Eddy's Molteni
#51
I'm in agreement.
In terms of provenance, let's say this guy has "extensive info". If I were him, I would likely not put in the public domain of the internet. Keeping the secrets secret enables more robust proof. If every Tom Dick and Harry knew what to forge, you are damn sure they would forge it.
Sure, having a high price and no real provenance on ebay makes for great fodder, but it also keeps all the looky loos from harassing the seller. If I was a serious buyer, my questions would be serious and not on ebay.
In terms of provenance, let's say this guy has "extensive info". If I were him, I would likely not put in the public domain of the internet. Keeping the secrets secret enables more robust proof. If every Tom Dick and Harry knew what to forge, you are damn sure they would forge it.
Sure, having a high price and no real provenance on ebay makes for great fodder, but it also keeps all the looky loos from harassing the seller. If I was a serious buyer, my questions would be serious and not on ebay.
#52
So if it is one of the bikes that he rode what sort of value would it be?
What is the value of a professional race over a shop race bike, and how much does it effect the price if it was rode by one of the big names?
What is the value of a professional race over a shop race bike, and how much does it effect the price if it was rode by one of the big names?
#53
Senior Member


Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 21,861
Likes: 3,748
As to the value of a "famous rider's mount" for me, that is such an intangible and so in my view fraught with error or fraud that I personally would not pay extra for it.
#54
If I were selling a 25.000$ bike I'd do it through a renowned seller of vintage bikes to provide credibility without baring it all. Like they do with art galleries and independent controllers that check for looted and forged pieces. Maybe the bike world has something to learn from the art world in this case. Who knows.
What is interesting to me is $25K is squat compared to other collectibles yet is a very difficult sell for a bike ridden by the Babe Ruth of cyclists. btw, a Babe Ruth game bat can run you $86K.
#56
Full Member

Joined: May 2012
Posts: 254
Likes: 23
From: Belgium, Bicycle country
Bikes: 50 ? More?
The "diamond" chain stays were a standard part of Ugo De Rosa's arsenal. He used them for many years. You will not see them on other brands, but they are indeed common on De Rosa built bikes. These stays and seat stays are good proof that it is indeed De Rosa built.
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-1.../aIMG_2312.JPG
But were they all with diamond shaped chain stays ?
The seller is also selling another one somewhere else and this one (also presented as Molteni team) does not have them.
The "Merckx" (I verified and it was also presented as Eddy's bike in the Stalen Ross) has the diamond shaped but not so well shaped
Here : https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-K.../aIMG_2313.JPG
Having examined all détails, they were clearly rebuilt. I seem to remember one with the wrong year crank.
I've seen much better quality Kessels
Another De Rosa where you can see this shape
https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/--...%2520Copie.JPG
(My bike of the day in background)
#58
Galleries will take 50-60%. And galleries have been known for shenanigans. You have to pick your poison.
What is interesting to me is $25K is squat compared to other collectibles yet is a very difficult sell for a bike ridden by the Babe Ruth of cyclists. btw, a Babe Ruth game bat can run you $86K.
What is interesting to me is $25K is squat compared to other collectibles yet is a very difficult sell for a bike ridden by the Babe Ruth of cyclists. btw, a Babe Ruth game bat can run you $86K.
ah well.
#61
#62
Senior Member


Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 21,861
Likes: 3,748
There are a number of sellers who have developed a decent reputation for accuracy of description and straightforward dealings. A few who others routinely find desirable bikes and have built a reputation on that.
And more than a few characters.
I would suggest Stefan of Speedbicycles.ch as pretty straightforward, my transactions with him have beed businesslike and honest. I think that he would not promote a claim as to a bike's history unless he could really prove that claim. I have noticed on his site he is quite conservative with any mention of who owned a bike, and proving if it was used in a race or races is really difficult and I don't recall reading anything of that sort.
#63
Senior Member


Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 21,861
Likes: 3,748
#64
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 2,519
Likes: 39
From: Tacoma, WA
Bikes: 1962 Schwinn Paramount P12, 1971 Schwinn Paramount P13-9
I agree. One of Jimmy Hendrick's Fenders used in a concert just sold for 225,000 British Pounds. So $25,000 for a proven Merckx race bike doesn't seem unreasonable.
#65
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 1,115
Likes: 17
Do we know what size that silver bike is in his auctions, by the way?
#66
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 1,115
Likes: 17
Galleries will take 50-60%. And galleries have been known for shenanigans. You have to pick your poison.
What is interesting to me is $25K is squat compared to other collectibles yet is a very difficult sell for a bike ridden by the Babe Ruth of cyclists. btw, a Babe Ruth game bat can run you $86K.
What is interesting to me is $25K is squat compared to other collectibles yet is a very difficult sell for a bike ridden by the Babe Ruth of cyclists. btw, a Babe Ruth game bat can run you $86K.
#67
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 1,115
Likes: 17
I was going to let that one go, Notorious might be a better description in some cases.
There are a number of sellers who have developed a decent reputation for accuracy of description and straightforward dealings. A few who others routinely find desirable bikes and have built a reputation on that.
And more than a few characters.
I would suggest Stefan of Speedbicycles.ch as pretty straightforward, my transactions with him have beed businesslike and honest. I think that he would not promote a claim as to a bike's history unless he could really prove that claim. I have noticed on his site he is quite conservative with any mention of who owned a bike, and proving if it was used in a race or races is really difficult and I don't recall reading anything of that sort.
There are a number of sellers who have developed a decent reputation for accuracy of description and straightforward dealings. A few who others routinely find desirable bikes and have built a reputation on that.
And more than a few characters.
I would suggest Stefan of Speedbicycles.ch as pretty straightforward, my transactions with him have beed businesslike and honest. I think that he would not promote a claim as to a bike's history unless he could really prove that claim. I have noticed on his site he is quite conservative with any mention of who owned a bike, and proving if it was used in a race or races is really difficult and I don't recall reading anything of that sort.
Edit: post #1000 , baby!
Last edited by 753proguy; 03-24-14 at 07:18 PM. Reason: yee-hah
#68
I would also concur regarding Stefan Schaefter - and not just because he owns more of my drillium work than anyone on the planet and is an FB friend, to boot 
The guy is top-notch, period.
DD

The guy is top-notch, period.
DD
#69
People complain about ebay but their 10% plus the 5% a paypal is a pretty good deal.
#71
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 1,115
Likes: 17
...and PayPal isn't 5%. As a heavy user, I pay 1.9% plus the 75 cents or whatever. So maybe 12% total in fees when selling on eBarf.
Last edited by 753proguy; 03-26-14 at 11:37 AM. Reason: fixed a typo.
#72
Correct. If the price you acheive is 50% more than you would otherwise (which I think eBay often can be), then you are still ahead after paying their fees. Look at the "Barry Scott gambit" for example.
...and PayPal isn't 5%. As a heavy user, I pay 1.9% plus the 75 cents or whatever. So maybe 12% total in fess when selling on eBarf.
...and PayPal isn't 5%. As a heavy user, I pay 1.9% plus the 75 cents or whatever. So maybe 12% total in fess when selling on eBarf.
#73
Senior Member


Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 21,861
Likes: 3,748
Reserves, initial bids, hidden reserves can all potentially change the next nearest bidder dynamic.
The seller's and buyers premiums can distort the published auction price quite a bit. But I guess Copake does not have the eye candy waltzing around drumming up interest of the bidding crowd too like at Barrett-Jackson…
Alex March is the Rene Herse / Alex Singer frequent ebay presenter. I would place Stefan ahead of him.
#75
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 1,115
Likes: 17
indeed. ebay was a terrific deal, now it is still a deal.
Reserves, initial bids, hidden reserves can all potentially change the next nearest bidder dynamic.
The seller's and buyers premiums can distort the published auction price quite a bit. But I guess Copake does not have the eye candy waltzing around drumming up interest of the bidding crowd too like at Barrett-Jackson…
Alex March is the Rene Herse / Alex Singer frequent ebay presenter. I would place Stefan ahead of him.
Reserves, initial bids, hidden reserves can all potentially change the next nearest bidder dynamic.
The seller's and buyers premiums can distort the published auction price quite a bit. But I guess Copake does not have the eye candy waltzing around drumming up interest of the bidding crowd too like at Barrett-Jackson…
Alex March is the Rene Herse / Alex Singer frequent ebay presenter. I would place Stefan ahead of him.







