Backpack Friday
#77
Junior Member
Joined: Aug 2013
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
As a current brompton owner, This bike struck me for a few reasons:
- It's a straight handlebar by default, I have the curved 'M' brompton handlebars and the frame flex can be annoying.
- I'm hoping that by not having a rear 'rubber block' suspension and not having a fold on the top tube there's going to be a lot less frame flex. The power-loss in the Brompton really bugs me when trying to ride up hills.
- Custom sizing - I'm 5'10ish and always felt like I had to move the brompton seat far back, possibly causing issues with the weight balance. Hoping the varying frame sizes fixes this.
- Belt drive - I already had been wanting to eventually modify my brompton for this, based on Belt-drive Bromptons
- The weight: ~15lbs (even for a singlespeed) at the early bird price is really good deal compared to the Bromptons I've seen modified and sold to get near that weight over the years.
Concerns:
- I hope they're not achieving the 15lbs via carbon parts, anyone know what they're doing? Is it titanium parts for some of the Elite frame bits?
- I still want to mount a bag on the front, I hope there's going to be some type of mount at the front.
- Similarly, I also want to mount a bag on the back via a minimal rear rack instead of a clickfix for versatility. Right now with the brompton I can getaway with using a typical backpack on the rear and a messenger bag on the front.
- I didn't notice this until seeing the "new bike update #2" video, but putting the bike in a backpack involves removing the front wheel. Still debating how much that and the larger folded dimensions bug me.
Last edited by seltzered; 08-22-16 at 11:15 PM.
#78
As far as I can tell, there are 4 models
- Single Speed Packit, 19.2 lbs: Early: $999, Late: $1,300
- Three Speed Packit, 19.8 lbs: Early: $1,200, Late: $1,500
- 11 Speed Packit, 22 lbs: Early: $1,700, Late: $1,990
- Single Speed Packit Elite (either 14.9 lbs or 15 lbs, depends on where it is listed): Early $1,800, Late: $2,300
Backpack. $200 more. Kickstarter generally doesn't allow selecting more than one reward, but in some cases that can be done post KickStarter compaign.
The Packit Elite doesn't seem to come in multi-speed options.
#79
Full Member
Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 382
Likes: 19
If the elite retail price for a single speed is going to $2,600...what are prices going to be for the multi-geared?
Let's hope the Helix turns out well...
#80
Junior Member
Joined: Aug 2013
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
There's a line saying that they'll allow buyers of the elite to customize it with gearings later. I decided to pledge for the elite but am still waiting to hear back on what they're actually doing to get it to 15lbs.
As a current brompton owner, This bike struck me for a few reasons:
- It's a straight handlebar by default, I have the curved 'M' brompton handlebars and the frame flex can be annoying.
- I'm hoping that by not having a rear 'rubber block' suspension and not having a fold on the top tube there's going to be a lot less frame flex. The power-loss in the Brompton really bugs me when trying to ride up hills.
- Custom sizing - I'm 5'10ish and always felt like I had to move the brompton seat far back, possibly causing issues with the weight balance. Hoping the varying frame sizes fixes this.
- Belt drive - I already had been wanting to eventually modify my brompton for this, based on Belt-drive Bromptons
- The weight: ~15lbs (even for a singlespeed) at the early bird price is really good deal compared to the Bromptons I've seen modified and sold to get near that weight over the years.
Concerns:
- I hope they're not achieving the 15lbs via carbon parts, anyone know what they're doing? Is it titanium parts for some of the Elite frame bits?
- I still want to mount a bag on the front, I hope there's going to be some type of mount at the front.
- Similarly, I also want to mount a bag on the back via a minimal rear rack instead of a clickfix for versatility. Right now with the brompton I can getaway with using a typical backpack on the rear and a messenger bag on the front.
- I didn't notice this until seeing the "new bike update #2" video, but putting the bike in a backpack involves removing the front wheel. Still debating how much that and the larger folded dimensions bug me.
As a current brompton owner, This bike struck me for a few reasons:
- It's a straight handlebar by default, I have the curved 'M' brompton handlebars and the frame flex can be annoying.
- I'm hoping that by not having a rear 'rubber block' suspension and not having a fold on the top tube there's going to be a lot less frame flex. The power-loss in the Brompton really bugs me when trying to ride up hills.
- Custom sizing - I'm 5'10ish and always felt like I had to move the brompton seat far back, possibly causing issues with the weight balance. Hoping the varying frame sizes fixes this.
- Belt drive - I already had been wanting to eventually modify my brompton for this, based on Belt-drive Bromptons
- The weight: ~15lbs (even for a singlespeed) at the early bird price is really good deal compared to the Bromptons I've seen modified and sold to get near that weight over the years.
Concerns:
- I hope they're not achieving the 15lbs via carbon parts, anyone know what they're doing? Is it titanium parts for some of the Elite frame bits?
- I still want to mount a bag on the front, I hope there's going to be some type of mount at the front.
- Similarly, I also want to mount a bag on the back via a minimal rear rack instead of a clickfix for versatility. Right now with the brompton I can getaway with using a typical backpack on the rear and a messenger bag on the front.
- I didn't notice this until seeing the "new bike update #2" video, but putting the bike in a backpack involves removing the front wheel. Still debating how much that and the larger folded dimensions bug me.
UPDATE: Just heard back on them on a few things:
- The 'Elite' version's weight savings comes from using lighter wall cromoly tubing. Yay mystery solved.
- They don't have a front stem luggage mount since it sticks out too much for them to fit in the backpack.
I'm a bit torn on the lack of front luggage bit, I'm pretty impressed by the bike design though since it looks like it'll be a more solid ride.
#81
Full Member
Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 382
Likes: 19
They should include the luggage mount plate and let customers decide if they want it or the backpack. Surely the bolt mount itself isn't the issue? That's like, what, an inch bump? I have serious doubts about the backpack. It's enormous, blocking out the entire torso of the carrier. If I have the 11 gear hub version with a rack and fenders and the bike is nearing the mid-20's in weight--it's not going to be a light carry...at least for the smaller folks like me. And wearing that size of a backpack in the summer when it's 90 degrees with 90 percent humidity doesn't sound like much fun either.
#82
Junior Member
Joined: Aug 2013
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Hmmm...interesting about the cromoly, will have to google that.
They should include the luggage mount plate and let customers decide if they want it or the backpack. Surely the bolt mount itself isn't the issue? That's like, what, an inch bump? I have serious doubts about the backpack. It's enormous, blocking out the entire torso of the carrier. If I have the 11 gear hub version with a rack and fenders and the bike is nearing the mid-20's in weight--it's not going to be a light carry...at least for the smaller folks like me. And wearing that size of a backpack in the summer when it's 90 degrees with 90 percent humidity doesn't sound like much fun either.
They should include the luggage mount plate and let customers decide if they want it or the backpack. Surely the bolt mount itself isn't the issue? That's like, what, an inch bump? I have serious doubts about the backpack. It's enormous, blocking out the entire torso of the carrier. If I have the 11 gear hub version with a rack and fenders and the bike is nearing the mid-20's in weight--it's not going to be a light carry...at least for the smaller folks like me. And wearing that size of a backpack in the summer when it's 90 degrees with 90 percent humidity doesn't sound like much fun either.
Good point. Honestly I wasn't thinking too hard about the backpack, my other concern was just how 'carryable' it is relative to the brompton. In it's folded state the handlebar is above the top tube you're grabbing to carry with, they briefly show carrying it at 1:47 in the kickstarter video and it seems okay for brief carrying but i'm not as certain carrying longer distances / up stairs. Could maybe be solved via a handle accessory a la the off yer bike ones for brompton
Last edited by seltzered; 08-23-16 at 01:03 AM.
#83
The video is disingenuous when showing the Brompton around 1m20:
Hub Gear Calculator
That bike is too complicated and too big to use as a commuter bike that you'll have to fold/unfold several times a day. As a travel bike, however, how does it compare to the existing range of BF bikes?
On the positive side, I like the belt drive, the Alfine 11, and the different sizes the bike will be available.
- When carrying out of the car trunk, it looks like it's going to fall apart
- It looks like you have to spin like a circus monkey, although the six-speed version with a 50T chainring offers 33-100 gear inches (2.63-8m)
- When comparing folded sizes at 1m50, they "forgot" to fold the left pedal on the Brompton. They also forgot to show the bikes from the side…
- For some reason, the bike won't let you hang a bag in the front, although it's super convenient
Hub Gear Calculator
That bike is too complicated and too big to use as a commuter bike that you'll have to fold/unfold several times a day. As a travel bike, however, how does it compare to the existing range of BF bikes?
On the positive side, I like the belt drive, the Alfine 11, and the different sizes the bike will be available.
#85
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 922
Likes: 2
From: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Bikes: Wheeler Mtn bike, Strida 5.0, Tern Link Uno, FSIR Spin 2.0, Dahon Mu P8
I was a bit confused too on what he was talking about vs the film.
https://ksr-video.imgix.net/projects...-h264_high.mp4
all I can say it's about marketing their bike and i'll try to answer these:
-When carrying out of the car trunk, it looks like it's going to fall apart
They're just saying it's heavy not clumsy to take out which vs a normal single speed non titanium version is 23lbs vs their 19.2lbs similarly priced version. doesn't sound like much but to some 4lbs is the weight of a heavy laptop already.
-It looks like you have to spin like a circus monkey, although the six-speed version with a 50T chainring offers 33-100 gear inches (2.63-8m)
That wasn't even a Brompton they are comparing to, but there are some low end folders out there with really junk gear ranges. (I guess they are competing against the under $300 folding bikes also?) any $500+ dahon would be geared really well usually (30's to 90's) that's alot of usable range. They aren't singling out the Brompton here but the overall folding bike market it seems.
-When comparing folded sizes at 1m50, they "forgot" to fold the left pedal on the Brompton. They also forgot to show the bikes from the side…
Why in the world would they show you the side view when it's THEIR marketing?
doing that it would look like the BIGGEST fold! now that's just silly shooting yourself in the foot. for the pedal Probably the cameraman didn't know how it folds? still gives you the overall thiness, heh.
-For some reason, the bike won't let you hang a bag in the front, although it's super convenient
R&K bags would mount on that just like any bike. Just nothing proprietary from BF. But if you wanted it on the frame like Dahon and Bromptons, I'm guessing you can easily request for it since BF does everything custom and it's not a assembly line of all the same thing so they can easily weld some screw mounts for you
https://ksr-video.imgix.net/projects...-h264_high.mp4
all I can say it's about marketing their bike and i'll try to answer these:
-When carrying out of the car trunk, it looks like it's going to fall apart
They're just saying it's heavy not clumsy to take out which vs a normal single speed non titanium version is 23lbs vs their 19.2lbs similarly priced version. doesn't sound like much but to some 4lbs is the weight of a heavy laptop already.
-It looks like you have to spin like a circus monkey, although the six-speed version with a 50T chainring offers 33-100 gear inches (2.63-8m)
That wasn't even a Brompton they are comparing to, but there are some low end folders out there with really junk gear ranges. (I guess they are competing against the under $300 folding bikes also?) any $500+ dahon would be geared really well usually (30's to 90's) that's alot of usable range. They aren't singling out the Brompton here but the overall folding bike market it seems.
-When comparing folded sizes at 1m50, they "forgot" to fold the left pedal on the Brompton. They also forgot to show the bikes from the side…
Why in the world would they show you the side view when it's THEIR marketing?
doing that it would look like the BIGGEST fold! now that's just silly shooting yourself in the foot. for the pedal Probably the cameraman didn't know how it folds? still gives you the overall thiness, heh.-For some reason, the bike won't let you hang a bag in the front, although it's super convenient
R&K bags would mount on that just like any bike. Just nothing proprietary from BF. But if you wanted it on the frame like Dahon and Bromptons, I'm guessing you can easily request for it since BF does everything custom and it's not a assembly line of all the same thing so they can easily weld some screw mounts for you
Last edited by Azreal911; 08-23-16 at 09:23 AM.
#86
Senior Member

Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 3,541
Likes: 455
From: SF Bay Area
Bikes: Now: HPV Gecko FX 20 w/ assist.. Old: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
That bike is too complicated and too big to use as a commuter bike that you'll have to fold/unfold several times a day. As a travel bike, however, how does it compare to the existing range of BF bikes?
On the positive side, I like the belt drive, the Alfine 11, and the different sizes the bike will be available.
But if you did need to fold a lot, the quick fold is easy. drop the seat, snap the stem onto the pin, rotate the wheel. done. easy to carry because of the very light weight. (would not bother with the bag at all).
Last edited by linberl; 08-23-16 at 09:42 AM.
#88
#89
Full Member
Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 382
Likes: 19
They've upped the ante, now offering the 11 gear hub at an elite 19.2lb. Now we're talking. Estimated retail price will be $2,800. I'm going to call this bike, Packet (of wages to freaking own it!). No early adopter here, but this is definitely intriguing.
Add luggage mount please...
Add luggage mount please...
#90
Full Member
Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 382
Likes: 19
You're right about the bag. Can you imagine what it looks like on short people from behind? A tiny bit of a head showing, a giant rectangle carapace of a backpack and then legs. Basically a turtle standing on its back legs.
#91
Senior Member

Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 3,541
Likes: 455
From: SF Bay Area
Bikes: Now: HPV Gecko FX 20 w/ assist.. Old: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
But BF is calling it a city bike and the promo advertises it as a daily urban bike which implies lots of folding. Perhaps BF figured this out with the semi-fold.
You're right about the bag. Can you imagine what it looks like on short people from behind? A tiny bit of a head showing, a giant rectangle carapace of a backpack and then legs. Basically a turtle standing on its back legs.
You're right about the bag. Can you imagine what it looks like on short people from behind? A tiny bit of a head showing, a giant rectangle carapace of a backpack and then legs. Basically a turtle standing on its back legs.
The quick fold is very quick less than 30 seconds and easy to carry with no bag. Being a belt drive, you don't have to worry about grease, either.
#92
Senior Member

Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 694
Likes: 224
I don't see the attraction for this bike other than perhaps a BF ride feel.
Also, perhaps it makes sense for US folks as options for foldables are more limited as well as max weight concerns.
A CRIUS SMART is 7.6kg for the single sp and 8.6kg for the 3sp IGH.
Its fast to fold and easy to handle as its very light. (I have the 3.0)
Folded, it can be pushed around and it certainly can be carried in any bag if necessary esp if one adds removable pedals (eg. like the MKS ones)
To me, laziness is king.
More so in the tropical weather I'm in.
Stooped over to fix up the bike after a ride from home to the train station for example and I'd really not want to be sweating too much in the humidity and heat fixing up the BF.
Also, perhaps it makes sense for US folks as options for foldables are more limited as well as max weight concerns.
A CRIUS SMART is 7.6kg for the single sp and 8.6kg for the 3sp IGH.
Its fast to fold and easy to handle as its very light. (I have the 3.0)
Folded, it can be pushed around and it certainly can be carried in any bag if necessary esp if one adds removable pedals (eg. like the MKS ones)
To me, laziness is king.
More so in the tropical weather I'm in.
Stooped over to fix up the bike after a ride from home to the train station for example and I'd really not want to be sweating too much in the humidity and heat fixing up the BF.
#93
Senior Member

Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 3,541
Likes: 455
From: SF Bay Area
Bikes: Now: HPV Gecko FX 20 w/ assist.. Old: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
I don't see the attraction for this bike other than perhaps a BF ride feel.
Also, perhaps it makes sense for US folks as options for foldables are more limited as well as max weight concerns.
A CRIUS SMART is 7.6kg for the single sp and 8.6kg for the 3sp IGH.
Its fast to fold and easy to handle as its very light. (I have the 3.0)
Folded, it can be pushed around and it certainly can be carried in any bag if necessary esp if one adds removable pedals (eg. like the MKS ones)
To me, laziness is king.
More so in the tropical weather I'm in.
Stooped over to fix up the bike after a ride from home to the train station for example and I'd really not want to be sweating too much in the humidity and heat fixing up the BF.
Also, perhaps it makes sense for US folks as options for foldables are more limited as well as max weight concerns.
A CRIUS SMART is 7.6kg for the single sp and 8.6kg for the 3sp IGH.
Its fast to fold and easy to handle as its very light. (I have the 3.0)
Folded, it can be pushed around and it certainly can be carried in any bag if necessary esp if one adds removable pedals (eg. like the MKS ones)
To me, laziness is king.
More so in the tropical weather I'm in.
Stooped over to fix up the bike after a ride from home to the train station for example and I'd really not want to be sweating too much in the humidity and heat fixing up the BF.
Some people want bikes that fold great that happen to also be ride-able.
Different strokes....
#94
Senior Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 7,393
Likes: 10
From: Albany, WA
#95
Full Member
Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 382
Likes: 19
I don't see the attraction for this bike other than perhaps a BF ride feel.
Also, perhaps it makes sense for US folks as options for foldables are more limited as well as max weight concerns.
A CRIUS SMART is 7.6kg for the single sp and 8.6kg for the 3sp IGH.
Its fast to fold and easy to handle as its very light. (I have the 3.0)
Folded, it can be pushed around and it certainly can be carried in any bag if necessary esp if one adds removable pedals (eg. like the MKS ones)
To me, laziness is king.
More so in the tropical weather I'm in.
Stooped over to fix up the bike after a ride from home to the train station for example and I'd really not want to be sweating too much in the humidity and heat fixing up the BF.
Also, perhaps it makes sense for US folks as options for foldables are more limited as well as max weight concerns.
A CRIUS SMART is 7.6kg for the single sp and 8.6kg for the 3sp IGH.
Its fast to fold and easy to handle as its very light. (I have the 3.0)
Folded, it can be pushed around and it certainly can be carried in any bag if necessary esp if one adds removable pedals (eg. like the MKS ones)
To me, laziness is king.
More so in the tropical weather I'm in.
Stooped over to fix up the bike after a ride from home to the train station for example and I'd really not want to be sweating too much in the humidity and heat fixing up the BF.
I agree with Linberl--the Pakit is slightly oranges to Crius' apples.
#96
Full Member
Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 382
Likes: 19
Not sure why the bag size is an objection. Sure it's not the size of a backpack (which is unrealistic) but it was never said to be small. It's just smaller than most bike backpacks (assuming they exist). The point is the bike is quite light so toting it won't be a massive pain after a short while. Why would you care if the backpack is a bit larger than a big pack? As long as it doesn't snag on every pedestrian you pass... you might have a problem in a massively crowded place... just carry an open can of paint in each hand and you'll have bucketloads of room. 

#97
Senior Member

Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 3,541
Likes: 455
From: SF Bay Area
Bikes: Now: HPV Gecko FX 20 w/ assist.. Old: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
I'm thinking people would probably only use the bag if stowing it on a train, etc. It's so light, and grease-free, and the stem/seat connect instead of flopping around, so it would just be easier to quick fold and carry as is. that's what I do with my BF except I have a "shroud" to cover the wheels and chain to avoid grease and dirt, and that is not necessary here. For most people it would be a one-handed carrry, leaving one hand free. If you want both hands free I am sure you could get someone to sew a clip on the other long side of the bag and attach a shoulder strap. Would have been nice if BF had done that, giving some options for carrying, but maybe the weight shift is weird. Have to wait until some folks get them to see what works best.
#98
Sorry, not for me. The weight is fine, but I'm not going to be bothered fiddle faddling putting it together and taking it apart every time I make a stop. I agree, that the bike is probably built well, but for ease of use, there's nothing I've seen as yet that comes close to the Brompton. It folds fast and easy so I can go in an out of a store, train or whatever without messing with parts, especially it they are all wet and muddy.
#99
Senior Member

Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 3,541
Likes: 455
From: SF Bay Area
Bikes: Now: HPV Gecko FX 20 w/ assist.. Old: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
Sorry, not for me. The weight is fine, but I'm not going to be bothered fiddle faddling putting it together and taking it apart every time I make a stop. I agree, that the bike is probably built well, but for ease of use, there's nothing I've seen as yet that comes close to the Brompton. It folds fast and easy so I can go in an out of a store, train or whatever without messing with parts, especially it they are all wet and muddy.
Now, for a train where you have to stow it in the bag, it is a bit more complex. But not all commuters have that issue. And the Brompton does not offer 11 speeds nor a belt drive, AFAIK. It's all trade-offs for what matters to you.







