Fed up with the Brooks saddle
#1
bragi
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: seattle, WA
Posts: 2,911
Bikes: LHT
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 3 Times
in
3 Posts
Fed up with the Brooks saddle
Hi all:
I've been riding with a Brooks B-17 for the last nine months. It was a bit hard to break in, and it creaked a lot, so it took me a while to appreciate it. After a month or so, it did stop creaking, and it got really comfortable, and for a while things were quite good: there's nothing quite like a saddle so comfortable that you forget about it entirely. Lately, though, the creaking has started up again, which annoys me to no end, and the fact that the saddle is not impervious to rain has begun to trouble me, too. My question is this: does anyone know of a saddle that is as comfortable as a B-17 for commuting/touring purposes, but is also waterproof and not apt to creak like a 19th century carriage spring?
I've been riding with a Brooks B-17 for the last nine months. It was a bit hard to break in, and it creaked a lot, so it took me a while to appreciate it. After a month or so, it did stop creaking, and it got really comfortable, and for a while things were quite good: there's nothing quite like a saddle so comfortable that you forget about it entirely. Lately, though, the creaking has started up again, which annoys me to no end, and the fact that the saddle is not impervious to rain has begun to trouble me, too. My question is this: does anyone know of a saddle that is as comfortable as a B-17 for commuting/touring purposes, but is also waterproof and not apt to creak like a 19th century carriage spring?
#3
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: NA
Posts: 4,267
Bikes: NA
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 9 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 7 Times
in
7 Posts
Hi all:
I've been riding with a Brooks B-17 for the last nine months. It was a bit hard to break in, and it creaked a lot, so it took me a while to appreciate it. After a month or so, it did stop creaking, and it got really comfortable, and for a while things were quite good: there's nothing quite like a saddle so comfortable that you forget about it entirely. Lately, though, the creaking has started up again, which annoys me to no end, and the fact that the saddle is not impervious to rain has begun to trouble me, too. My question is this: does anyone know of a saddle that is as comfortable as a B-17 for commuting/touring purposes, but is also waterproof and not apt to creak like a 19th century carriage spring?
I've been riding with a Brooks B-17 for the last nine months. It was a bit hard to break in, and it creaked a lot, so it took me a while to appreciate it. After a month or so, it did stop creaking, and it got really comfortable, and for a while things were quite good: there's nothing quite like a saddle so comfortable that you forget about it entirely. Lately, though, the creaking has started up again, which annoys me to no end, and the fact that the saddle is not impervious to rain has begun to trouble me, too. My question is this: does anyone know of a saddle that is as comfortable as a B-17 for commuting/touring purposes, but is also waterproof and not apt to creak like a 19th century carriage spring?
#4
Junior Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Location: NJ
Posts: 19
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Before purchasing B17, for couple of months I've been riding on this one Amazon.com : Planet Bike Men's A.R.S. Anatomic Relief Bicycle Saddle (Black/Black) : Bike Saddles And Seats : Sports & Outdoors
Comfortable, comparatevely cheap, though not waterproof.
Comfortable, comparatevely cheap, though not waterproof.
#5
Bourbon junkie
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: NorCal
Posts: 722
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 5 Post(s)
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
My brooks and selle anatomica saddles creak when their tension is on the loose side.
Last edited by ricebowl; 06-04-14 at 01:04 AM.
#7
Banned
Yeah, I'm not convinced about the Brooks. I think it's one of these overhyped items for the "trailer queen" equivalent of a bicycle.
#8
The Flying Scot
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: North Queensferry Scotland and London (and France)
Posts: 1,904
Bikes: Custom (Colin Laing) 531c fast tourer/audax, 1964 Flying Scot Continental, 1995 Cinelli Supercorsa, Holdsworth Mistral single speed, Dahon Speed 6 (folder), Micmo Sirocco and a few more
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I love my Brooks (all of them!)
Any creaking is generally not the saddle, but the saddle rails in the seatpost clamp. I usually put some copperslip in and the creaking goes.
Any creaking is generally not the saddle, but the saddle rails in the seatpost clamp. I usually put some copperslip in and the creaking goes.
__________________
plus je vois les hommes, plus j'admire les chiens
1985 Sandy Gilchrist-Colin Laing built 531c Audax/fast tourer.
1964 Flying Scot Continental (531)
1995 Cinelli Supercorsa (Columbus SLX)
1980s Holdsworth Mistral fixed (531)
2005 Dahon Speed 6 (folder)
(YES I LIKE STEEL)
2008 Viking Saratoga tandem
2008 Micmo Sirocco Hybrid (aluminium!)
2012 BTwin Rockrider 8.1
plus je vois les hommes, plus j'admire les chiens
1985 Sandy Gilchrist-Colin Laing built 531c Audax/fast tourer.
1964 Flying Scot Continental (531)
1995 Cinelli Supercorsa (Columbus SLX)
1980s Holdsworth Mistral fixed (531)
2005 Dahon Speed 6 (folder)
(YES I LIKE STEEL)
2008 Viking Saratoga tandem
2008 Micmo Sirocco Hybrid (aluminium!)
2012 BTwin Rockrider 8.1
#9
The Left Coast, USA
#11
Friendship is Magic
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Sacramento, CA
Posts: 22,985
Bikes: old ones
Mentioned: 304 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 26425 Post(s)
Liked 10,381 Times
in
7,209 Posts
...if the creaking is what you want to address, as stated above, it usually has a source that comes from someplace in your
assembly where two things meet and are sliding back and forth a little bit, so basically a lot of possibilities.
You start a methodical process of elimination by putting something lubricious along the rails, (teflon tape sometimes works),
and then tighten all the bolts and connections. there's also a source for squeaks up at the nose, so you work in some wax
or proofide up there, where the leather meets other parts. Most times the squeaks can be eliminated.
But I agree with those here who think that Brooks saddles are a marketing phenomenon. The ones I ride are old, and have
collected on various bicycles in ways mysterious, like gifts from some anonymous cargo cult god.
assembly where two things meet and are sliding back and forth a little bit, so basically a lot of possibilities.
You start a methodical process of elimination by putting something lubricious along the rails, (teflon tape sometimes works),
and then tighten all the bolts and connections. there's also a source for squeaks up at the nose, so you work in some wax
or proofide up there, where the leather meets other parts. Most times the squeaks can be eliminated.
But I agree with those here who think that Brooks saddles are a marketing phenomenon. The ones I ride are old, and have
collected on various bicycles in ways mysterious, like gifts from some anonymous cargo cult god.
__________________
#12
Senior Member
If it started creaking again, maybe you could tighten the tension bolt a bit. Perhaps 1/4 to 1/2 turn (clockwise when viewed from the front).
I have 4 Brooks saddles and I love them all, especially on long rides. On shorter rides (< 50 miles), I can use pretty much any saddle. But on longer rides, that's when I really notice the difference.
I have 4 Brooks saddles and I love them all, especially on long rides. On shorter rides (< 50 miles), I can use pretty much any saddle. But on longer rides, that's when I really notice the difference.
#13
Banned
Ah OCD requires absolute silence .. you've never ridden a horse with it's leather saddle either, I assume.
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Above ground, Walnut Creek, Ca
Posts: 6,681
Bikes: 8 ss bikes, 1 5-speed touring bike
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 86 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 4 Times
in
4 Posts
sounds like roadie pillow talk.
i love it! can't wait to work that into a conversation in the near future. i'm going to be on the lookout for their reaction, if any...
#15
incazzare.
To the OP, creaking may or may not be the saddle. Are you sure it's not the seatpost or stem? I'd re-grease both. Did your saddle come with a rain cover? Most Brooks saddles do. If you want a similar fit and feel, but a more waterproof saddle, you could try a C-17. I just got one and it basically feels like a regular Brooks. I believe it is very slightly narrower than a B-17, but not much.
__________________
1964 JRJ (Bob Jackson), 1973 Wes Mason, 1974 Raleigh Gran Sport, 1986 Schwinn High Sierra, 2000ish Colian (Colin Laing), 2011 Dick Chafe, 2013 Velo Orange Pass Hunter
1964 JRJ (Bob Jackson), 1973 Wes Mason, 1974 Raleigh Gran Sport, 1986 Schwinn High Sierra, 2000ish Colian (Colin Laing), 2011 Dick Chafe, 2013 Velo Orange Pass Hunter
#16
Banned
1. When were the 80s? 35 years ago. Do you wear fluorescent coloured windbreakers now?
2. I would argue that most OEM equipment is a cost-conscious decision for the manufacturer. Meaning that anything on a mid-range bike is a cost-compromise. Especially components that aren't part of a gruppo.
It's not that I don't think they're high-quality, I just think that most people won't get 25+ years out of them to justify the cost. This is one of my reasons that I'm doing the BSO test, I want to set an inexpensive threshold for reasonable quality.
#17
incazzare.
Why on earth do you need to get 25 years out of them to justify the cost? Their prices are on par with other high quality saddles.
As for the 80's, what does how long ago it was have to do with anything? You're talking about style, I guess? I'm talking about quality. My point was that people rode this kind of saddle for many years, so it's not a product that is about hype. Brooks saddles stopped appearing on higher end bikes because other saddles were lighter and cheaper--that doesn't mean better, of course. Those are two considerations I personally place way under comfort and quality.
More power to you with your BSO test--it sounds like this just isn't your market, then.
As for the 80's, what does how long ago it was have to do with anything? You're talking about style, I guess? I'm talking about quality. My point was that people rode this kind of saddle for many years, so it's not a product that is about hype. Brooks saddles stopped appearing on higher end bikes because other saddles were lighter and cheaper--that doesn't mean better, of course. Those are two considerations I personally place way under comfort and quality.
More power to you with your BSO test--it sounds like this just isn't your market, then.
__________________
1964 JRJ (Bob Jackson), 1973 Wes Mason, 1974 Raleigh Gran Sport, 1986 Schwinn High Sierra, 2000ish Colian (Colin Laing), 2011 Dick Chafe, 2013 Velo Orange Pass Hunter
1964 JRJ (Bob Jackson), 1973 Wes Mason, 1974 Raleigh Gran Sport, 1986 Schwinn High Sierra, 2000ish Colian (Colin Laing), 2011 Dick Chafe, 2013 Velo Orange Pass Hunter
#18
Banned
My point was that people rode this kind of saddle for many years, so it's not a product that is about hype. Brooks saddles stopped appearing on higher end bikes because other saddles were lighter and cheaper--that doesn't mean better, of course. Those are two considerations I personally place way under comfort and quality.
More power to you with your BSO test--it sounds like this just isn't your market, then.
More power to you with your BSO test--it sounds like this just isn't your market, then.
2. Actually, it's totally my market ... my BSO test is to see how the other half lives
#19
incazzare.
Old, sure. But also proven and time tested. It does not automatically follow that something which is old is no longer good. Do you buy the newest carbon fiber saddle as soon as it comes out?
__________________
1964 JRJ (Bob Jackson), 1973 Wes Mason, 1974 Raleigh Gran Sport, 1986 Schwinn High Sierra, 2000ish Colian (Colin Laing), 2011 Dick Chafe, 2013 Velo Orange Pass Hunter
1964 JRJ (Bob Jackson), 1973 Wes Mason, 1974 Raleigh Gran Sport, 1986 Schwinn High Sierra, 2000ish Colian (Colin Laing), 2011 Dick Chafe, 2013 Velo Orange Pass Hunter
#20
Banned
Proven and time tested, doesn't mean good value for money. I think we can all name products that survive solely on their perceived heritage. I'm undecided yet if Brooks is one of these. They do have some new models which are interesting. And, to be fair, I probably see dozens of 15+ year old Brooks saddles on beater city bikes every weekend in CPH!
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Gig Harbor, WA
Posts: 2,470
Bikes: Surly Long Haul Trucker, Gary Fisher Hoo Koo E Koo, Dahon Mu P 24 , Ritchey Breakaway Cross, Rodriguez Tandem, Wheeler MTB
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 32 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
My B 17 doesn't make any noise at all. When it rains, I simply cover the saddle with the cheap plastic bag I always carry under the saddle , between the rails. I like mine. I've tried the Selle Anatomica , with less than satisfactory results YMMV. If I try something other than a brooks ( not very likely ) it would be the Selle SMP, I've heard a lot of good regarding it's comfort.
#22
Banned
a synthetic one wont need a cover , though I put one on in the winter for absorbing the wear and tear on the Pleather .
maybe a C17 will give you a fashionably satisfactory Look.
maybe a C17 will give you a fashionably satisfactory Look.
#23
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Cascadia
Posts: 1,206
Bikes: Jamis Quest Comp
Mentioned: 2 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 169 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 3 Times
in
3 Posts
I think I tried ever saddle under $50 at REI, none were comfortable for more than 5 miles.
Figured, 'what the hell, I'm uncomfortable anyway...might as well break in a brooks and see what it's all about', and my butt felt great from mile 1. Money well spent.
#24
Junior Member
My B17 makes no noise after 2 years. Quite happy with it. Plan on doing some longer rides this summer and am happy to have it.
It also makes my Trek 7.2 FX look a bit classier!
I also recall reading a story about a cyclist who purchased his Brooks saddle just prior to WWII and used it as long as he was able. So let's assume he used it for 50 years. What other saddle could you use that long? Perhaps Brooks is really the cheapest way to go for the long haul!
It also makes my Trek 7.2 FX look a bit classier!
I also recall reading a story about a cyclist who purchased his Brooks saddle just prior to WWII and used it as long as he was able. So let's assume he used it for 50 years. What other saddle could you use that long? Perhaps Brooks is really the cheapest way to go for the long haul!
Last edited by TrekCommuter; 06-04-14 at 08:22 PM.
#25
20+mph Commuter
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Greenville. SC USA
Posts: 7,517
Bikes: Surly LHT, Surly Lowside, a folding bike, and a beater.
Mentioned: 31 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1434 Post(s)
Liked 331 Times
in
219 Posts
One of the best saddles I have ever owned:
Specialized Bicycle Components
I have never owned a Specialized bike, but I picked up an Avatar Elite a few years ago for my road bike and liked it so much I moved it to my Long Haul Trucker (which is set up like my road bike).
I rode Brooks saddles exclusively from 1974 to 1994. Loved them. But given all of the new materials and designs available these days I wouldn't ride a Brooks anymore if I got them for free.
Specialized Bicycle Components
I have never owned a Specialized bike, but I picked up an Avatar Elite a few years ago for my road bike and liked it so much I moved it to my Long Haul Trucker (which is set up like my road bike).
I rode Brooks saddles exclusively from 1974 to 1994. Loved them. But given all of the new materials and designs available these days I wouldn't ride a Brooks anymore if I got them for free.