Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Singlespeed & Fixed Gear (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/)
-   -   Ask Scrod (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/769181-ask-scrod.html)

redpear 10-21-11 10:30 AM

Scrod,

What's your opinion on

a. Expensive frame with cheap components

b. Expensive components with cheap frame

And why do you think there is a stigma with mixing expensive+cheap?

Scrodzilla 10-21-11 10:44 AM


Originally Posted by ddeadserious (Post 13395478)
Is it blasphemous to put an S300 crankset in a Leader 721 frame?

If it is, Angie's on the highway to Hell:

http://www.pedalroom.com/p/angies-le...1tr-2789_3.jpg

Scrodzilla 10-21-11 10:46 AM


Originally Posted by redpear (Post 13395524)
Scrod,

What's your opinion on

a. Expensive frame with cheap components

b. Expensive components with cheap frame

And why do you think there is a stigma with mixing expensive+cheap?

I have no real opinion on this and don't adhere to "stigmas".

Whatever gets you riding and enjoying yourself works.

ddeadserious 10-21-11 10:55 AM


Originally Posted by Scrodzilla (Post 13395581)
If it is, Angie's on the highway to Hell:

img snip

Sweet. Is there really any major reason to go with Omniums over the S300's?

Scrodzilla 10-21-11 10:58 AM

144 bcd cranks tend to be a little stiffer. Also, options for high-quality 144 bcd chainrings are a little more plentiful. The S300 is one of the best 130 bcd cranks out there, in my opinion.

Soo__Fuego 10-21-11 09:55 PM


Originally Posted by Scrodzilla (Post 13394447)
What gives you that impression - the fact that Angie and I own five of them? :lol:

here:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1...725-735geo.jpg

I dont know who that is but thank you for your help. 792mm/31" standover on the 58cm seems like the winner for me.

Scrodzilla 10-21-11 10:05 PM

Angie is my lady and other half of Retrogression.

Just so you know, the 58cm frames are pretty huge. I'm 5'10" with a 33" inseam and typically ride a 58cm steel frame but my 725 is a 55cm.

Soo__Fuego 10-21-11 10:15 PM

Cool.


Im six foot even with same inseam, suggestions on whether 55 or 58?

homebrewk 10-22-11 02:32 PM

How do your used ThickSlicks have no skids on them if you ride brakeless? Do you just do light backpedaling to control your speed? I always thought that was hard to do when you want to come to a complete stop on a hilly intersection or something.

Scrodzilla 10-22-11 02:42 PM

I've mentioned it in this thread and others - riding brakeless doesn't necessitate skidding. There's no sense in hauling ass toward a busy intersection and then needing to lock up your back wheel to stop. That's just stupid.

The rear ThickSlick actually has one small skid on it - just because I wanted to see how sticky they really were when they were new (and they are very sticky) - but it literally didn't even leave a visible mark.

homebrewk 10-22-11 02:57 PM

Ok. How about this:

What's some advice about riding brakeless? (ex: things to do/not to do, techniques)

yummygooey 10-22-11 03:01 PM

Pay attention to your surroundings and don't ride like an idiot.

/notscrod

calbob76 10-22-11 03:04 PM

I ride brakeless, I just think it's important to be aware of things going on around you (as you always should be on a bike) to make sure you will have time to stop if you need to (again, as you should be on any bike). I much prefer clipless when riding brakeless just because it's a lot more secure than straps and cages, but that is all personal preference. I run a 17t back cog so that helps as far as skid patches goes, but lately I have been trying to not skid as much as possible and it's working out great. I'm not going through tires as fast and it just feels a lot smoother. Overall brakeless isn't bad imo

solbrothers 10-22-11 03:05 PM


Originally Posted by yummygooey (Post 13400101)
Pay attention to your surroundings and don't ride like an idiot.

/notscrod

this. and there really isnt a reason to ever skid

jimmytango 10-22-11 03:28 PM

I have a front brake that I haven't touched in months. Don't ride like you're trying to set an hour record and pay attention like your life depends on it, cuz it really does.

homebrewk 10-22-11 03:30 PM

Yeah, I see what you guys are saying. I just don't see how you can go down a somewhat large hill and [safely] control your speed.

jimmytango 10-22-11 03:32 PM

If you have hills use a brake. Otherwise, put your left foot on the downtube, and park your right foot on the tire. But seriously, get a front brake. I'd rather be safe than cool.

Scrodzilla 10-22-11 03:41 PM


Originally Posted by homebrewk (Post 13400183)
Yeah, I see what you guys are saying. I just don't see how you can go down a somewhat large hill and [safely] control your speed.

With a gear ratio which is a good match for your ability, it really isn't that hard.

homebrewk 10-22-11 03:49 PM

I see. I'm not ever considering riding brakeless but if I did I would want to know. I don't want to end up like these guyz:


Scrodzilla 10-22-11 03:56 PM

I don't get what you're saying.

homebrewk 10-22-11 04:01 PM

The guys in the video don't stop.

Scrodzilla 10-22-11 04:03 PM

Why would they? They're clearly participating in a race.

CharneK 10-22-11 08:25 PM

Scrod, I would like to drop below 70 gi.

Right now I'm at 48/17, new cog for 48/19 or new ring for 44 or 43/17?

Price difference between ring and cog isn't too much of an issue.

Scrodzilla 10-22-11 08:52 PM

Bigger gears result in less wear on your chain and a smoother drivetrain in general. 48/19 FTW.

redpear 10-22-11 08:56 PM

Plus it looks BAMF

yummygooey 10-22-11 08:56 PM

I ran both 48/19 and 44/17. They feel the same, so I just stick with 48/19 'coz:


Originally Posted by Scrodzilla (Post 13401251)
Bigger gears result in less wear on your chain and a smoother drivetrain in general.

And:


Originally Posted by redpear (Post 13401268)
Plus it looks BAMF


CharneK 10-22-11 09:01 PM

I suspected the wear thing, so yeah, should be cheaper too. Hope my shop of choice has one in stock, I hate waiting.

max5480 10-23-11 01:20 AM

dearest scrod,
why is the road forums section so lame?
i try reading some threads, but then i'm like... "lame"
-max

jimmytango 10-23-11 01:41 AM

I think it's because they take the forum more seriously...

/Scrod-in-training

hamfoh 10-23-11 03:25 AM

+1 on the 'brakeless doesn't mean you skid'. I really only skid if I'm effing around with my friends. I never do it while commuting, and I mean never. I just keep an eye out on the lights and the intersections and control my speed based on what's in front of me. If you're riding a ratio you're comfortable with then it won't take much time at all to get used to what the dos and dont's are, homebrewk.

Scrod,
I was looking at Faz's Kagero and saw he's 53/15. Am I just a bitter @ss or does a ratio like that, for someone who doesn't get on the track, scream "trying too hard"? or is it just me?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:07 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.