![]() |
^ point taken, but there still aren't more parts to a threaded system.
|
^ right. I'd say that the number of parts is close enough for that aspect to not really be an issue. What should be considered are the skills and special tools that are needed to properly set up each system.
There is only one bolt that actually adjusts the headset on a threadless system, and it is usually just a 5mm allen bolt. On a threaded system, you have to both own and know how to use two wrenches. One is a specialized headset wrench of the right size for the adjustable nut. The other is an adjustable wrench or anything that will properly clamp on the lock-nut. Manipulating these two so that you have both a properly tightened headset and locking the two nuts together does take a bit of skill. Sure, you can change the height of the stem faster and more easily on a quill system, but this is shadowed by the level of skill required to properly setup a threaded headset. I'd also propose the hypothesis (from my experience as a mechanic in a bike shop) that a higher percentage of threaded headsets than threadless headsets are too tight or too loose. I'd bet that more are too loose than too tight, because it's much more apparent when a headset is too tight, and the two nuts are often not properly locked together and allow the headset to slowly loosen. I will agree that quill stems do have a certain elegance that can't be found in most threadless setups. But the design of the threadless system gives it complete mechanical advantage when in use. |
Originally Posted by darksiderising
(Post 8019980)
If you're going to address the top cap, adjusting bolt, and star nut as separate pieces, then you need to do the same with the bolt and wedge on the quill stem.
|
The conversion is really not that hard, 1 1/8 threaded headsets can be found easily, Chris King has a few nice ones with somewhat of a "vintage" look, and the forks shouldnt be hard to find either, but the quill stem in 1 1/8 is going to be a fun one to find in the classic quill look :twitchy:
Heres a Ritchey 1 1/8 headset: http://images.google.com/imgres?imgu...US275%26sa%3DN and here are a few 1 1/8 quill type stems: http://images.google.com/imgres?imgu...US275%26sa%3DN and heres the "Wound up" 1 1/8 carbon road fork: http://images.google.com/imgres?imgu...US275%26sa%3DN You should be good to go! |
Originally Posted by ilikebikes
(Post 8020943)
The conversion is really not that hard, 1 1/8 threaded headsets can be found easily, Chris King has a few nice ones with somewhat of a "vintage" look, and the forks shouldnt be hard to find either, but the quill stem in 1 1/8 is going to be a fun one to find in the classic quill look :twitchy:
|
I did. http://images.google.com/imgres?imgu...US275%26sa%3DN
EDIT! Well I thought I did? Those are threadless? Hmmmm...... |
Originally Posted by ilikebikes
(Post 8020943)
....but the quill stem in 1 1/8 is going to be a fun one to find in the classic quill look
|
Originally Posted by darksiderising
(Post 8020956)
Can you link to some 1 1/8 threaded road forks?
|
Originally Posted by roadfix
(Post 8021028)
Most all 1 & 1/8" and even 1 & 1/4" quill stems made were ugly high risers for mountain bikes and hybrids.
|
Originally Posted by ilikebikes
(Post 8021036)
OK, here ya go ;) http://www.teamcyclist.com/store/Alp...-20_P14091.cfm They have another but it looks like the standard "80s" MTB fork.
And anyways, so far there is one fork that we've found, and it costs $300. Not as easy to find these as you claimed earlier. |
Originally Posted by wearyourtruth
(Post 8019719)
you make it sound as if threadless is some sort of god-send and threaded assemblies are only for hobos and idiots....
...but at least argue that they are superior in accurate ways. just sayin... # of parts? You may be right there, but integrated threadless ones don't have cups, and internal ones don't have races either. But hey, threaded does look nicer, epically some nice, polished locknuts. Well, that was kinda gay. I wanna see what the OP comes up with, hopefully it looks the way he likes. |
Originally Posted by darksiderising
(Post 8021329)
I am skeptical about that fork being threaded. It claims to be an all-carbon fork. It lists nothing of a steel or aluminum steer tube. It also lists the steer tube length as 300mm, which is a typical uncut length for a threadless fork.
And anyways, so far there is one fork that we've found, and it costs $300. Not as easy to find these as you claimed earlier. Order Now for Holidays! 1-800-819-5720 Click Here to Buy/Print an Instant Gift Card MSRP: $329.99 Our Price: $299.99 You Save: $30.00 Please select your Description: SKU: TC110075 Alpha-Q Competition Series CS 20 Forks unique matte finish, All Carbon design. Steerer Tube: 1-1/8" Threaded. Steerer Tube Length: 300.0 mm. Fork Rake: 41 mm. Axle to Crown Length: Crown Race: 30.0. Front Axle Type: 9x1. Wheel Size: 700c. Front Hub Spacing: 100 mm. Brake Type: Road Caliper - Short Reach. Brake Usage F/R: Front. Material: Carbon. Color: Carbon. Team Cyclist is an authorized Alpha-Q dealer and will honor all manufacturer warranties. © 1992 - 2008 Team Cyclist - All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Site Map | Site Problems?Shop our other sites: SkateAmerica.com | BossMotocross.com | SpeedTeam.com" Maybe a misprint? Call and find out :thumb: |
DO NOT ORDER FROM THEM. Please try and search some threads like i should have before i ordered with them
|
Please let the OP know why. I just found them to show the OP that the parts he needs, although they are hard to find, are not impossible to find ;)
|
Originally Posted by ilikebikes
(Post 8022506)
Please let the OP know why. I just found them to show the OP that the parts he needs, although they are hard to find, are not impossible to find ;)
|
I can appreciate both the threaded and thread less systems and have never had either fail on me... thread less headsets are a smidge easier to set up and require less tools but in my opinion, quill stems are as elegant as can be.
Converting a bike that was designed for a thread less headset to a threaded one is going to be an expensive project and a pita when it comes to finding a suitable quill stem that does not look like ass. |
Originally Posted by darksiderising
(Post 8022679)
...which means that you have minimal options and have to pay high prices. Doesn't seem like the best route to go just to have a quill stem.
|
So, the best way i came up with to do it was to do the chris king devolution headset with a threaded fork with a one inch steerer.
After reading all of the posts hear helpful and otherwise, i convinced him to save the money and run the stock fork/headset and spend his money on buying a second bike! i am interested in finding a supplier for 1 1/8" threaded forks. it seems there is a general interest in running quills on newer frames. might be worth one of the more boutique bike mfg. making them |
posted twice
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:32 PM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.