bike to the curb. Man, the adreneline!
You know, I think that many drivers believe we can just hit the brake & stop if need be, and they don't realize we're not stopping until we reach our destination. A large part of driving is anticipation what the next man will do before he does it. This holds true with riding in traffic. You have to see it before it happens. When you can master this, bye bye brake!
#58
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 2,760
Likes: 0
From: San Francisco
Bikes: Steelman eurocross, Surly CrossCheck, IRO Rob Roy...
#59
Keirin riders don't need brakes on the track so it would make sense they would need a brake on the road.
#60
NYC
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
From: NYC
Bike riding on any bike is dangerous, but assuming that riding fixed with a handbrake is ALWAYS less dangerous is wrong.
This forum has always passed off brakeless riders as clueless, unintelligent and illogical or just plain "hipsters" without ever asking why some of us will never use a handbrake on their track/fixed bikes.
#61
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 2,760
Likes: 0
From: San Francisco
Bikes: Steelman eurocross, Surly CrossCheck, IRO Rob Roy...
+1
I always ask myself if I should be riding with a brake, especially here in SF. But then I think, well if I need a brake then I have no business riding riding a track bike on the street. Not hating on brakes but if you wanna ride fixed then you should KNOW how to control your bike no matter what the situation.
I always ask myself if I should be riding with a brake, especially here in SF. But then I think, well if I need a brake then I have no business riding riding a track bike on the street. Not hating on brakes but if you wanna ride fixed then you should KNOW how to control your bike no matter what the situation.
Beginner sessions every Saturday.
#62

I imagine the false sense of security a person must have going faster than they would without a brake, only to squeeze their front brake in a panic moment & fly over the handlebars or lock up the front wheel & skid face first into the ground. To answer my own question, this is what I think. I would never ride any bike with only a front brake for that very reason.
#63
not aristotle
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 113
Likes: 0
From: Long Beach, CA
1. looks fun.
2. looks safe.
not much to hate about it
2. looks safe.
not much to hate about it
#64
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 3,054
Likes: 4
Bikes: 2012 Motobecane Vent Noir; 2016 Mercier Kilo TT Pro
That's what I'm on about; the prejudice (on both sides of this issue) frustrates me.
__________________
https://www.pedalroom.com/members/iamtim
https://www.pedalroom.com/members/iamtim
#65
I got a story for you about the time I learned not to use a master link on a FG:
One day I was riding down Fifth Ave on the downward hill between 40th & 34th. I was between 2 busses when my chain popped. The busses closed in & I was gaining momentum down the hill. 38th, 37th, 36th...I was on the white lines with a bus on either side in their lanes. I mean there was about 2 feet between the two busses, not counting me & my bike.
As we approached 34th Street the light turned red. I would have sailed thru one of the busiest intesections in NYC & probably been hit by a taxi & blown clear inside the Empire State Building! Instict kicked in-I sat up on the bike, grabbed on to the window frames of either bus & as they braked for the red light at 34th, I came to a halt. My legs were shaking so bad I could hardly walk the bike to the curb. Man, the adreneline!
You know, I think that many drivers believe we can just hit the brake & stop if need be, and they don't realize we're not stopping until we reach our destination. A large part of driving is anticipation what the next man will do before he does it. This holds true with riding in traffic. You have to see it before it happens. When you can master this, bye bye brake!
One day I was riding down Fifth Ave on the downward hill between 40th & 34th. I was between 2 busses when my chain popped. The busses closed in & I was gaining momentum down the hill. 38th, 37th, 36th...I was on the white lines with a bus on either side in their lanes. I mean there was about 2 feet between the two busses, not counting me & my bike.
As we approached 34th Street the light turned red. I would have sailed thru one of the busiest intesections in NYC & probably been hit by a taxi & blown clear inside the Empire State Building! Instict kicked in-I sat up on the bike, grabbed on to the window frames of either bus & as they braked for the red light at 34th, I came to a halt. My legs were shaking so bad I could hardly walk the bike to the curb. Man, the adreneline!
You know, I think that many drivers believe we can just hit the brake & stop if need be, and they don't realize we're not stopping until we reach our destination. A large part of driving is anticipation what the next man will do before he does it. This holds true with riding in traffic. You have to see it before it happens. When you can master this, bye bye brake!
If you are going to ride brakeless you should practice the ted shred for situations like this, and keep a better eye on your chain tension.
I ride brakeless and when friends I know ask me about getting into, I always tell them they should definitely throw a brake on for awhile. Even I think having a brake makes sense, but I do also feel that riding brakeless gives you a differnt concept on riding. Its certainly not as practical, but to me makes it funner. This is BF, the general consensus here has always been ride a brake, no need to fight over it more.
#66
If you are going to ride brakeless you should practice the ted shred for situations like this, and keep a better eye on your chain tension.
I ride brakeless and when friends I know ask me about getting into, I always tell them they should definitely throw a brake on for awhile. Even I think having a brake makes sense, but I do also feel that riding brakeless gives you a differnt concept on riding. Its certainly not as practical, but to me makes it funner. This is BF, the general consensus here has always been ride a brake, no need to fight over it more.
I ride brakeless and when friends I know ask me about getting into, I always tell them they should definitely throw a brake on for awhile. Even I think having a brake makes sense, but I do also feel that riding brakeless gives you a differnt concept on riding. Its certainly not as practical, but to me makes it funner. This is BF, the general consensus here has always been ride a brake, no need to fight over it more.
#67
P.L.U.R
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 62
Likes: 0
From: San Francisco, CA
Bikes: 1985 Shwinn World 10 speed, 1970-ish Centurion Converted to Fixed Gear
i actually got my centurion frame that i converted out of the dump xD
it rides really nicely, is fun, and looks like a beater... which it is.
#68
Junior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 20
Likes: 0
We know who we are & why we do it. 
I imagine the false sense of security a person must have going faster than they would without a brake, only to squeeze their front brake in a panic moment & fly over the handlebars or lock up the front wheel & skid face first into the ground. To answer my own question, this is what I think. I would never ride any bike with only a front brake for that very reason.

I imagine the false sense of security a person must have going faster than they would without a brake, only to squeeze their front brake in a panic moment & fly over the handlebars or lock up the front wheel & skid face first into the ground. To answer my own question, this is what I think. I would never ride any bike with only a front brake for that very reason.
#69
O.P. needs to read up on Sheldon's theories on this. I have and still do ride fixed with and without a brake and think that a brake is the way of a serious cyclist. You call it a false sense of security, it is more like being able to go as fast as you want, whenever. I love brakeless riding but only in the city when you dont get as much room to break out and really build up speed, especially downhill.
#70
scraper bikes
Joined: Sep 2007
Posts: 185
Likes: 0
From: NYC and SF Bay Area
Bikes: eddy mercxier kilo tt
i dont even look at those two options,
i just judge them by their skin color.
bwahahahahhahaha
jk.
>.>
<.<
1 - conversion, i think - this guy/girl has not heard of the mercier kilo tt
2 - brake ("you're ruining the scene man!!!" hahahahaha. i think, wow this guy is smarter than most")
i just judge them by their skin color.
bwahahahahhahaha
jk.
>.>
<.<
1 - conversion, i think - this guy/girl has not heard of the mercier kilo tt
2 - brake ("you're ruining the scene man!!!" hahahahaha. i think, wow this guy is smarter than most")
#71
1. same as above, why does this person have an old piece of junk when track geo is so much cooler? mixed with feelings of "i love my kilo"
2. i think "well at least they're not ruining tires."
but seriously, i just agree, as always, with peabody.
2. i think "well at least they're not ruining tires."
but seriously, i just agree, as always, with peabody.
#72
Bromptoneer
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 2,942
Likes: 0
From: Brooklyn, NY
Bikes: Brompton S2L
It's not the bike that tweaks me.... it's the rider/owner, and the extent some go to be part of their little clique. If I see a guy, pants rolled up, t-shirt, fixed and cruising downtown... nice bike!
If I see a guy, pants super-tight, rolled up, ****ty american apparel shirt, ascot or hankerchief, mutton chops connected to a mustache, vintage cycling cap, no helmut, practicing "bmx tricks", well... he looks like a tool and a riding cliche.
Same with other bikes though, roadie in spandex, no biggie. Roadie in full on super-pro gear, shaved legs, riding a $5000 bike while cruising at slow-pokey 15mph at a park? tool. If you want to ride like your on The Tour, head outside the city and but out a 100 miles at 20+ mph.
Anyway.... I'm sure I look like an idiot to tons of people I pass. I'm sure we all look like idiots to someone.
If I see a guy, pants super-tight, rolled up, ****ty american apparel shirt, ascot or hankerchief, mutton chops connected to a mustache, vintage cycling cap, no helmut, practicing "bmx tricks", well... he looks like a tool and a riding cliche.
Same with other bikes though, roadie in spandex, no biggie. Roadie in full on super-pro gear, shaved legs, riding a $5000 bike while cruising at slow-pokey 15mph at a park? tool. If you want to ride like your on The Tour, head outside the city and but out a 100 miles at 20+ mph.
Anyway.... I'm sure I look like an idiot to tons of people I pass. I'm sure we all look like idiots to someone.
#73
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 50
Likes: 0
it depends on whether they're riding it or walking it while sipping a soy latte in wicker park
brakes are a GOOD IDEA, especially in the city where stupid things happen incessantly.
brakes are a GOOD IDEA, especially in the city where stupid things happen incessantly.
#74
どうでもいいよ
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 238
Likes: 0
From: West Tokyo Japan
1) I get stoked when I see a conversion. You rarely see a conversion here in Japan. Most people with a conversion out here probably know a lot more than that kid who bought his keirin bike off of that Japanese auction site.
2) I check the rest of the bike to see if they are a serious enthusiast out training or a hipster. I have never ridden fixed with brakes. But I am seriously thinking of buying a Panasonic FP39 (their road training track frame set up for both front and rear brakes). Sometimes I really feel limited going down hills on narrower roads with traffic. Going down hills is the only part my geared Crosscheck is better than my track bike because of the brakes.
Last edited by westokyo; 07-27-08 at 06:46 AM.
#75
1. There goes a guy with some possible mechanical skills.
2. There goes a guy with some possible idea of safety.
2. There goes a guy with some possible idea of safety.




