Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Testing New Wheels (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/875335-testing-new-wheels.html)

bianchi10 03-20-13 05:22 PM


Originally Posted by Campag4life (Post 15411950)
don't you love the irony pdedes? Laughable.
The fredly guy making the request hasn't contributed one substantive post to the conversation and yet he has a vote.
Further, the OP agrees...the same OP that would be 'adrift at sea' without the contribution of those who have participated in the OT
sidebar. Classic.

lets clear that up. The only thing that i asked opinions on were the color choice of hubs. Everything else has been feedback from my experience with wheels I have tested or answered questions. The information that I get from jude has kept me within range of land and not floating out to anywhere. The majority of the participation in this thread has been derailing and non related. i have made my choices based off of what jude has recommended me. some of the comments have validated my choices and I certainly appreciate that feedback, but none of the commentary here was a deciding factor for me.

I <3 Robots 03-20-13 05:32 PM

How is this new set going to be different than the Boyds you have now? I don't see how much different they will be vs the Boyds...or am I missing something.

pdedes 03-20-13 05:33 PM


Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 15411985)
lets clear that up. The only thing that i asked opinions on were the color choice of hubs. Everything else has been feedback from my experience with wheels I have tested or answered questions. The information that I get from jude has kept me within range of land and not floating out to anywhere. The majority of the participation in this thread has been derailing and non related. i have made my choices based off of what jude has recommended me. some of the comments have validated my choices and I certainly appreciate that feedback, but none of the commentary here was a deciding factor for me.

And that's why your feedback is untrustworthy. But, your entertainment value isn't too ****ty.

bianchi10 03-20-13 05:35 PM


Originally Posted by I <3 Robots (Post 15412021)
How is this new set going to be different than the Boyds you have now? I don't see how much different they will be vs the Boyds...or am I missing something.

Wider rim, stiffer rim, different spoke count, different spoke, different hub.

Different in every way actually

WhyFi 03-20-13 05:39 PM


Originally Posted by pdedes (Post 15412025)
And that's why your feedback is untrustworthy. But, your entertainment value isn't too ****ty.

Wait - what? You expect him to give more weight to the anonymous online opinions of Tweedledumb and Tweedledumber, rather than that of a well-respected local wheel builder?

bianchi10 03-20-13 05:40 PM


Originally Posted by pdedes (Post 15412025)
And that's why your feedback is untrustworthy. But, your entertainment value isn't too ****ty.

I am assuming that isnt meant to be a compliment.

How the hell did this thread turn into this?

Campag4life 03-20-13 05:41 PM


Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 15411985)
lets clear that up. The only thing that i asked opinions on were the color choice of hubs. Everything else has been feedback from my experience with wheels I have tested or answered questions. The information that I get from jude has kept me within range of land and not floating out to anywhere. The majority of the participation in this thread has been derailing and non related. i have made my choices based off of what jude has recommended me. some of the comments have validated my choices and I certainly appreciate that feedback, but none of the commentary here was a deciding factor for me.

A startling revelation. Thanks for sharing.
In that case...I vote pink for your hub color. :)

Campag4life 03-20-13 05:42 PM


Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 15412053)
I am assuming that isnt meant to be a compliment.

How the hell did this thread turn into this?

Quick...somebody hand Nick a mirror.

I <3 Robots 03-20-13 05:43 PM

I see that its physically different...but the ride? Are you flexing the Boyd enough to tell the difference?

Don't mean to question your decision...just want to see why. Seems you're making sort of a sideways move.

Campag4life 03-20-13 05:45 PM


Originally Posted by WhyFi (Post 15412044)
Wait - what? You expect him to give more weight to the anonymous online opinions of Tweedledumb and Tweedledumber, rather than that of a well-respected local wheel builder?

Good point. But you shouldn't be so hard on yourself. :)

dtrain 03-20-13 05:49 PM


Originally Posted by I <3 Robots (Post 15412065)
I see that its physically different...but the ride? Are you flexing the Boyd enough to tell the difference?

Don't mean to question your decision...just want to see why. Seems you're making sort of a sideways move.

What a touch stiffer wouldn't be worth the roughly $700 difference to you? ;)

JoelS 03-20-13 05:53 PM


Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 15412053)
I am assuming that isnt meant to be a compliment.

How the hell did this thread turn into this?

It's the 41. Every thread turns into this. IMO, it's rather unfortunate as there are a lot of folks happy to share knowledge they've gleaned. But it gets difficult to find the signal when you have to sort through all the noise.

JoelS 03-20-13 05:54 PM


Originally Posted by dtrain (Post 15412086)
What a touch stiffer wouldn't be worth the roughly $700 difference to you? ;)

For some, not for others. YMMV

bikerjp 03-20-13 05:57 PM

For fun I put my C2/CK wheels on my caad today. They have blue hubs to go with bike they were intended for but I wanted to see what colored hubs would look like. Alos was curious if they felt different on caad - they didn't really. Maybe one ride is hard to tell but also possible that two sets of well built alloy wheels aren't going to be much different.

Anyway, here's a pic. Maybe not the best color for that bike but at least not black. Maybe some cages with blue or something else with blue would help. Curious to see what Bianchi goes with.

https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-q...9/caadc2ck.jpg

I <3 Robots 03-20-13 06:00 PM


Originally Posted by dtrain (Post 15412086)
What a touch stiffer wouldn't be worth the roughly $700 difference to you? ;)

Thats like me getting rid of my 404's for a pair of Enves and saying that the Enves are more aero. :P

bianchi10 03-20-13 06:10 PM

There was nothing "wrong" with the boyds. After riding on other wheels I realized that a 20/24 spoke is flexy for my weight. It wasn't necessary to get new wheels, but i wanted to. I was able to feel a worthwhile difference between the boyds I had and the newer wheels that had a higher spoke count which felt stiffer. Also preferred the feel of the 23mm wide rim.

Grambo 03-20-13 06:15 PM

Blue hubs look good with your all black rig. Blue seat post collar, CK blue headset and blue bar tape to finish it off. just my 2 cents.



'

Originally Posted by bikerjp (Post 15412125)
For fun I put my C2/CK wheels on my caad today. They have blue hubs to go with bike they were intended for but I wanted to see what colored hubs would look like. Alos was curious if they felt different on caad - they didn't really. Maybe one ride is hard to tell but also possible that two sets of well built alloy wheels aren't going to be much different.

Anyway, here's a pic. Maybe not the best color for that bike but at least not black. Maybe some cages with blue or something else with blue would help. Curious to see what Bianchi goes with.

https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-q...9/caadc2ck.jpg


Bob Dopolina 03-20-13 06:19 PM

[QUOTE=Grambo;15412185]Blue hubs look good with your all black rig. Blue seat post collar, CK blue headset and blue bar tape to finish it off. just my 2 cents./QUOTE]

Too matcha, matchy. That's why I suggested the blue bar tape as a complimentary colour to the MANGO hubs.

OP the offer still stands on the free blue tape if you go MANGO and want to check it out.

DaveWC 03-20-13 06:30 PM


Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 15412164)
There was nothing "wrong" with the boyds. After riding on other wheels I realized that a 20/24 spoke is flexy for my weight. It wasn't necessary to get new wheels, but i wanted to. I was able to feel a worthwhile difference between the boyds I had and the newer wheels that had a higher spoke count which felt stiffer. Also preferred the feel of the 23mm wide rim.

Don't get caught up in justifying your reasons for wanting new gear. Your input to this thread is the reason most tuned in. If nothing else, the diversion into the details of wheelbuilding in the last few pages shows why you're not buying tools and building the wheels yourself. You won't please everyone on these threads, so please yourself.

WhyFi 03-20-13 06:30 PM


Originally Posted by Campag4life (Post 15412072)
Good point. But you shouldn't be so hard on yourself. :)

Ohhhh - the burn of the "I know you are, but what am I?" comeback.

bianchi10 03-20-13 06:32 PM


Originally Posted by DaveWC (Post 15412250)
Don't get caught up in justifying your reasons for wanting new gear. Your input to this thread is the reason most tuned in. If nothing else, the diversion into the details of wheelbuilding in the last few pages shows why you're not buying tools and building the wheels yourself. You won't please everyone on these threads, so please yourself.

thanks Dave. i appreciate it.

bikerjp 03-20-13 07:05 PM


Originally Posted by Bob Dopolina (Post 15412199)

Originally Posted by Grambo (Post 15412185)
Blue hubs look good with your all black rig. Blue seat post collar, CK blue headset and blue bar tape to finish it off. just my 2 cents.

Too matcha, matchy. That's why I suggested the blue bar tape as a complimentary colour to the MANGO hubs.

OP the offer still stands on the free blue tape if you go MANGO and want to check it out.

So with blue hubs should I get mango bar tape?

bianchi10 03-20-13 07:49 PM

Edited

rpenmanparker 03-20-13 08:09 PM


Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 15412560)
I dont know if this was already assumed, but if not, this might change some of the opinions?

I asked jude again about the spokes and she said that this super spoke that I'm getting is one that most people confuse with the non bladed super. There is also a bladed super version which is also called the super sapim spoke but stronger than the "classic" super.

Was everyone basing their opinions on the non bladed super?

OP, you should have just let it lie. This is just going to start the whole thing all over again.

The aero spokes are made by rolling out the round ones. So Lasers become C X-Rays and regular Supers become aero Supers. And as we said earlier, stronger (which I don't think changes) doesn't affect stiffness anyway. Finally, how tight you can make a spoke doesn't affect stiffness, but even if it did, spoke tension is usually limited by rim strength, not spoke strength. Really, it is just like in that recent movie, Best Exotic Marigold Hotel: "Everything will be alright in the end. If it is not alright, it is because this isn't the end." Jude has a good reputation as a wheel builder, not a civil engineer. Those two thing are not mutually exclusive, but the former doesn't require the latter either. She doesn't have to get this stuff right. We only fixate on it because we are nerds.

Like I said: Give it a rest. Everything will be fine.

JoelS 03-20-13 08:16 PM

Note: It takes more than 1 to give it a rest.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:33 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.