damage to aluminum frame okay to ride on ?
#1
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
From: Seattle, WA
Bikes: Cervelo S1, Giant OCR3
damage to aluminum frame okay to ride on ?
I think this is fine, but just checking if I should be more worried ...
I hit a sharp edged pretty decent size rock (6" x 3" maybe) which first gashed my tire and then bounced of the bottom of my frame and my shin.
The wheel seems untrued now, is it salvageable?
More of a concern is the the dent I saw in the frame. Is this any cause for concern, or should it be fine?
Thanks for any help!
IMG_0068..jpgIMG_0072..jpgIMG_0071..jpgIMG_0069..jpgIMG_0070..jpgIMG_0067..jpg
I hit a sharp edged pretty decent size rock (6" x 3" maybe) which first gashed my tire and then bounced of the bottom of my frame and my shin.
The wheel seems untrued now, is it salvageable?
More of a concern is the the dent I saw in the frame. Is this any cause for concern, or should it be fine?
Thanks for any help!
IMG_0068..jpgIMG_0072..jpgIMG_0071..jpgIMG_0069..jpgIMG_0070..jpgIMG_0067..jpg
#3
You should be fine riding on it for now, but keep your eye on it.
Aluminum does not like to be dented and it will eventually crack and fail. However, it will be a slower process, and the failure is unlikely to be catastrophic.
I dented an aluminum top tube about two months ago and kept riding and racing the frame. It developed a slight crack after a few weeks and the top tube started getting a little wavy looking - that's when I retired it.
If it were a steel frame, the dent would not be an issue.
Aluminum does not like to be dented and it will eventually crack and fail. However, it will be a slower process, and the failure is unlikely to be catastrophic.
I dented an aluminum top tube about two months ago and kept riding and racing the frame. It developed a slight crack after a few weeks and the top tube started getting a little wavy looking - that's when I retired it.
If it were a steel frame, the dent would not be an issue.
#4
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
From: Seattle, WA
Bikes: Cervelo S1, Giant OCR3
You should be fine riding on it for now, but keep your eye on it.
Aluminum does not like to be dented and it will eventually crack and fail. However, it will be a slower process, and the failure is unlikely to be catastrophic.
I dented an aluminum top tube about two months ago and kept riding and racing the frame. It developed a slight crack after a few weeks and the top tube started getting a little wavy looking - that's when I retired it.
If it were a steel frame, the dent would not be an issue.
Aluminum does not like to be dented and it will eventually crack and fail. However, it will be a slower process, and the failure is unlikely to be catastrophic.
I dented an aluminum top tube about two months ago and kept riding and racing the frame. It developed a slight crack after a few weeks and the top tube started getting a little wavy looking - that's when I retired it.
If it were a steel frame, the dent would not be an issue.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Bobray95
Classic and Vintage Bicycles: Whats it Worth? Appraisals.
4
07-10-16 08:07 PM






