Is raw milk better for you?
#26
Faster but still slow
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 5,978
Likes: 2
From: Jersey
Bikes: Trek 830 circa 1993 and a Fuji WSD Finest 1.0 2006
From what I recall pasturization was developed by Louis Pasteur for the brewing industry. Exploding bottles wasn't desirable.
The problem with you is that you make blanket statements that processing(whatever that means) is all bad all the time. Life isn't that simple.
One could say that ingesting cow milk is unnatural. There are tons of arguments against it. Frankly I am surprised you would drink milk at all.
Raw milk isn't bad and it isn't good. You must have impecable technique and instruments and you will likely be fine. But simply heating milk to 160 degrees is not bad either. Do you cook with milk? Do you cook food at all? If you think pasteurization is wrong, then all cooking is wrong. Have fun with your raw chicken.
#27
the consumption of dairy has stood the test of time of being one of the most important foods for mankind. We would be seriously malnourished without it and probably wouldn't have spread as far as we have. Cheese making was an early form of food preservation and many people would have starved to death over winters without it.
Now after many eons of milk consumption all of a sudden in the last 60-70 years AFTER the intoduction of pasturization some people have become lactose intolerent. Does the mainstream blame pasturization for this?
Absolutely not! It must be that milk is just bad for human consumption despite thousands of years of human consumption and the new proccessing techniques that came just before the spread of lactose intolerence are blameless. Right
Regards, Anthony
Now after many eons of milk consumption all of a sudden in the last 60-70 years AFTER the intoduction of pasturization some people have become lactose intolerent. Does the mainstream blame pasturization for this?
Absolutely not! It must be that milk is just bad for human consumption despite thousands of years of human consumption and the new proccessing techniques that came just before the spread of lactose intolerence are blameless. Right
Regards, Anthony
#28
Originally Posted by AnthonyG
Now after many eons of milk consumption all of a sudden in the last 60-70 years AFTER the intoduction of pasturization some people have become lactose intolerent. Does the mainstream blame pasturization for this?
Do some research on a site the isnt weston price. You'll see that lactose intolerance is not some 'new' disease that has suddenly occured after pasturization was introduced. In fact its the norm.
#29
Originally Posted by Jarery
Do you just make this crap up?
Do some research on a site the isnt weston price. You'll see that lactose intolerance is not some 'new' disease that has suddenly occured after pasturization was introduced. In fact its the norm.
Do some research on a site the isnt weston price. You'll see that lactose intolerance is not some 'new' disease that has suddenly occured after pasturization was introduced. In fact its the norm.
As ugly as this sounds natural selection may have played a role here. In wheat dominant societies such as the middle east children who are gluten intolerent die in their childhood years. Gluten intolerence is still reasonable common in European societies where other staples exist. In dairy dominant cultures lactose intolerence would be rare however I don't think that lactose intolerence has the same deadly consequenses as gluten intolerence does.
Regards, Anthony
#31
Originally Posted by IronMac
Lactose intolerance is the norm across East Asia.
I am from a mostly Northern European background. My brother and I get it from our mom, who is completely Northern European. I'm not severely lactose intolerant, and my symptoms are nearly nonexistant when consuming unpasteurized dairy products. I suspect I still produce a little lactase and the beneficial flora in raw dairy products aid the lactose breakdown process somehow. I wonder if raw dairy products would make any difference to someone more intolerant. Somehow, I doubt it.
#33
Originally Posted by AnthonyG
the consumption of dairy has stood the test of time of being one of the most important foods for mankind. We would be seriously malnourished without it and probably wouldn't have spread as far as we have. Cheese making was an early form of food preservation and many people would have starved to death over winters without it.
Now after many eons of milk consumption all of a sudden in the last 60-70 years AFTER the intoduction of pasturization some people have become lactose intolerent. Does the mainstream blame pasturization for this?
Absolutely not! It must be that milk is just bad for human consumption despite thousands of years of human consumption and the new proccessing techniques that came just before the spread of lactose intolerence are blameless. Right
Regards, Anthony
Now after many eons of milk consumption all of a sudden in the last 60-70 years AFTER the intoduction of pasturization some people have become lactose intolerent. Does the mainstream blame pasturization for this?
Absolutely not! It must be that milk is just bad for human consumption despite thousands of years of human consumption and the new proccessing techniques that came just before the spread of lactose intolerence are blameless. Right
Regards, Anthony
Pasteurized milk is to blame for childhood autism though, right?
__________________
www.marrow.org
www.marrow.org
#34
Nah, childhood autism comes from the mercury preservative in vaccines.
I accept that south eastern Asians maybe by and large lactose intolerent but then the northern asians such as the Mongolians are a culture that thrives on dairy don't they.
I have for a number of years removed dairy and wheat/gluten from my diet and was much healthier without them. I was however very ill with very poor bowel function and both dairy and wheat are hard to digest so only having easy to digest foods assisted greatly. As I've slowly healed I can digest dairy and wheat much better than I used to be able to so I am very slowly re introducing them. I still avoid over proccessed dairy and I don't drink regular store milk but I do have access to raw jersey milk which is much easier to digest as far as I'm concerned. I realy crave dairy fat and it feels right to me however I am still struggling to get my magnesium/calcium levels/balance sorted out so dairy is a rare indulgence for me at the moment. The point of the story I guess is that I can vouch for raw dairy being easier to digest than pasturized/proccessed dairy.
Regards, Anthony
I accept that south eastern Asians maybe by and large lactose intolerent but then the northern asians such as the Mongolians are a culture that thrives on dairy don't they.
I have for a number of years removed dairy and wheat/gluten from my diet and was much healthier without them. I was however very ill with very poor bowel function and both dairy and wheat are hard to digest so only having easy to digest foods assisted greatly. As I've slowly healed I can digest dairy and wheat much better than I used to be able to so I am very slowly re introducing them. I still avoid over proccessed dairy and I don't drink regular store milk but I do have access to raw jersey milk which is much easier to digest as far as I'm concerned. I realy crave dairy fat and it feels right to me however I am still struggling to get my magnesium/calcium levels/balance sorted out so dairy is a rare indulgence for me at the moment. The point of the story I guess is that I can vouch for raw dairy being easier to digest than pasturized/proccessed dairy.
Regards, Anthony
#35
unbent
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
From: Kalamazoo, Michigan
Bikes: Currently an EZ-1 Supercruiser
#36
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 800
Likes: 4
From: Portland, OR
Originally Posted by unbent
But whats in a real world example as stated above? Just as long as the billboards/government is saying "DRINK MILK" (funded by the pasturized diary industry) thats good enough right...
By the way, I had some raw milk that had been left in a cool cupboard for 4 months, tasted like really strong/sour yoghurt.
#37
Faster but still slow
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 5,978
Likes: 2
From: Jersey
Bikes: Trek 830 circa 1993 and a Fuji WSD Finest 1.0 2006
Now after many eons of milk consumption all of a sudden in the last 60-70 years AFTER the intoduction of pasturization some people have become lactose intolerent. Does the mainstream blame pasturization for this?
#38
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 800
Likes: 4
From: Portland, OR
Originally Posted by slowandsteady
.... Lactobacillus acidophilus daily.
I agree with you though, lot of benefits from active cultures. If your going to eat pasturized dairy, high quality yoghurt is the best way. The greek yoghurt is great stuff, good substitute for sourcream as well-
#39
Faster but still slow
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 5,978
Likes: 2
From: Jersey
Bikes: Trek 830 circa 1993 and a Fuji WSD Finest 1.0 2006
Occurs naturally in raw milk....funny how man trys to imitate nature by adding lacto acidophilus to pasturized milk.
I agree with you though, lot of benefits from active cultures. If your going to eat pasturized dairy, high quality yoghurt is the best way. The greek yoghurt is great stuff, good substitute for sourcream as well-
I agree with you though, lot of benefits from active cultures. If your going to eat pasturized dairy, high quality yoghurt is the best way. The greek yoghurt is great stuff, good substitute for sourcream as well-
Salmonella
Rabies
E. coli
Listeria
Various Streptococcus and Staphylococcus bac-t
numerous other pathogens
#40
Originally Posted by slowandsteady
Do you know what else can occur naturally in raw milk?
Salmonella
Rabies
E. coli
Listeria
Various Streptococcus and Staphylococcus bac-t
numerous other pathogens
Salmonella
Rabies
E. coli
Listeria
Various Streptococcus and Staphylococcus bac-t
numerous other pathogens
So, what we need are the facts and not the scare tactics. Do you have a reference?
Oh and bacteria ARE NOT pathogens. Its not that simple.
Regards, Anthony
#41
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 800
Likes: 4
From: Portland, OR
Originally Posted by slowandsteady
Do you know what else can occur naturally in raw milk?
Salmonella
Rabies
E. coli
Listeria
Various Streptococcus and Staphylococcus bac-t
numerous other pathogens
Salmonella
Rabies
E. coli
Listeria
Various Streptococcus and Staphylococcus bac-t
numerous other pathogens
Of course in rare circumstances, the way I unsderstand it, if the 'bad' bacteria overwhelms the good stuff, then a person could get sick. We are talking SEVERLY contaminated. Just like regular milk can make you sick, if its not properly cared for.
What is your take on steak joints that serve rare steaks or sushi places with all the sashimi?
Are they out to get us! They have the possibility of all the same contamination as you stated above-
#44
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 800
Likes: 4
From: Portland, OR
Originally Posted by UmneyDurak
Yeah, but life expectancy was much shorter and death rate much higher.
Most of the people that are 'old' (what your basing your point on) grew up with the raw milks, butters and high cholesterol foods in the early 1900's. Maybe in 50-70 years you will have an argument, because that will show what type of impact all the synthetic foods have of today. From the looks of it though (the obesity epidemic) our life spans will be going back down.
Modern medicine that was started in the early 1900's by William Welch has alot to do with lifespans. Prior to him the human body and viruses were not clearly understood. Prior to these medical breakthroughs, doctors were sometimes more dangerous than the disease itself. Morphine overdose was quite common.
So again, all the 80/90 year olds have Mr. Welch to thank for part of their lifespan, the other part has to do with the whole foods they grew up eating...all whole foods with no synthetic agents.
I am not an advocate of current medical practices, I dont get flu shots, I dont take medicine and I dont get sick. I believe alot of medicine has harmed us more than it has helped. Naturopaths are the way to go, something the chinese have known for a long time-




