Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Budget Hot or Not.... (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/793358-budget-hot-not.html)

WhyFi 02-24-14 08:27 PM


Originally Posted by kylecivicsi (Post 16523907)
Not sure if these belong here or not, but here is my new 2013 Giant Defy Advanced SL 1. Not much done to it, just a selle anatomica saddle and some shimano 105 carbon pedals. Just got my sidi's in the mail today, so I threw them in for good measure. Oh, and I got photo bombed while trying to take bike pics! She loves riding on the top tube while I'm putting in my trainer time :)

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=365898http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=365899

The seat tube/seat stays/top tube junction area looks all kinds of wonky to my eye. Why not carry the size and shape of the (integrated?) seat post all the way down to the BB?


Cute kid, though. ;)

kylecivicsi 02-24-14 08:42 PM


Originally Posted by WhyFi (Post 16524062)
The seat tube/seat stays/top tube junction area looks all kinds of wonky to my eye. Why not carry the size and shape of the (integrated?) seat post all the way down to the BB?


Cute kid, though. ;)

*supposedly* the shape of the seat post makes it more compliant, which helps dampen road vibration. Wether or not that is marketing hype, I don't know. I do know the ride is miles ahead of my aluminum frame defy. The harshness is greatly dampened.

side note: I'm thinking about adding lime green lizard skin bar tape. I can't decide if it would clash really hard or add something a little different. I know this thin fizik tape needs to go though. No cushion, and I don't wear gloves.

RPK79 02-24-14 10:02 PM


Originally Posted by kylecivicsi (Post 16524111)
*supposedly* the shape of the seat post makes it more compliant, which helps dampen road vibration. Wether or not that is marketing hype, I don't know. I do know the ride is miles ahead of my aluminum frame defy. The harshness is greatly dampened.

side note: I'm thinking about adding lime green lizard skin bar tape. I can't decide if it would clash really hard or add something a little different. I know this thin fizik tape needs to go though. No cushion, and I don't wear gloves.

Don't.

Frum 02-25-14 12:42 AM

3 Attachment(s)
The black bike is my commuter, which in the picture is running some bulky, knobby tires with fenders. Now that the snow is gone, it's running mudflaps and 700x23 slicks. 500 dollar bike. Second is my fun bike that I take on group rides, out for personal rides, and on longer trips. Apparently I need to change the bottle cages.

SpeshulEd 02-25-14 01:06 AM


Originally Posted by RPK79 (Post 16524321)
Don't.


Lizard skin bar tape is nice, but not green.

buffalowings 02-25-14 02:05 AM


Originally Posted by Frum (Post 16524548)
The black bike is my commuter, which in the picture is running some bulky, knobby tires with fenders. Now that the snow is gone, it's running mudflaps and 700x23 slicks. 500 dollar bike. Second is my fun bike that I take on group rides, out for personal rides, and on longer trips. Apparently I need to change the bottle cages.

Just throw on some elite custom race cages.

thirdgenbird 02-25-14 09:20 AM


Originally Posted by buffalowings (Post 16524634)
Just throw on some elite custom race cages.

exactly.

zymphad 02-25-14 09:42 AM


Originally Posted by mazdaspeed (Post 13868218)
This thread is fail, the bikes are too expensive. No under 1000 no care.

I thought it would be fun to see some cool looking bikes that I see 90% of people outside of 41 ride and are actually considered affordable. Bikes that if you used to commute and used daily and if it got stolen, you could replace again easily. I personally find bikes that people actually commute with every day far more interesting than some hyper expensive bike that is only ridden on only the nicest of days but would never dare to leave in public while at work or school etc.

This thread is filled with Cannondale Super Six, Litespeed Ti, deep rim Zipp wheels and custom built DT Swiss etc, SRAM Red drivetrain etc, it's stupid. Stupid stupid thread.

revchuck 02-25-14 10:12 AM

The above may be directed at me, since I posted a bike with those parts a while back. The DA7800 shifters were $125 used (and the matching RD was from a mixed DA/Ultegra drivetrain I bought for $100 from a friend), the wheels were $450 new and did come off another bike, and the FSA K-Light crankset was part of a trade...and the frame set was bought used. FWIW, the wheels are back on the original bike and have been replaced by a set of Open Pros with a Powertap rear and Ultegra front hub, but for a race bike with power, it still falls into "bargain" territory. :)

gsa103 02-25-14 10:19 AM


Originally Posted by zymphad (Post 16525260)
I thought it would be fun to see some cool looking bikes that I see 90% of people outside of 41 ride and are actually considered affordable. Bikes that if you used to commute and used daily and if it got stolen, you could replace again easily. I personally find bikes that people actually commute with every day far more interesting than some hyper expensive bike that is only ridden on only the nicest of days but would never dare to leave in public while at work or school etc.

This thread is filled with Cannondale Super Six, Litespeed Ti, deep rim Zipp wheels and custom built DT Swiss etc, SRAM Red drivetrain etc, it's stupid. Stupid stupid thread.

There's a version of this thread in the Commuter forums. I will agree the Budget thread is a little silly since it looks like the main HrN thread with "Hey look at the bike I just (figuratively) stole".

SpeshulEd 02-25-14 10:28 AM


Originally Posted by zymphad (Post 16525260)
I thought it would be fun to see some cool looking bikes that I see 90% of people outside of 41 ride and are actually considered affordable. Bikes that if you used to commute and used daily and if it got stolen, you could replace again easily. I personally find bikes that people actually commute with every day far more interesting than some hyper expensive bike that is only ridden on only the nicest of days but would never dare to leave in public while at work or school etc.

This thread is filled with Cannondale Super Six, Litespeed Ti, deep rim Zipp wheels and custom built DT Swiss etc, SRAM Red drivetrain etc, it's stupid. Stupid stupid thread.

There's not many of those bikes or components in the budget thread. And if you just want to look at commuters, then go to the commuting forum. Flatbar commuters don't really fit in the road bike forum.

RPK79 02-25-14 10:45 AM


Originally Posted by zymphad (Post 16525260)
I thought it would be fun to see some cool looking bikes that I see 90% of people outside of 41 ride and are actually considered affordable. Bikes that if you used to commute and used daily and if it got stolen, you could replace again easily. I personally find bikes that people actually commute with every day far more interesting than some hyper expensive bike that is only ridden on only the nicest of days but would never dare to leave in public while at work or school etc.

This thread is filled with Cannondale Super Six, Litespeed Ti, deep rim Zipp wheels and custom built DT Swiss etc, SRAM Red drivetrain etc, it's stupid. Stupid stupid thread.

My last submission was at or under $1,000 and the one before that was in the $500 range. I don't remember you giving either one a Hot (or a Not for that matter!).

daven 02-25-14 10:55 AM

As with every gear-based hobby, 'affordable' and 'budget' are only meaningful in context. If you want to see it get really silly, go read a copy of Stereophile!

WhyFi 02-25-14 11:03 AM


Originally Posted by zymphad (Post 16525260)
I thought it would be fun to see some cool looking bikes that I see 90% of people outside of 41 ride and are actually considered affordable. Bikes that if you used to commute and used daily and if it got stolen, you could replace again easily. I personally find bikes that people actually commute with every day far more interesting than some hyper expensive bike that is only ridden on only the nicest of days but would never dare to leave in public while at work or school etc.

Great, but that's not what this thread is about. Why not start the thread that you want to see rather than ***** that this thread isn't what you'd hoped?

SpeshulEd 02-25-14 01:35 PM

Or don't start a thread and just use the one that already exists:
http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread...r-Bicycle-Pics

goenrdoug 02-25-14 01:53 PM

Not to make any assumptions, but I don't think he's suggesting the idea of the commuter thread.

I know I've hesitated to post the budget bike I built for $600 in this thread along-side last-year's $1900 carbon bikes with Enve wheelsets and dura-ace componentry, etc.

While the $2000 number was arbitrarily picked (and it's about $1000 too high, IMO) it's the budget part that is the important piece to remember in here. This is not the overflow thread for the main hot-or-not thread. If one has a $1999 bike that isn't quite hot enough to make it in that thread, this isn't the place for it.

buffalowings 02-25-14 02:15 PM

$2000 is definitely on the higher end of things.. $1000 should be the max.. when I think budget, I think $500-1000, not $2k bikes with enve rims and ****

RPK79 02-25-14 02:26 PM


Originally Posted by buffalowings (Post 16526313)
$2000 is definitely on the higher end of things.. $1000 should be the max.. when I think budget, I think $500-1000, not $2k bikes with enve rims and ****

Considering what an entry level bike costs stock and also considering that stock is not Hot a $2,000 cap is not asking that much... In fact I seem to remember the cap being raised to $3,000 because $2,000 was unrealistic. If you have a less expensive bike and it is Hot post it.

This has already been hashed over. Post more bikes and quit complaining about what is or isn't "budget" in your mind.

WhyFi 02-25-14 02:27 PM

http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread...ke-do-you-have

SpeshulEd 02-25-14 03:00 PM


Originally Posted by goenrdoug (Post 16526236)
Not to make any assumptions, but I don't think he's suggesting the idea of the commuter thread.

I know I've hesitated to post the budget bike I built for $600 in this thread along-side last-year's $1900 carbon bikes with Enve wheelsets and dura-ace componentry, etc.

While the $2000 number was arbitrarily picked (and it's about $1000 too little high, IMO) it's the budget part that is the important piece to remember in here. This is not the overflow thread for the main hot-or-not thread. If one has a $1999 bike that isn't quite hot enough to make it in that thread, this isn't the place for it.


Originally Posted by buffalowings (Post 16526313)
$2000 is definitely on the higher end of things.. $1000 should be the max.. when I think budget, I think $500-1000, not $2k bikes with enve rims and ****

Can someone point me to all the bikes with enve wheels in this thread, I seem to have missed those?

Honestly, I look at this thread because I enjoy looking at bikes. If a bike is hot, it doesn't matter how much money was spent on it. I've seen plenty of cheaper bikes in the hot or not thread that have received "hots" - to me these threads are for posting your bike after you traded out some stock parts, shined it up and made it look nice, not necessarily for the "hey, I just bought this bike" posts.

goenrdoug 02-25-14 03:31 PM


Originally Posted by SpeshulEd (Post 16526430)
Can someone point me to all the bikes with enve wheels in this thread, I seem to have missed those?

Touche... I exaggerate. Ask my wife.


Honestly, I look at this thread because I enjoy looking at bikes.
Absolutely. I look at bike p*rn day and night and this thread, the similar thread in the century forum, the main hot-r-not, pinterest, various instagram folks, etc. are all great sources for a never-ending supply of bikes staged reasonably well and begging for my internet-based approval.

That being said, if the thread's supposed to be shooting for a particular flavor or idea, it's nice if the bikes posted within stick reasonably close to it. I wouldn't post my (hypothetical) new Pinarello with flamey blue paint and slammed geometry to the century bike thread... I dunno, maybe it's just my OCD.


And before anyone calls me out on it, I will go ahead and post my bike, now that I'm a newbie who's posting AGAIN in this thread without having posted a bike. Need to dial in the handlebar & hoods angle, though, before posting it...

bugly64 02-28-14 10:52 PM

Here's my new frame, that actually fits me. I have re-utilized all the parts from my last frame. The new frame is a Flyxii FLX-FR-322.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v3...ps9e7a1376.jpg

link0 03-01-14 04:41 AM

http://i.imgur.com/KVHgi3O.jpg

RPK79 03-01-14 08:24 AM


Originally Posted by bugly64 (Post 16537416)
Here's my new frame, that actually fits me. I have re-utilized all the parts from my last frame. The new frame is a Flyxii FLX-FR-322.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v3...ps9e7a1376.jpg

Hot.


Originally Posted by link0 (Post 16537741)

Warm. Not a fan of the tires, seat post, or bottle holder.

Both bikes are in the wrong gear!

celticfrost 03-01-14 06:33 PM

Camera acting like a POS. Anyway, my commuter:2002 Lemond Alpe d'Huez w/ assorted NOS and used Campy, Mavic, FIR, WTB, Ritchey, Maxxis, bits and pieces (aka, "budget" stuff). Don't hate on the hipster tires too much -- Maxxis Re-Fuse for $16 (only had white left in stock).

http://i81.photobucket.com/albums/j2...psb441dfbc.jpg
http://i81.photobucket.com/albums/j2...ps7d75dcb0.jpg


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:49 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.